Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Ran

[Poll] How would you rate episode 508?

How would you rate episode 508?  

997 members have voted

  1. 1. What's your rating from 1-10, with 10 being the highest/best

    • 1
      23
    • 2
      7
    • 3
      5
    • 4
      10
    • 5
      17
    • 6
      17
    • 7
      43
    • 8
      78
    • 9
      209
    • 10
      585


Recommended Posts

Gave it a 10. Probably my second favorite episode to date behind Rains of Castamere (barely edging out Blackwater and the Children.) Last 20 minutes were simply incredible and I love the Dany/Tyrion dynamic.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only thing missing was Crystal Gale(wighted) singing "Don't it make my brown eyes blue" as Jon sails away.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've watched it three times. This is definitely one of the best episodes of the series. Looks like this might be the highest rated episode ever on Westeros?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I watch it on my iMac, and when I first watched it in daylight, I was getting pretty annoyed that my own reflection was dominating lots of the scenes. It was somewhat better on a nighttime rewatch. The darkness is definitely a bit much on a computer - is there the same issue on a TV?

Our tv has no issue with it. Neither does my Macbook Pro (with the retina display), but my husband's laptop would have problems with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our tv has no issue with it. Neither does my Macbook Pro (with the retina display), but my husband's laptop would have problems with it.

A normal PC had it quite dark.

I was comfortable with the darkness because it enhanced the creepiness.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

7/10 Dissapointed but still a fan.

Pros

-The drama between Jorah and Dany continues. Well acted, and heart-rending.

-Tyrion has finally met up with Dany. Yay? - more in Cons

-Arya is on the fast-track to being a faceless man. There's some interesting commentary on the ethics of what is, essentially, life insurance for sailors. We get to see Arya taking on a new role, though mostly in a montage-esque form.

-Sansa finds out Bran and Rickon are alive. Maybe Reek(Theon) is beginning to soften and give ground. Perhaps there's hope of him being an eventual ally to Sansa. Sophie manages to get a little more aggressive this time, we actually start to see a little more emotion out of her than the usual slack jaw and parted lips. I say Sophie, because I believe that Sansa - as I know her from the books - would have freaked the fuck out over being handed to Ramsey and raped. Lets hope we see more strength and sharp wit out of Sophie in the future, rather than lines simply recited whilst thinking about her twitter feed.

-Stuff at the wall is moving along. Not how the books went... but it's fine. Nice drama building with Jon's squire.

-Epic fucking battle. I'm only listing this in the pros because it was an epic battle, and amazing. For my take on the implications for the series and the lore, see cons.

Cons

-Tyrion might be drinking more than normal but he hasn't shown the audience just how low his self esteem goes. Oh sure he might complain about his family, but his dignity doesn't really begin to desert him the way it does in the books. I can understand why the showmakers chose not to make their Emmy-winner be a 'circus-freak', but that reeks somewhat of cowardice to me. Tyrion is my favorite character, and following him across the narrow sea in the books was a painful experience for me. I found myself embarassed for him, and ashamed of myself for feeling that way. Ultimately I could only appreciate the stark realism of the depths of shame and self-loathing a person is capable of, and the sense of hope that lingers when we know that a person is fundamentally bigger than their shortcomings or, more importantly, those imposed upon them by society. And what about the wit, the sarcasm? How, in any way, was Tyrion and Dany's meeting satisfying? Tyrion basically recited his and Dany's resumes, and then used the drama between Dany and Jorah as a springboard onto her small council. This was not a confluence of personality, rather than a convenient joining of plot devices - a slightly epic job interview. When Dinklage isn't voicing the words of Martin, his lines fall flat - no offense to PD, DBW, or DB, but Martin IS Tyrion. The strength, the frailty, the self-loathing, the escapism, the brilliance, the facade - it's all Martin. Who can capture that better than GRRM himself. I hope the showmakers and Dinklage figure out the magic formula, as they tread new ground.

-Maisie's failure to breathe life into Arya continues. She's gotten by this far on good writing, coaching, and a solidly thought-out character. What will become of her once there are no more books to consult? I guess we'll see, next episode.

-Epic fucking battle. Too fucking epic. Trying too hard. Too evil dead. Relied too heavily on effects and jarring surprises or transitions. Ultimately didn't do much for the series or lore, except re-emphasize the fact that there's an Army of Dar... dead out there and that dragonglass and valyrian steel can kill white walkers. The Thenn's fight was weak. IMHO the series has gone too far in exposing the audience to the white walkers rather than keeping them as a more subtle element to be brought out in the final chapters of the grand story. They've always been there, since the prologue of book one, but I feel like it's GRRM's intention for the readers to get so caught up in the affairs of the south that they almost forget the impending doom in the north. I would have liked to have seen more of this time used to flesh out Arya's story, even though Maisie's acting makes me grind my teeth.

Overall, I feel like the show is finally venturing out into its own storyline, trying - and failing a bit - to capture the ethos of Martin's world. They still have the gratuitous HBO sex and violence, the political intrigue, and the drama; but it all feels a bit tired and unoriginal suddenly. I feel like the show is beginning to coast in the tracks that it has established over the last five years, and we can look forward to a less-than-satisfying finish with perhaps a couple of almost-predictable and derivative twists and kill-offs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This episode gave me hope for the rest of the season! Episode 7 was a real joke to me. It was so disconnected and dull and I was not impressed in anyway. My mouth was hanging open for all of episode 8, extremely impressed and I am excited for episode 9 because we all know the reputation it needs to uphold.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

9



Easily the best episode of the season so far. I really didn't like season 5 much until this episode, because the plot was moving about as slowly as molasses, but this episode finally pushed the rock down the hill and things seem to be moving again. Loved the scene between Dany and Tyrion, loved the final half hour at Hardhome, and I continue to love how Cersei is suffering.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My first 10 of the season. A gave it a 10 not because it was perfect (I don't think there is such a thing), but because you'd be hard pressed to find a better episode in this season or any previous.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

who are the trolls that voted below 7?

Go over to rant and rave, people still trolling D&D about sansa rape.

I feel people should vote with reasoning than just "I will hate you forever, here take my 1/10" attitude

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I gave a 5.



  • Much better than the last three. Had it just been Hardhome, I would have given a 9. Winterfell really dragged this episode (Iwan, Sophie and the plot there just didn't make sense, still).
  • Dany-Tyrion was repetitive.
  • I didn't understand why the zombies white walkers were so World War Z. I went back to the Season 2 finale and those white walkers were miles slower, and not quite as rabid. I didn't like the emotional manipulation that introduced a new character, and gave a her so many lines just so I would feel bad when she died.
  • I didn't like the implication that the Faceless Men were vigilantes.


Holly hell I was glad we didn't get Dorne, though sad at the lack of NCW...then again, his arc is so terrible that I'm almost glad we don't see him as much.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't like the emotional manipulation that introduced a new character, and gave a her so many lines just so I would feel bad when she died.

That WAS, IS, and always shall be GoT.

Forgot Ned & Robb did ya? ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I absolutely loved this episode! Definitely my favourite so far!



It had a lot of elements I've been hoping/ wishing for. Cersei getting her comeuppance just like in the book; Sansa showing a little backbone, (even if it was only to Reek but she has to start somewhere!); Snow zombies finally, and excellently executed; and then Tyrion and Dany finally meeting and having a little snark between them, but finally seeing eye to eye. I'm very excited about the latter - the actors portray these characters so very well!



EDIT: I forgot about Cat of the Canals. Even though they changed her name, I loved that they included her! I don't think the hair style suits Maisie at all though hehe!


Edited by Reek the Sneak

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That WAS, IS, and always shall be GoT.

Forgot Ned & Robb did ya? ;)

That didn't happen in one episode, Which was the case with not-Val.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

who are the trolls that voted below 7?

Gave it a 4 just after viewing it.

Found Dany trusting Tyrion so fast completely unbelievable and her break the wheel speech remembered me too much LF "chaos a ladder" in the empty formula category, and I also hated the World War Z aspect of the battle.

Now after re-viewing it and reading all the positive comments, I do think I was more than harsh, and I should have given it a 6 or 7 at least (especially has I had noted previous episode 7), be it only for not having Dorne, for the well done Wilding council, Arya scene and terrifying septa.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×