Jump to content
Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn

Poll: Answer 10 mysteries of asoiaf

Recommended Posts

On 7/4/2018 at 1:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. Somewhere in Westeros living a non story crucial life

2.Lyanna

3.A group of nobles, not one person.

4.I really hope it's Ashara or some commoner but probably Lyanna

5. Illyrio's Blackfyre son

6.Luton, his death in the frey manderly fight is way too suspect for someone who had no dog in that race.

7.Mance or Stannis, I'm leaning towards Stannis but I see how mance might've written it.

8.Nobody, just some dead NW member

9.Theon's self hatred

10.Nobody.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Walda said:

Could you give me a bit of detail 

Sure.  But (hopefully) just to clarify, and not start arguments.  Nothing against arguments, but I'm not sure this is the thread

"When they were swapped?"

Probably at around the time that Doran was plotting to send Quentyn to be fostered, and Mellario threw that major tantrum that Arianne overheard.

"What about all the Mudd imagery around Frog?"

I don't know what this means.  Sorry.

"and where does Young Griff getting his platinum hair and violet eyes, so unlike his father's and mother's? "

I assume he gets his blond hair and blue eyes from his mother, Mellario.

"How did he get from King's Landing to the ship? Where were the lions?"
 
He was picked up by a ship that later sank. The lions were on an uncharted island or Sothyros peninsula.
 
(This is really just a jokey way of saying his body will never be found).

"Did Myrcella die with both ears intact? Or was she killed by Doran?"

She was killed by Darkstar's poisoned blade.  The poison and infection were fatal.

"Wouldn't Balon Swann notice the difference?"

Apparently not.  

"Trystane?"

Insufficient data..

"Do you mean fAegon is still alive, or do you mean 'Frog' of the Windblown is still alive?"
 
Well, both really.  The fellow we know as Young Griff, was born as Quentyn Martell to Doran and Mellario, and is still alive.  The fellow we know as Quentyn Martell, a/k/a Frog of the Windblown, was born as Aegon to Rhaegar and Ellia, and is also still alive.
 
"If the latter, who was the poor sap Missandei nursed to death?"
 
Not Quentyn.  One of the non-descript Windblown present, most likely the Tattered Prince, incognito.
 
In my opinion, of course.
Edited by Platypus Rex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 10:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. I don't know.

2. Ned Stark. There is no way 14 yo Lyanna was a knight of some sort, and she can't be confused with Jaime Lannister right? 

3. Green Grace.

4. Ashara Dayne. 

5. Son of Rhaegar and Lyanna. Real Blackfyre is Daario. We have no proof of Saera and/or Illyrio being Blackfyres and them having a child. Stop with baseless "theories" just because you hate him.

6. Big Walder Frey.

7. Mance Rayder.

8. Night's King.

9. I don't know.

10. OG Azor Ahai was Brandon of the Bloody Blade. AA≠TPTWP 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1. Where is Tysha?

Braavos

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

Certainly Eddard, maybe at Lyanna's request, but probably mostly from hanging out with Howland himself.

- Booming voice

- Robert's horse

- Hadn't intended to ride so borrows armor from friends(see Baelor Breakspear in Hedge Knight)

- Ethan Glover told Aerys (triggers Aerys' call for Eddard & Robert's heads)

3. Who is the Harpy?

Shavepate

4. Who is Jon's mother?

Lyanna

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

Rhaegar's son

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

Big Walder

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

Mance

8. Who is Coldhands?

Maybe a raven's tooth, maybe the night's king, maybe an ancient Jon Snow - the one Ygritte mentions for being a cursed name

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

Have heard several plausible options, I prefer the one where it is someone who heard Theon call Robb his brother/Eddard his father, forget the name currently. Due for a re-read amirite?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

Too many obvious options.

Edited by Kienn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 8:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

Dead

Howland Reed

Galazza Galare/Green Grace

Lyanna

Blackfyre descendant

Ramsay

Melisandre

Benjen 

Roose

No one

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 9:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. I don't think we'll ever know 

2. Still think it was Lyanna Stark

3. More than one person, the Green Grace is one of them

4. Lyanna Stark

5. I don't think it really matters. He is a dragon, probably a black one as Varys hinted but he could also be a descendant of one of Aegon V's brothers (one had a daughter the other a son). I don't think he's Rhaegar's... 

6. I really don't know... I'd bet on Ramsay. 

7. Ramsay but I think it was tampered with by someone at the Wall

8. Not Benjen Stark for sure. Probably someone from the NW, I don't think we'll ever know. 

9. I'd say Mance but just because I can't come up with another name. 

10. Rhaegar Targaryen was always my first choice. I admit I'm having doubts now. He set everything in motion that led to Jon's and Daenerys' births, I think Jon and one of the dragons (Viserion) are the new Lightbringer. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Where is Tysha?

We will never know.

 

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

Lyanna Stark

 

3. Who is the Harpy?

Key figure being the Green Grace.

 

4. Who is Jon's mother?

Lyanna Stark

 

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

Blackfyre through Illyrio.

 

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

Mance and crew.

 

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

Ramsay but he was incorrect about truly defeating Stannis & Stannis being dead. The Boltons will lose the battle.

 

8. Who is Coldhands?

Not buying that it is not Benjen.

 

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

Not sure, will need to re-read.

 

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

Jon Snow

 

11. What happened to Tyrek Lannister?

Kidnapped by Varys or Littlefinger (leaning towards Varys, though LF seems to have a few young heirs in his pocket).

 

12. Where did Qyburn come from and what are his goals?

His story holds up. His goals are to continue his work..

 

13. What is Littlefinger's full back story?

The story as we know it. However, it would be interesting to know more.

 

14. Where did Jaime and Brienne go?

To see LSH and the BWB.

 

15. What happened to Gerion Lannister?

He died or went through a mid-life experience that convinced him to start fresh.

16. Where is Benjen?

Coldhands.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
On 7/4/2018 at 9:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. Tysha is probably dead or living a commoner's life somewhere in Westeros. Possibly otherwise as a whore in one of the Free Cities - most likely Braavos. The only chance of Tyrion meeting her again is if she's a whore in Essos, but I don't think that's the case.

2. Lyanna Stark

3. Some Meereenese noble, I don't know

4. Lyanna Stark

5. A Blackfyre

6. Big Walder Frey

7. No idea XD

8. A random Night's Watch corpse which is being warged by Bloodraven

9. Don't know

10. Jon Snow or Daenerys Targaryen (or noone at all)

Edited by Adam Targaryen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 12:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. She won’t appear again. But if I had to pick a place, the brothel in White Harbor whose name I can’t remember. 

2. Lyanna 

3. Who cares? 

4. Lyanna 

5. Blackfyre, son of Illyrio and Serra, Varys’ sister 

6. Big Walder 

7. Ramsay. 

8. The Night’s King, attempting to redeem himself 

9. No idea. 

10. Jon Snow 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1. Where is Tysha? Doesn't matter

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)? Lyanna Stark

3. Who is the Harpy? Galazza Galare

4. Who is Jon's mother? Lyanna Stark

5. Real identity of Aegon VI? Blackfyre

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey? Big Walder Frey

7. Who wrote Pink Letter? Ramsay Bolton

8. Who is Coldhands? Just an old ranger, no one named

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell? Howland Reed or Theon's conscious 

10. Who is Azor Ahai? Jon Snow, if it is indeed one person

Edited by LordMarek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Where is Tysha? In Westeros somewhere.

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)? Lyanna Stark

3. Who is the Harpy? Green Grace

4. Who is Jon's mother? Lyanna Stark

5. Real identity of Aegon VI? Son of Ilyrio and Sera

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey? Dont know... but I wouldnt be surprised if it is Ramsey.

7. Who wrote Pink Letter? Mance

8. Who is Coldhands? One of Raven's Teeth

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell? Harwin

10. Who is Azor Ahai? Most probably Jon Snow.

1. What happened to Tyrek Lannister? Currently in hiding.

12. Where did Qyburn come from and what are his goals? I think he may have been a bastard from a great house who has a love of Necromancy.

13. What is Littlefinger's full back story? Still undecided but he wants to create chaos none the less.

14. Where did Jaime and Brienne go? Off to Stoneheart

15. What happened to Gerion Lannister? He is somewhere in Essos.

16. Where is Benjen? Beyond the wall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 9:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

3. Who is the Harpy?

4. Who is Jon's mother?

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

8. Who is Coldhands?

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

 

1. Either we will never know or Tyrion actually killed her and has himself created a false memory.

2. Lyanna

3. Multiple people, including the Green Grace

4. Lyanna; it would be kind of funny if she became pregnant with a daughter while already pregnant- would explain the timeline 

5. A Blackfyre descendant, probably Illyrio’s relative

6. Ramsay

7. Little Walder; my current guess is that Mance gave him some info, the rest he learned from Clydas, who is actually a bastard brother of Lord Frey (both are chinless) and is now sending secret messages to Lord Bolton. LW did it to appeal to Ramsay, who then killed him when he learned about it.

8. Craster’s father

9. A Stark loyalist, maybe Harwin

10. A concept

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 3:40 AM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha?

Somewhere in Essos.  I'm not interested in her plot.

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?

Some tourney knight that Howland and Lyanna paid.  

3. Who is the Harpy?

Galazza Galare

4. Who is Jon's mother?

Lyanna

5. Real identity of Aegon VI?

Aegon Blackfyre

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey?

Mance Rayder

7. Who wrote Pink Letter?

Ramsay 

8. Who is Coldhands?

Somebody with Stark blood who died.  See how he warged the elk.

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell?

?

10. Who is Azor Ahai?

Daenerys

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/4/2018 at 5:40 PM, Prince Yourwetdream Aeryn said:

1. Where is Tysha? Dead and gone 

2. Who is Mystery Knight of Harrenhall (Laughing tree)?  Lyanna

3. Who is the Harpy? don't care. an organisation.

4. Who is Jon's mother? Lyanna

5. Real identity of Aegon VI? Illyrio & Serra's child and a Blackfyre

6.  Who killed Little Walder Frey? Big Walder Frey I hope

7. Who wrote Pink Letter? Stannis.

8. Who is Coldhands? An executed disgraced Night's Watch man resurrected.

9. Who is Hooded man of Winterfell? Septon Chayle

10. Who is Azor Ahai? Its a story whose key elements will repeat but won't necessarily be one person. (Some undead person will be weilding a flaming sword due to fire & blood magic as has been demonstrated by Beric.) Jon Dany Jaime & Brienne will all have a role.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×