Jump to content

Hypothetical: You're Robb Stark and You've Been Given a Second Chance


StarkofWinterfell

Recommended Posts

 

Not when the 4,000 are fortified at the Twins. Robb was unable to the Twins by 'surprise' in AGOT when he almost had 20k who will he do it with 3,500?

 

There is a reason that Walder did not go to meet his guests outside, much to the chagrin of Edmure, the Freys were clearly cautious.

My bad, I thought you meant 4000 outside of the Twins.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He managed to destroy all of stannis' food siege equipment and hundreds of horses during a blizzard with 20 men without being caught then beat managed to suprising stannis with a cavalry charge to the front the next day.


Yeah the showrunners really stretched the idea of suspension of disbelief with that ridiculous scene. Unless Ramsay had a team of magical super ninjas, even modern black op strike forces with today's military technology would have a very hard time pulling something like that off.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fake some reason to be late.
Assassinate Roose Bolton, maybe some of his high off people.
The foot soldiers didn't know about the real plan, they were told to get ready, not to drink, but they most likely didn't know that they were going to kill their own guys until they got the order. Fake evidence that it were the Lannisters to eliminate a powerful enemy or even the Freys.
But with the Boltons they would be 7000 (they at least believe to be loyal to the north) to 4000 Freys.
Probably killing Walter too, hoping to start a Frey family war. Or after that killing Bolton go into the Twins. Make a huge scene to get revenge for Roose. Get ride of the three musicians and bring your own.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only one day!  To undo all the mess that Robb created!  StarkofWinterfell, be generous.  Let's rewind to the point in time before Cat released the kingslayer, before he married the Westerling girl.  That gives us, his advisors, something to work with.  Say perhaps, give Jeyne a fatal accident so Robb keeps his vows to the Freys.

 

One day is not going to change the following:

 

  1. Breaking his promise to the Freys
  2. Cat releasing Jaime
  3. Killed Karstark
  4. Failure to give Edmure proper instructions
  5. Declare himself King in the North
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...