JonCon's Red Beard

Because the name of the thread is "EP510 Discussion". It's for discuss the show. :dunno:

You think Vikings or Black Sails are bad shows?

A war they already lost. They have Trystane. Is Doran going to attack KL when they have Trystane? Why? To let the Martells without an heir? In a war they cannot win? :dunno:

And how the F Varys managed to get into a pyramid? Wouldn't the Unsullied be all red alert? Did he say "I'm friends with the imp" and the Unsullied said "ah, ok!". :dunno:

The biggest plothole is that Ellaria is ok with Trystane being killed, apparently.

I wish people stop saying "I like the show because it's better than wait ten years for Martin!" It's like saying "my boyfriend beats me but it's ok because at least I have a boyfriend". People, have some respect. Have some standards.

IN A WORLD WHERE THINGS MAKE SENSE, yes, Jon/Kit would return. Then, this show... But seriously, let's say Jon doesn't return next season. Who is fighting the Others? Mel? Davos? Olly? :dunno:

More people is actually acknowledging this season was very bad, even "important" critics. Some people watch it because they enjoy it and don't want to make a big deal about it, that's fine. Some others defend the show in a way that is making me believe HBO has specifically sent them to do that (I mean, if political groups do that in FB, twitter and similar, why not here?). Because one thing is to say "yeah, I enjoyed the show" and another one "you all are wrong! the show is good!!". I mean, look at what I've said before. people can't get enough of the all "Feast and Dance are bad because they left everything unresolved!" rant, yet, this season has ended IN THE SAME WAY with mostly of the characters they hate in F and D having WORST plots. The only "resolutions" we're having are things we already know would happen: Stannis never gets to the throne, Myrcella dies (as Tommen will) and... that's it.

I can't believe I'm gonna say this... but Dany's scene was great BECAUSE SHE DIDN'T FUCKING TALK.

You know, in the episode, Jon gets killed because he favoured the wildlings. Just like in the books. Yet, it feels so so so so so so so so so so so so different. This is what happens when you change EVERYTHING preceding the scenes and insist on make the book scenes. This is for those who keep saying "you book readers just are pissed they make everything different!" Every scene of this episode WAS FROM THE BOOKS. But they simply tossed them in the episode without any context or motivation. I'll say it again People jump from their seats when the player runs through the goal to score, because they don't know whether he might or might not do it. That's what moves them. Not the score itself. They celebrate or rage about the resolution of the play, but it's the play what gives them feelings.

Yes. As Olly.

BTW, Ellaria's incredibly idea was to also get Trystane killed, right? Because there is no way Jaime won't realise this has been the Dornish idea. Unless he goes fully stupid and say "I know you didn't because you loved her". I take back what I said: I'm GLAD Aimee is not involved in this fucking mess. She deserves better.

Something within my mind actually believes some people is getting paid to rank the episode above 7...

Kit is having a laugh in that whole interview... :rolleyes:

The board ate my post, fuck. Whatever... all Stannis fans come here for your hug. You deserve it, guys... (the hug, not the butchering of the character).

The scene itself was good. The whole thing was a mess.

BTW... whatever happened with the final scene of the book?

I give a 2. I was going to give a 1 but I kinda liked the Ramsay's fanboyish glorification scene battle against Stannis.

Olly survived the show but not Stannis L O L

The season ends in a lot of cliffhangers. Just like AFFC/ADWD The books you hate... because they end in a lot of cliffhangers :lol: :lmao:

For the watch---ers who want blood and tits and gore...

Mel, please go and kill yourself.

I don't think the Cersei scene is ok. The walk is there because it's in the book, not because it makes sense.

You killed Stannis! Shame! Shame!!!

Hacks! Hacks! Hacks! Shame!!! *throw poop*