Jump to content

dawgs4ever

Members
  • Posts

    1
  • Joined

  • Last visited

dawgs4ever's Achievements

Commoner

Commoner (1/8)

  1. Didn't feel like the RW was epic enough or had enough build up. Should've been more sense of impending doom that Robb and others were foolishly ignorant of, like in the book. Should've been more greatjon and more actual fighting rather than just a slaughter. The feast hall wasn't nearly as big as I pictured in my head when reading that story either. Didn't like how Greywind was handled at all. Should've had him howling early on and had him chained up outside where he could at least do a little damage before dying. Greywind going out like that seemed like a really pathetic and lazy adaptation, IMHO. The Danaerys scenes were ok, but the capturing of the city was really meh. Having guards just randomly come out in huge numbers from out of nowhere.. makes no sense.. silly scene, even though it was nice to see the different types of combat on display. Also agree with others that the Hound/Arya scenes at the end could have been more dramatic. Arya wasn't nearly as "urgent" as she should have been trying to get into the camp once she figured out what was going on. And the Hound should've had to cleave a few folks while chasing after her. Despite all of that, though, I still gave it an 8. Powerful stuff. Just could have been, and deserved to be, so much more powerful.
×
×
  • Create New...