Meh, I didn't love it but I didn't hate it. I was a little disappointed with Renly's death. I was expecting more killing and anguish over him from Loras. I didn't expect the two Reeds to make it into the series but I was hoping that they might consolidate the both of them into one at the least. I'd give it an overall 8 because it still was incredibly good even with all my little nitpicks!