Sir Noone Sword Of The Day

I have to agree that Michele Fairley's performance was awesome she really made the episode even though Catelyn is one of my least favorite characters. 10/10

Good episode though the Melisandre f***ing Gendry was just another example of how much the show over-exaggerates the sex in the series, can't say im complaining a huge amount though.

everything was good in this episode except it lacked a great moment like the previous episode... still good though so 8/10

I didn't like it much... They claimed that Loras was the heir to Highgarden... no mention of Garlan or Willas. I'm starting to hate the QOT arrogance. IMO she didn't feature that much in the book (only as much as oberyn IMO) and her role is being over exaggerated a little. I didn't mind the whole Gendry thing, I thought it was a smart idea in replacement for Edric Storm (another character to confuse the viewers), however again Arya is starting to annoy me a bit with her antics... someone gag her already. Mel talking to Arya about the 'darkness within her' was good as well in replacement of the old lady on the hill. I'm Still perplexed as to how they are going to solve the whole Tormund going over the wall. He is one of my favorite characters and his portrayal has been great in the TV show. Also only 4 managed to get over the wall (from what we saw) so unless they make more come over later than i am wondering how the battle of castle black will happen. So many changes in this episode IMO and flaws in story's so i didn't like it much

Great episode, but doesn't Sansa realize that she can't marry Loras, because he is in the Kingsguard??

I agree with this, i hate TV shae more than book shae, These seens are for fans of Peter Dinklage because in the third book he doesn't do much really until the 'purple wedding', so i think they are just filling his screen time with crap to satisfy the Dinklage fans

i voted 6 maybe a bit harsh, but i still thought the episode was good... just not that good, plus I'm rather disappointing with how the season has started so far, i think its just because whats to come is so epic and i have to wait a week for each episode

I thought it was a solid start, a nice building block. I'm just so bloody excited for the rest of the season though, there are so many scenes that i want to see so to have to wait another whole week for the next episode is a killing me. plus this episode didn't reveal the epicness that is going to happen, which i suppose is good for non book fans, didn't expect to see giants though which was cool and of course the dragons looked awesome