Jump to content

Chebyshov

Members
  • Posts

    5,116
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Chebyshov

  1. See, that's what bothers me. While I couldn't see the gem missing, it was obvious what she was doing. To the point that none of Tyrions interactions with the cup are done in a way where he could have poisoned it. I mean, the first pour is in front of Tywin & Cersei, the 2nd in front of everyone. There's no ambiguity with the way it was done.

    I don't think there's supposed to be. But also keep in mind we knew what to look for going in.

  2. Not enough visually to go on.

    The jewel on the far left could also be missing since it's obscured - so it looks like the necklace could just not have been made with gems on either side.

    I think it's enough to go on...especially because then as Olenna is walking to her seat, you hear an audible "plink" right as she passes Margery. The only thing that I can't find is Margery slipping into Joff's cup, but we see her handle his cup right before he cuts the cake, and she was sitting next to him all wedding. I haven't had time for a proper rewatch yet, so maybe it's in there somewhere.

    I doubt the Unsullied caught any of this, which is why I'm assuming next episode it will be made explicit.

  3. Since Locke does not exist in the book I think either D&D outlined for George or D&D flat wrote that scene.

    D&D inserted a scene in Blackwater that GRRM said he didn't write.

    Can't now figure out what Locke's plot purpose is?

    He going to the most dangerous place , Castle Black, in Westeros at the worst time.

    I am guessing the Wilding crew south of Wall are going to kill him and his party.

    I assumed they were setting up his rendezvous with Brienne. I'd guess she'd bite his ear.

  4. You are right, Newstar, with your answer.

    Would Shae have listened if once again Tyrion had talked about the danger?

    And the way Tyrion did this it would have been easier for her to forget faithless Tyrion in the future, not the concerned lover sacrificing his happiness for her safety but the arrogant nobleman sending his whore away. I guess once again Tyrion was thinking around one corner too much with his attempt at being evil.

    And now we will see an Othello-like tragical misunderstanding when Shae dies, making Tyrion maybe darker than in the books because he won't listen when he should have??

    I tremendously enjoyed Margaery!

    You could see everything, everything in her face, disgust, false laughter, attempt at distraction and worry. That so very clever young woman! Dorner was extraordinary, just like Diana Rigg!

    And I really loved Turner. I have not been a fan of Sansa so far but Turner's acting in the two first episodes has impressed me and starts to win me over for Sansa. She has a brain, she is furious, she makes her standpoint clear, is full of pity and now her play shows that she has a clear understanding of the subtleties and power games that are going on. "And now we have a new Queen", her voice got so wonderfully cynical. Her face showed every memory of her father's beheading at the dwarf jousting and shame about Tyrion's treatment.

    And the solidarity she showed to Tyrion when she passed the goblet, two victims of Joffrey and yet proud, full of understanding for each other, great acting.

    I was just about to sing praises to Natalie Dorner. Absolutely fantastic in this episode.

    As for Sansa, I'm glad she and Tyrion had a slightly nice last moment (her handing him the cup). It was a good conclusion for them, and went along with the whole Show!Sansa bending at the wedding.

  5. I understand why they changed most of the things, including Sir Illyn, but two things I don't get:

    1) Why Melisandre was burning Ser Axell Florent, instead of Ser Alester, and why he suddenly became Selyse's brother. Also, Stannis didn't command his death because he was a sinner (which would make him more of a fanatic), but because he tries to negotiate a peace treaty with Tywin Lannister behind Stannis' back.

    2) Why Lady Olenna doesn't put her hands on Sansa's necklace, to remove one of the gems, possibly containing the poison that killed Joffrey.

    Number 1 who knows, but number 2 she does. Just rewatch...the far right jewel is missing and you can see Olenna briefly touch it

  6. I also have to remark that the Ramsey and Roose scene was nicely done. I was wary about spending so much time at the Dreadfort, but I liked it.

    It was, but I'm confused about Myranda. She was one of the girls from Theon's castration scene last year, but she can't be the same Myranda who's friends with Mya Stone, right?

  7. There's plenty of time to establish the fact that Sansa's necklace played a role in the murder. I don't see why D&D wouldn't do that. In the books it happened shortly after the wedding, so I'm hoping next week Sansa tells Dontos that the necklace is missing a stone.

    That plus the preview showed a scene between Margery and Olenna clearly discussing the poisoning. I'm guessing they might just be explicit about it there so the audience knows Tyrion is innocent

×
×
  • Create New...