Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

RhaenysBee

Non-ASOIAF Elimination Game XXIV - Best Animated Movie

Recommended Posts

Which in my opnion is jumping the gun. Whenever games are started that quickly, we seem to get a few posts asking, why is Item A not here. That's usually an indication that not everyone had a chance to look at the list. It doesn't have to be as an involved process, but I'm just thinking that more time would have helped create a better list.

I'm sorry you weren't able to have a look at the list before the new game started. Next time we will wait some days before posting the new thread or just start voting threads here too, if that's what the majority would like to see so we can have a perfect list. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm sorry you weren't able to have a look at the list before the new game started. Next time we will wait some days before posting the new thread or just start voting threads here too, if that's what the majority would like to see so we can have a perfect list. :)

i fail to see the point really , someone will always be unhappy , the list is fine . we shouldn't take the EG so seriously . but yes we did start really fast but i hardly find all these complaints to be necessary . :dunno: and yes i am mostly just grumpy because you tasteless bastards killed my fireflies :bawl:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 4
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 9 +
5. Monsters Inc. 5
6. How To Train Your Dragon 7
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 10
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
19. The Hunchback of Notre Dame 1 -
21. Mulan 3
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 3-
26. The Jungle Book 5
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 7
29. Wall-E 15

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 4
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 9
5. Monsters Inc. 6+
6. How To Train Your Dragon 7
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 10
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
19. The Hunchback of Notre Dame 0 -
21. Mulan 3
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 3
26. The Jungle Book 5
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 7
29. Wall-E 15

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 4
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 9
5. Monsters Inc. 6+
6. How To Train Your Dragon 7
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 10
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
21. Mulan 4+
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 2-
26. The Jungle Book 5
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 7
29. Wall-E 15

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 4
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 9
5. Monsters Inc. 6
6. How To Train Your Dragon 7
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 10
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 4-
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
21. Mulan 4
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 2
26. The Jungle Book 5
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 7
29. Wall-E 16+

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly I think you guys posted this a little too quickly. Because I'm wondering what you guys did with Beauty and the Beast. The one animated film nominated for Best Picture.

As for the final list, on the ASOIF side, we've been letting everyone vote on what they want to take off, then tallying the votes. Whichever entries had the most votes, were the ones that got taken off.

Lord Lyman, before we had three threads for asoiaf EG, EGs worked like this. People nominated stuff at the end of the previous thread and when we had 30 we posted the new thread. Nobody even nominated Beauty and the Beast. If you guys think we put up the new thread too soon or want a voting thread and ideas thread and all that, anybody who feels like can sure do that. I never thought there was need for one, but if you feel it's fair that way, then go ahead and start those threads :)

Which in my opnion is jumping the gun. Whenever games are started that quickly, we seem to get a few posts asking, why is Item A not here. That's usually an indication that not everyone had a chance to look at the list. It doesn't have to be as an involved process, but I'm just thinking that more time would have helped create a better list.

I'm sorry you weren't able to have a look at the list before the new game started. Next time we will wait some days before posting the new thread or just start voting threads here too, if that's what the majority would like to see so we can have a perfect list. :)

i fail to see the point really , someone will always be unhappy , the list is fine . we shouldn't take the EG so seriously . but yes we did start really fast but i hardly find all these complaints to be necessary . :dunno: and yes i am mostly just grumpy because you tasteless bastards killed my fireflies :bawl:

In my opinion, it's OK.

The ASOIAF EGs have a registry and some history, so things are a bit more formal. For me I don't mind how this one was done as long as it doesn't fall between the cracks as has nearly happened in the past.

That said: HOW COULD YOU LEAVE OFF THE INCREDIBLES??

ok

I'll calm down now. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal 10.

Hurt 2.

dang. should have quoted Helena and SGD.

will copy and paste.

SGD

\Hurt 2
Heal 26

Helena

Hurt Brave Little Toaster
Heal Hercules

2. Ice Age 2 --
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 9
5. Monsters Inc. 6
6. How To Train Your Dragon 7
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 10
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5 +
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
21. Mulan 4
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 1 -
26. The Jungle Book 6 +
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 8 +
29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Dragon

Hurt whatever that Toaster thingy is??? :eek: :idea:

Heal 8
Hurt 4

2. Ice Age 2
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 8
5. Monsters Inc. 6
6. How To Train Your Dragon 8
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 11
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 4
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
21. Mulan 4
23. Prince of Egypt 6
24. Brave Little Toaster 0
26. The Jungle Book 6
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 8
29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 2
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 8
5. Monsters Inc. 6
6. How To Train Your Dragon 8
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 11
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 3-
15. Sleeping Beauty 7
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 6
21. Mulan 5+
23. Prince of Egypt 6
26. The Jungle Book 6
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 8
29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hurt dalmatians

Heal sleeping beauty

2. Ice Age 2

3.Toy Story 5

4. The Lion King 8

5. Monsters Inc. 6

6. How To Train Your Dragon 8

7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6

8. Lady & The Tramp 11

9. Up 7

10. Ratatouille 5

11. Shrek 7

12. Aladdin 7

13. Finding Nemo 5

14. 101 Dalmatians 2-

15. Sleeping Beauty 8+

17. Little Mermaid 5

18. The Fox and the Hound 6

21. Mulan 5

23. Prince of Egypt 6

26. The Jungle Book 6

27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11

28. Hercules 8

29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Fox and the Hound, hurt Ice Age

2. Ice Age 1-

3.Toy Story 5

4. The Lion King 8

5. Monsters Inc. 6

6. How To Train Your Dragon 8

7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6

8. Lady & The Tramp 11

9. Up 7

10. Ratatouille 5

11. Shrek 7

12. Aladdin 7

13. Finding Nemo 5

14. 101 Dalmatians 2

15. Sleeping Beauty 8

17. Little Mermaid 5

18. The Fox and the Hound 7+

21. Mulan 5

23. Prince of Egypt 6

26. The Jungle Book 6

27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11

28. Hercules 8

29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2. Ice Age 1
3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 8
5. Monsters Inc. 7+
6. How To Train Your Dragon 8
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6
8. Lady & The Tramp 11
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 5
14. 101 Dalmatians 1-
15. Sleeping Beauty 8
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 7
21. Mulan 5
23. Prince of Egypt 6
26. The Jungle Book 6
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 8
29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hurt 2

Heal 13

Kill 101 Dalmations

Heal Hercules

2. Ice Age 0

3.Toy Story 5

4. The Lion King 8

5. Monsters Inc. 7

6. How To Train Your Dragon 8

7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 6

8. Lady & The Tramp 11

9. Up 7

10. Ratatouille 5

11. Shrek 7

12. Aladdin 7

13. Finding Nemo 6 +

14. 101 Dalmatians 0-

15. Sleeping Beauty 8

17. Little Mermaid 5

18. The Fox and the Hound 7

21. Mulan 5

23. Prince of Egypt 6

26. The Jungle Book 6

27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11

28. Hercules 9 +

29. Wall-E 16

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

3.Toy Story 5
4. The Lion King 8
5. Monsters Inc. 7
6. How To Train Your Dragon 8
7. All Dogs Go To Heaven 5-
8. Lady & The Tramp 11
9. Up 7
10. Ratatouille 5
11. Shrek 7
12. Aladdin 7
13. Finding Nemo 6
15. Sleeping Beauty 8
17. Little Mermaid 5
18. The Fox and the Hound 7
21. Mulan 5
23. Prince of Egypt 6
26. The Jungle Book 6
27. Nightmare Before Christmas 11
28. Hercules 9
29. Wall-E 17+

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×