Forlong the Fat Posted May 22, 2019 Share Posted May 22, 2019 3 minutes ago, Apoplexy said: It hadnt been till season 8, which is one of my biggest criticisms of season 8. That's a very strange interpretation of a story that differentiated from the first season by killing so many important characters. But to get back to a point you overlooked; Jaime didn't completely fail. He couldn't stand the idea of his sister dying horribly alone, so he returned to help her escape or die with her. It's not like he went back and started pushing kids out of windows again. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RFL Posted May 22, 2019 Share Posted May 22, 2019 Ever seen the reaction of a recovering addict if they are told the supply is about to end forever? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kissdbyfire Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 On 5/21/2019 at 11:11 AM, #FreeGhost said: To me, this was almost troll-level insulting Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
It_spelt_Magalhaes Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 Was it trollish? I think so. It had zero chance of surviving Danygeddon, the damn book. But there it freaking is. Sigh. But mostly I'd like to treat it as the old 'history written by the winners' trope. Ser Brienne didn't exactly bullshit the whole thing. But, much like d&d's finest moments it certainly implied a lot of shit that wasn't true unless your level of delusion is 'Melisandre'. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
a girl knows nothing Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 3 hours ago, the Other Wolf said: She swore herself to Sansa, so wtf is she doing in KL? I do not have an issue with her being the one to write in the book, but she should be in Sansa's Queens Guard. Haha good point! I sort of forgot about that. Maybe the show did too? Or maybe since the North is a separate entity now, Sansa’s guard will be made up of only northmen/women. Brienne isn’t of the North so she wouldn’t be a part of that. I don’t know... I’m just spitballing here. I suppose this can be added to the list of other vows that became null and void at the end. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Forlong the Fat Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 1 minute ago, a girl knows nothing said: Haha good point! I sort of forgot about that. Maybe the show did too? Or maybe since the North is a separate entity now, Sansa’s guard will be made up of only northmen/women. Brienne isn’t of the North so she wouldn’t be a part of that. I don’t know... I’m just spitballing here. I suppose this can be added to the list of other vows that became null and void at the end. Or maybe Sansa happily agreed for her to fulfill her life's goal to be one of the most respected knights in the world, and to assist and protect Bran. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
the Other Wolf Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 1 minute ago, a girl knows nothing said: I sort of forgot about that. Maybe the show did too They clearly forgot about a LOT of sh!t. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
the Other Wolf Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 1 minute ago, Forlong the Fat said: Or maybe Sansa happily.... Would have taken 3 seconds for Sansa to release her of her vows. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Forlong the Fat Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 50 minutes ago, the Other Wolf said: Would have taken 3 seconds for Sansa to release her of her vows. Yeah. They should put in a bunch of extra scenes so the people who will assume the dumbest thing based on everything that happens won’t assume the dumbest things Except those people have an unlimited reserve of dumb assumptions. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DirePenguin Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 1 detail about Jaime that bothered me was that why the hell would Northern soldiers capture him... He was with them and fought along side them at Winterfell. After that it's not like he made an announcement to everyone like "HEY I'M ON CERSEI SIDE NOW". I mean if I'm part of that army and see Jaime there I'd even assume he traveled there with me you know... Did his name above his head somehow turned Red like in online MMO letting everyone know he's an enemy now? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
L’Age d’or Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 D&D completely shat the bed, but you are being paranoid if you see it as them giving one last fuck you to the audience. I myself liked it as one last reminder that the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard is actually a highly prestigious title, all previous Lord Commanders were sophisticated men who were more than just a good sword. The scene from the books when Jaime first gets familiar with it is one of favourites; so naturally I was happy about the inclusion of that scene. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nerevanin Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 I liked the scene a lot. It was really touching. Especially when Brienne admitted that Cersei was Jaime's true love (it was bullshit but it was touching). The part that slighly irritated me was that the book survived Dany's attack just like this. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apoplexy Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 11 hours ago, Forlong the Fat said: What does that have to do with whether it would be normal to complete their entries to reflect their ultimate fate, whether they were kicked out, castrated, dismissed or killed, as was done in the two examples I provided? Because up until now, the White Book records stories of members in context to their work as members of the KG. If the book records Barristan Selmy's exploits in Essos, then you have a point. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apoplexy Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 11 hours ago, Forlong the Fat said: That's a very strange interpretation of a story that differentiated from the first season by killing so many important characters. But to get back to a point you overlooked; Jaime didn't completely fail. He couldn't stand the idea of his sister dying horribly alone, so he returned to help her escape or die with her. It's not like he went back and started pushing kids out of windows again. The first season killed characters who's story arc was finished or who were largely secondary. As for Jaime, he may not have started flinging children from windows but his redemption arc heavily centered around him breaking free from cersei's control over him. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apoplexy Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 11 hours ago, RFL said: Ever seen the reaction of a recovering addict if they are told the supply is about to end forever? Again, with the specific case of Jaime Lannister, it was jarring and just poor writing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Apoplexy Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 2 hours ago, DirePenguin said: 1 detail about Jaime that bothered me was that why the hell would Northern soldiers capture him... He was with them and fought along side them at Winterfell. After that it's not like he made an announcement to everyone like "HEY I'M ON CERSEI SIDE NOW". I mean if I'm part of that army and see Jaime there I'd even assume he traveled there with me you know... Did his name above his head somehow turned Red like in online MMO letting everyone know he's an enemy now? Exactly. And let's just assume that somehow word reached them that Jaime lannister had left the north, why on earth would he not put the damn glove on the damn golden hand? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RFL Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 Quote Again, with the specific case of Jaime Lannister, it was jarring and just poor writing. You keep offering the fact that it was jarring as a premise to support that it was poor writing. I would argue that being jarring makes it more realistic to the actions of a relapsing addict. I've seen addicts move on, build a good life, be years from their last relapse and relapse over seemingly trivial things or even nothing that was identifiable. And let's just assume that somehow word reached them that Jaime lannister had left the north, why on earth would he not put the damn glove on the damn golden hand? Recall Sansa (or someone) had made the great announcement that Jaime would be staying as their "guest". That was a thinly veiled term for hostage. Also they addressed the hand. Tyrion specifically asked him and he mentioned Cersei once called him the stupidest of the Lannisters. We are so desperate to find the examples of poor writing that we are seeing enemies where there are none. There are plenty of examples of perplexing arcs here I'm just not unboard with the idea that Jaime's is one of them or that Brienne's writing in the book is either Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Forlong the Fat Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 3 hours ago, Apoplexy said: Because up until now, the White Book records stories of members in context to their work as members of the KG. If the book records Barristan Selmy's exploits in Essos, then you have a point. You just made that up. Why would you make something like that up? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Forlong the Fat Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 3 hours ago, Apoplexy said: The first season killed characters who's story arc was finished or who were largely secondary. As for Jaime, he may not have started flinging children from windows but his redemption arc heavily centered around him breaking free from cersei's control over him. Were Ned, Robb, and Catelyn secondary characters? Saying they only killed characters whose story arc was finished is a tautology so I have no response to it, other than to say that Jaime’s story arc also was complete when he died. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RFL Posted May 23, 2019 Share Posted May 23, 2019 Your arc is generally complete when you die. Sometimes, especially in times of war, our stories do not get a satisfying arc. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.