Diehard_si

You never seen Braveheart?? In fact my only criticism was that the battle seemed to copy 3 main war movies. That one, 300 for the 'Spartan shield' and Lord of the Rings... The Vale arriving like the riders of Rohan.

The stupid tactics were part of the plot. He lost his head against his sisters advice. Sansa really won the day, Jon has a lot to learn still ( an upgrade at least from knowing nothing ). IMO a 10.

Always love a good laugh at this forum once a week. The so called 'fans' voting their favorite show 1 out of 10 thinking they are cool giving it the lowest score ever. I think the only episode to be below a 6 should be unbowed, unbent unbroken which was very poor, but if you are giving any of the others below this then I think you should stop watching as the show really isn;t for you.

A great episode... if you didn't like this one, then I guess the show isn't for you.

8 It was on for a 9 until the Dorne scene. A solid start.

I imagine she could sacrifice herself to save Jon.

perhaps, and if I could have given it 9.5 I would have, but I round up.

I feel sorry for some of you. You're so far gone in your hatred of any slight variance to the books you are missing a TV spectacle. Seriously if you gave this a 1 just stop watching it's clearly not the show for you. Voted 10,the Arya going blind scene and the Dornish scenes were the only weak bits.the rest was great.

I wasn't keen on the Jason and the Argonauts scene, the lack of LS and Coldhands. Tyrions seemed a bit rushed and somehow the drama of his actions lost. Again the Stannis scene just seemed to happen with no sense of relief for the watch or emotion. The events just happened on screen and it wasn't captivating. I might have enjoyed this were my expectations not so high. I expected this to be the best episode of any TV show ever, but it just didn't work. Normally I look on here just for a quick guide as to how the episode will be as I'm in the UK and watch a day late. I normally ignore the generally snobby and overly picky comments, but for once I'm forces to agree with some. A 7 from me

9 for me. The Yara scene was a bit daft and I wasn't overly keen on the Stannis scene. The trial was however great and the hall at Meereen was pretty much exactly as I'd pictured it in my head. Peter Dinklage was absolutely superb though. Not sure on the guy place Mace though, he seems weak

Amazing episode. I've not seen twitter and Facebook explode like that over a drama before. That's normally saved for footy or reality TV events. It was different, but just as chilling. I sat there in silence for about 25 mins after. Everyone wants to talk about it. 10

6 Worst episode of the series. Don't even think I'll bother watching it again. Didn't like Mel turning up for Gendry and the Meera and Osha scene was pointless. Wall climb was great tho.

An 8. Season 2 frustrated me. I'm trying hard to be more open minded in the adaption now. There are annoyances but tying to see through them. It's a near impossible job to get these books on screen and overall they are doing a damn good job. No one is going to do any better, put it that way.