Jump to content
Romag

Best fighters in each region

Recommended Posts

Who is the top 3 fighters in each region after aGoT and after aDwD

The wall and the free folk

GoT

1.qhorin halfhand

2.mance rayder

3.benjen stark

North 

1.Greatjon Umber??

2.Jorah Mormont??

3.

Riverlands

1.Brynden Tully

2.Jason Mallister

3.Black Walder Frey

Westerlands

1.Jaime Lannister

2.the mountain

3.the hound

Vale

1.Yohn Royce

2.Lyn Corbray

3.??

Crownlands

Stormlands

1.Barristan Selmy

2.Balon Swann

3.Brienne

Dorne

1.Oberyn

2.sandsnake?

3.Darkstar?

Reach

1.Garlan?

2.Loras?

3.??

Iron Island

1.Victarion/Euron

2.Harlaw??

3.??

Essos

1.Khal Drogo

2.belwas??

3.???

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Essos needs Daario, Jorah and Grey Worm on there I reckon.

Crownlands is I guess where one would place Thoros of Myr.

Jon Snow and Tormund need to be mentioned too, somewhere.

Randyll Tarly in the Reach.

Bronn - who knows where to put him. Crownlands I guess?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right now in the North the best is probably Hosteen.

In the RL, it's probably the hound.

In the crownlands, I have to go with Gregor.

In the stormlands, it's probably someone from the GC on their way to SE.

In the Reach, it's probably Garlan or Andrik.

In Dorne, Areo most likely.

In the Vale, Lyn Corbray has the best reputation but I'm not sold.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A Dance with Dragons

Beyond the Wall:

  1. The Others
  2. Mance Rayder
  3. Tormund

The Night's Watch:

  1. Iron Emmett
  2. Alliser Thorne
  3. Jon Snow

The North:

  1. Mors Umber
  2. Hosteen Frey
  3. Maege Mormont

The Riverlands:

  1. Brynden Tully
  2. Addam Marbrand
  3. Daven Lannister

The Vale:

  1. Yohn Royce
  2. Lyn Corbray
  3. ?

The Crownlands:

  1. Robert Strong
  2. Loras Tyrell
  3. Randyll Tarly

The Westerlands:

We don't know anyone there right now.

The Iron Islands:

We don't know anyone there right now.

The Reach:

  1. Garlan Tyrell
  2. ?
  3. ?

The Stormlands:

  1. Rolly Duckfield 
  2. Balaq
  3. Jon Connington

Dorne:

  1. Areo Hotah
  2. Gerold Dayne
  3. Balon Swann

Essos:

  1. Barristan Selmy
  2. Victarion Greyjoy
  3. Jhaqo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A Game of Thrones

Beyond the Wall: (not going to count the Others)

  1. Mance Rayder
  2. Tormund
  3. Styr

The Night's Watch:

  1. Benjen Stark
  2. Alliser Thorne
  3. Jeor Mormont (why not?)

The North:

  1. Greatjon Umber
  2. Eddard Stark
  3. Rickard Karstark

The Riverlands: (a bit of an unknown)

  1. Jason Mallister
  2. Tytos Blackwood
  3. ??? Patrek Mallister? Marq Piper? A Frey?

The Vale:

  1. Yohn Royce
  2. Brynden Tully (He's in the Vale at this time).
  3. Lyn Corbray

The Crownlands:

  1. Jamie Lannister
  2. Barristan Selmy
  3. Sandor Clegane/Out of shape Robert Baratheon?

The Westerlands:

1. Gregor Clegane

2. Lyle Crakehall

3. Adam Marbrand

The Iron Islands:

1. Victarion Greyjoy

2. Harras Harlaw

3.  Don't know of house don't care

The Reach:

  1. Garlan Tyrell
  2. Loras Tyrell
  3. Randyll Tarly

The Stormlands: 

(With Bobby B in the capital)

  1. Balon Swann
  2. Emmon Cuy
  3. Guyard Morrigen

Dorne:

  1. Oberyn Martell
  2. Gerold Dayne
  3. ??

Essos:

  1. Khal Drogo
  2. Jon Connington aka Griff
  3. *insert pit fighters and unsullied captains*

A Dance with Dragons

Beyond the Wall:

  1. Who is here at this point?? Mother Mole? Coldhands? Something that cannot be killed except by valyrian steel is not going up as a top fighter.

The Night's Watch:

  1. Alliser Thorne
  2. Dying Jon Snow
  3.  ??

The North:

  1. Roose Bolton
  2. Mors Umber
  3. Harrion Karstark or one of the Ryswells (since most of the young heirs/lords are dead)

The Riverlands:

  1. Brynden Tully
  2. Brienne of Tarth (excluded before because unknown in the beginning)
  3. Adam Marbrand

The Vale:

  1. Yohn Royce
  2. Lyn Corbray
  3.  Lothor Brune

The Crownlands:

  1. Robert Strong
  2. Loras Tyrell
  3. Randyll Tarly

The Westerlands:

1. Daven Lannister

2. Other Westerlords

The Iron Islands:

We don't know anyone there right now.

The Reach:

  1. Garlan Tyrell
  2. Baelor Brightsmile (guessing)
  3. Euron Greyjoy

The Stormlands:

  1. Jon Connington
  2. Other Stormlords?

Dorne:

  1. Balon Swann
  2. Areo Hotah
  3. ??

Essos:

  1. Barristan Selmy
  2. Victarion Greyjoy
  3. Daario

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Platypus Rex said:

Why has no-one mentioned Ser Pounce?

I think Lady Whiskers is the champion Cat of Ice and Fire.

She defeated Ser Pounce and took the mouse.

After all,

Quote

 "Ser Pounce must learn to defend his rights . . . In this world the weak are always the victims of the strong."

Lady Whiskers lmao

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Loras and Garlan are likely tied for the Reach with both being the best at different aspects of combat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

    Spotted Pate, the aforementioned character, an empty-headed pig boy with good fortune
    Pate (novice), a novice at the Citadel
    Pate the Woodcock, a knight of King Jaehaerys I's Kingsguard
    Pate of Longleaf, a squire who killed Lord Jason Lannister
    Pate (Night's Watch), a builder in the Night's Watch
    Pate (Ranger), a ranger in the Night's Watch
    Pate the stonemason, a stonemason who became High Septon
    Pate of Fairmarket, a peasant who became King of the Trident
    Pate the Plowman, the founder of House Moreland
    Pate (Standfast), a peasant sworn to House Osgrey
    Pate of the Blue Fork, a hedge knight married to Amerei Frey
    Pate (Pinchbottom), an old man who lived at Little Dosk and was killed by ironborn raiders
    Steely Pate, a blacksmith during the reign of Daeron II
    Pate (Old), an old man killed by Lannister forces during the War of the Five Kings
    Pate (Mory), another man killed by Lannister forces during the War of the Five Kings
    Pate (Lancewood), yet another man killed by Lannister forces during the War of the Five Kings
    Pate (Shermer's Grove), still another man killed by Lannister forces during the War of the Five Kings
    Spotted Pate of Maidenpool, another builder in the Night's Watch, he died defending Castle Black
    Pate (King's Landing), a whipping boy for Joffrey and Tommen Baratheon
    Pate (orphan), an orphan taken in at the Crossroads inn

 

The answer to all "who is the best" questions is always Pate, or Pates.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Minsc said:

Loras and Garlan are likely tied for the Reach with both being the best at different aspects of combat.

If we are focusing on combat and less on jousting I believe Garlan is going to get the edge.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In Dorne, I think Daemon Sand and Ser Gerold Dayne can probably match up with/be included in a top 10 list of anyone left alive after ADWD.  I also think Ser Archibald Yronwood and Areo Hotah are formidable.  

Jason Mallister should be included along with Brynden Tully amongst river lords.  Mallister seems to have a good tourny rep and backed that up with impressive showings on the Trident and the Greyjoy rebellion in true combat situations.  However, both may be a little old to be truly elite after ADWD (especially Brynden).  

I think some of the people listed we don't really have proof for.  Randyll Tarly for instance - he's probably one of the finest commanders in Westeros; but, there's no proof that he's someone you'd want to choose in a Trial by Combat.  Similarly, I feel like Bronze Yohn is probably not in his prime any more/a little too old to be considered elite.  

Andrik the Unsmiling is noted as the best in the Isles.  Victarion, Ser Herras, and Qarl the Maid are probably the next best.  

In the Stormlands, Ser Richard Horpe is a candidate.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
11 hours ago, Legitimate_Bastard said:

I think Lady Whiskers is the champion Cat of Ice and Fire.

She defeated Ser Pounce and took the mouse.

After all,

Lady Whiskers lmao

Nah.  Ser Pounce, like any True Knight, is too chivalrous to fight a Lady.  It was still he who caught that villainous mouse.

Edited by Platypus Rex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

11 hours ago, Platypus Rex said:

Nah.  Ser Pounce, like any True Knight, is too chivalrous to fight a Lady.  It was still he who caught that villainous mouse.

I wonder how he blazons his coat of arms?

I imagine a rampaging feline standing over the corpse of a slain mouse on a field of red - similar to the Lannister arms but with a cat instead of a lion.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On ‎3‎/‎7‎/‎2019 at 4:13 PM, nyser1 said:

If we are focusing on combat and less on jousting I believe Garlan is going to get the edge.

You can use the lance in actual combat not just jousting. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Minsc said:

You can use the lance in actual combat not just jousting. 

Indeed. However, you it is an impractical weapon in close combat. Should the lance survive the first contact with the enemy it would likely be discarded for an alternate weapon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

North: Great Jon/ Mance Rayder

Iron Islands: The unsmiling guy and the Harlaw who holds one of the shield Islands currently. 

Riverlands: Hosteen Frey/ Black Walder maybe Ser Tytos Blackwood ? 

Vale: Bronze Yohn and Ser Lyn Corbray 

Reach: Ser Garlan Tyrell 

Stormlands: Balon Swann perhaps? And the bastard of nightsong. 

Westerlands: Jamie and Ser lyle Crackhall and the Cleagane brothers. 

Dorne: Oberyn and perhaps Darkstar? 

Essos: Grey worm and Dario 

Edited by Stormking902
Mistake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×