Jump to content

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Jon Weirgaryen

Small Questions v.10089

Recommended Posts

It is possible, but we have to wait to find out.

Benjen was very young during the Rebellion, and he was the Stark in Winterfell.

Whether he knew or not, Ned knew he would take care of Jon at the Wall, though.

Why did Benjen take the black?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where did Mya Stone and Edric Storm come in the line of succession? Or are they not even considered?

As bastards, they are not even considered.

If the Bobby B's line had met a premature end, a Grand Council could have, maaaaaybe, considered them - like Lord Hornwood's bastard son was considered when no Hornwoods were left to inherit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When Jamie returned to KL with 200 Northmen, it was like he wasn't expected when he reached the city. How did 200 Northmen reach the city without being met to state their business miles beforehand. Are there no scouts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When Jamie returned to KL with 200 Northmen, it was like he wasn't expected when he reached the city. How did 200 Northmen reach the city without being met to state their business miles beforehand. Are there no scouts?

I assume they did and they were. They were flying a peace banner for that very reason.

And as for not be expected, well, it's not like they can call the Red Keep on their SmartPhones, the scouts would get there the same time as they did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As bastards, they are not even considered.

If the Bobby B's line had met a premature end, a Grand Council could have, maaaaaybe, considered them - like Lord Hornwood's bastard son was considered when no Hornwoods were left to inherit.

But can't legitimateized bastards hold lands and titles?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No POV characters from the Vale? We get at least one POV character from each of the 9 "kingdoms" that make up Westeros, even 2 from Essos and 1 from beyond the Wall, but none from the Vale? It must be boring there.

Who would your Vale POV character be? Not Littlefinger. His mind is a Pandora's box of secrets which no man can know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I assume they did and they were. They were flying a peace banner for that very reason.

And as for not be expected, well, it's not like they can call the Red Keep on their SmartPhones, the scouts would get there the same time as they did.

Actually Tywin might not have had intelligence that would have suggested a need for scouts up the Kingsroad. But if he did have them out there they would have gotten bsck to the city before Walton. They might not have noticed Jaime.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No POV characters from the Vale? We get at least one POV character from each of the 9 "kingdoms" that make up Westeros, even 2 from Essos and 1 from beyond the Wall, but none from the Vale? It must be boring there.

Who would your Vale POV character be? Not Littlefinger. His mind is a Pandora's box of secrets which no man can know.

who else, Bronze Yohn Royce baby

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I assume they did and they were. They were flying a peace banner for that very reason.

And as for not be expected, well, it's not like they can call the Red Keep on their SmartPhones, the scouts would get there the same time as they did.

I'll reread the section. Wouldn't scouts send ravens, the smartphone of that era? If scouts arrived with the news of possibly hostile invaders, at the same time the possibly hostile invaders arrive at the door, then what would be the point of having scouts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any evidence to support the claim from little finger that he deflowered catelyn tully other then his word

u mean lysa?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any evidence to support the claim from little finger that he deflowered catelyn tully other then his word

LF and Lysa slept together twice, prior to LF being send away after his duel with Brandon. The first time was when LF had gotten drunk after Catelyn had turned him down, the second time was after the duel, in the fortnight LF was cared for at Riverrun.

Because he was so very drunk, his first time, he thought he had slept with Catelyn, while in fact, he had slept with Lysa.

The second time, while wounded from hid duel, he was aware it had been Lysa, causing him to think he had slept with both girls, while in reality he had slept with Lysa twice.

So no, LF did not deflower Cat, although he sincerely believes he did.

Edit: clarification

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Who was Roose Bolton's first wife?

That is currently unknown.

Where did Mya Stone and Edric Storm come in the line of succession? Or are they not even considered?

They aren't at all considered, as they are bastards.

Why did Benjen take the black?

At Harrenhal, Benjen heard the plea of a Black Brother for new recruits, and he took that plea to hearth. However, something cause Benjen to join at an extremely young age, something which he might have regretted later on (as expressed to Jon Snow).

So while it seems that Benjen was always going to join the Black, at some point in his life, something happened that caused him to join at a very young age. As Benjen joined shortly after the Rebellion had ended, it is most logical that he joined because of something that happened during the war. what exactly, is unknown.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

LF and Lysa slept together twice. The first time was when LF had gotten drunk after Catelyn had turned him down, the second time was after the duel.

Because he was so very drunk, he thought he had slept with Catelyn, while in fact, he had slept with Lysa.

So no, LF did not deflower Cat, although he sincerely believes he did.

Thanks. Great answer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No POV characters from the Vale? We get at least one POV character from each of the 9 "kingdoms" that make up Westeros, even 2 from Essos and 1 from beyond the Wall, but none from the Vale? It must be boring there.

Who would your Vale POV character be? Not Littlefinger. His mind is a Pandora's box of secrets which no man can know.

Alayane is in the Vale currently, and she's a POV. ;)

But can't legitimateized bastards hold lands and titles?

Legitimized? Yes, though it is currently unknown whether you first need to specifically include the legitimized bastard into the line of succession, or whethet that happens automatically.

Mya and Edric are not legitimized, though. They are only recognized.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At Harrenhal, Benjen heard the plea of a Black Brother for new recruits, and he took that plea to hearth. However, something cause Benjen to join at an extremely young age, something which he might have regretted later on (as expressed to Jon Snow).

Where is this from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×