Jump to content
HelenaExMachina

Little Questions That Don't Fit Anywhere Else Part 3

Recommended Posts

Guest

Will the winter end when the NK is killed?

In the show, I think so.

In the books, I dont know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/28/2017 at 12:26 PM, valgrel said:

Who will use Heartsbane in the fight against WW ? Sam will certainly not, and it would be a waste to leave the only 2-handed valyrian sword (Longclaw, Oathkeeper are bastard swords) in its sheath. 

Jorah could be the best choice, or maybe Sandor. Anyone else ?

I don't think anyone will. I think Gendry will reforge it into two regular sized swords.

If it stays as one, The Hound would make sense because of it's size and his training with swords.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

OK, maybe I missed this, but I cant be the only one who has noticed that we have a  major character for each of The Seven? Assuming Boat Baby.....Father= Jon Snow, Mother= Daenerys, Warrior= Jamie, Smith= Gendry, Crone= Melisandre, Stranger= Arya. Perhaps this is how they defeat the NK?

Edited by Golden Eyed Meraxes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I just remembered Benjen's horse from Season 7 Episode 6, when Benjen saves Jon and Jon rides on it to the Wall (and of course in earlier episodes too, with Bran and Meera) - Is Benjen's horse resurrected/living dead with COTF magic like he is or is it just a normal horse? I don't remember how it looked but I think maybe it was half decaying... Did the COTF save his horse with dragonglass through its heart just like they saved him? And if not, how the hell has that horse survived north of the Wall for so long?

Edited by Adam Targaryen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@John Suburbs @Lord Varys

Even in the show, it looks like, Marge did it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2W2xHM4cWo

At 3:59 Joffrey gives his goblet to Marge, she goes with it to the table, not the table where Tyrion and Sansa were sitting (right table), not the table where Olenna was sitting with Mace (left table), but a different table, smaller than others, the one at which Joffret and Margaery were sitting in the beginning of the video (cetral table). Olenna didn't left her table. So, it was Marge, who dropped the poison into wine, while she was holding the cup in her hands.

In the book-version, during the adding of poison, the chalice was standing on Tyrion's table, on the inner side of it, closer to the pie, on the opposite side from Tyrion, on the side closer to Marge.

If I'm not mistaken, the script for this episode was written by GRRM. So, what their sitting arrangements looked like in the show, is close to what they were in the book.

Thus, when (in the book-version) Joffrey returned to Tyrion's table, after cutting the pie, he didn't went on the other side of the table, where Tyrion was sitting with Sansa, he stayed on the "inner side", and that's where he left his chalice, and from where he picked it up. So, when he was choking and dying from poison, he was separated by the table from Tyrion and Garlan. Thus, whoever poisoned his wine, was on this (inner) side of the table. And out of those three people (Joffrey, Marge and Olenna), Marge is the only one, who could have done it (Olenna is not tall enough, and Joffrey didn't poisoned himself).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Megorova said:

@John Suburbs @Lord Varys

Even in the show, it looks like, Marge did it.

The show has Olenna confess to Margaery that she killed Joffrey. And Margaery had no clue what was about to happen. We also see Olenna mess with the wine goblet in the episode. It is subtle but it is there.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/5/2019 at 3:46 PM, Megorova said:

@John Suburbs @Lord Varys

Even in the show, it looks like, Marge did it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2W2xHM4cWo

At 3:59 Joffrey gives his goblet to Marge, she goes with it to the table, not the table where Tyrion and Sansa were sitting (right table), not the table where Olenna was sitting with Mace (left table), but a different table, smaller than others, the one at which Joffret and Margaery were sitting in the beginning of the video (cetral table). Olenna didn't left her table. So, it was Marge, who dropped the poison into wine, while she was holding the cup in her hands.

In the book-version, during the adding of poison, the chalice was standing on Tyrion's table, on the inner side of it, closer to the pie, on the opposite side from Tyrion, on the side closer to Marge.

If I'm not mistaken, the script for this episode was written by GRRM. So, what their sitting arrangements looked like in the show, is close to what they were in the book.

Thus, when (in the book-version) Joffrey returned to Tyrion's table, after cutting the pie, he didn't went on the other side of the table, where Tyrion was sitting with Sansa, he stayed on the "inner side", and that's where he left his chalice, and from where he picked it up. So, when he was choking and dying from poison, he was separated by the table from Tyrion and Garlan. Thus, whoever poisoned his wine, was on this (inner) side of the table. And out of those three people (Joffrey, Marge and Olenna), Marge is the only one, who could have done it (Olenna is not tall enough, and Joffrey didn't poisoned himself).

 

On 7/5/2019 at 4:52 PM, Lord Varys said:

The show has Olenna confess to Margaery that she killed Joffrey. And Margaery had no clue what was about to happen. We also see Olenna mess with the wine goblet in the episode. It is subtle but it is there.

 

:agree:This. In the mummer's farce, it is clear that Margy did not do it, not like there is any reason to think that what that happens in the show confirms anything in the books.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, John Suburbs said:

 

:agree:This. In the mummer's farce, it is clear that Margy did not do it, not like there is any reason to think that what that happens in the show confirms anything in the books.

Not exactly. The fact that George wrote the Purple Wedding certainly allows us to cite the fact that there is no pie there and no talk of him ever speculating about the pie. I mean, at this point in the story they certainly could have gone with whatever you think the pie poisoning plot was about if that was what George's intention was. They could also have decided to not go down that route, of course, but they could have made things right there, no? The fact that they made Joff's death more or less the way it went down as per the 'official story' in the books certainly helps to put your idea into way out there fringe conspiracy territory.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/9/2019 at 10:12 AM, Lord Varys said:

Not exactly. The fact that George wrote the Purple Wedding certainly allows us to cite the fact that there is no pie there and no talk of him ever speculating about the pie. I mean, at this point in the story they certainly could have gone with whatever you think the pie poisoning plot was about if that was what George's intention was. They could also have decided to not go down that route, of course, but they could have made things right there, no? The fact that they made Joff's death more or less the way it went down as per the 'official story' in the books certainly helps to put your idea into way out there fringe conspiracy territory.

The pie is too complicated for the show, and much less salacious. They would have to explain the history of Highgarden hegemony, the recent shifts in the balance of power, and all the rest. With the wine, they can first create the evil, sexually depraved Joffrey that makes for good television and then explain Lady Olenna's actions with nothing more than "you don't think I would really let you marry that monster, do you?"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The whole goblet thing was still a pure stroke of luck for Olenna. Maergery could have easily drunk from it as well. And there was every chance she would. Hence this plan being completely bonkers in it's execution and only luck prevented someone else from choking to death, namely Olenna's own family and biggest chess piece.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, John Suburbs said:

The pie is too complicated for the show, and much less salacious. They would have to explain the history of Highgarden hegemony, the recent shifts in the balance of power, and all the rest. With the wine, they can first create the evil, sexually depraved Joffrey that makes for good television and then explain Lady Olenna's actions with nothing more than "you don't think I would really let you marry that monster, do you?"

I'd say that the pie idea is also far too complicated for the novels ;-).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Mystical said:

The whole goblet thing was still a pure stroke of luck for Olenna. Maergery could have easily drunk from it as well. And there was every chance she would. Hence this plan being completely bonkers in it's execution and only luck prevented someone else from choking to death, namely Olenna's own family and biggest chess piece.

It was not luck nor was there ever any danger to Margaery because there was no poison in the chalice until Joffrey barfed into it. The poison was in the pie; Tyrion was the target, not Joffrey.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Lord Varys said:

I'd say that the pie idea is also far too complicated for the novels ;-).

It is not. The whole thing can, and will, be explained in two or three paragraphs -- a drop in the bucket for a 1000-page novel.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, John Suburbs said:

It is not. The whole thing can, and will, be explained in two or three paragraphs -- a drop in the bucket for a 1000-page novel.

Then it could also have been done in the show.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×