Jump to content

The Most Powerful House?


Recommended Posts

Historically, Targaryen. At the start of ASOIAF it is obviously Baratheon. Currently (at the end of ADWD) I think it is the Tyrells. However, one could make the case that Dany (and therefore House Targaryen) is the most powerful since she has the ultimate weapon : dragons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When are we speaking?

 

Look at soft and hard power and if we say at the start of "A Game of Thrones", I say we are looking at:

 

  • Lannisters
  • Baratheons (all branches together)
  • Stark
  • Tyrell
  • Hightower

 

In that order.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, nyser1 said:

When are we speaking?

 

Look at soft and hard power and if we say at the start of "A Game of Thrones", I say we are looking at:

 

  • Lannisters
  • Baratheons (all branches together)
  • Stark
  • Tyrell
  • Hightower

 

In that order.

 

Lannisters have gold. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Targaryens have distorted the long term power hierarchy in Westeros. The most interesting point in time to assess the comparative power of the Houses is probably 300BC, before Aegon’s landing. And at that point it would seem that the ranking was somewhat different to today.

It would seem the Starks were comparatively more powerful than they appear today, raising more men than any region except the Reach. Sure, the Lannisters 22000 men at the Field of Fire wasn’t their full strength, but given that populations were apparently significantly lower than today, it might well have been 60% or more of their entire strength. So a total strength of 30-35k for the Westerlands and a similar strength for the North seems quite reasonable at that point. With the Reach at perhaps 55-60k compared to today’s 100k.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
On 7/23/2020 at 5:08 PM, McGuv19 said:

Historically, Targaryen. At the start of ASOIAF it is obviously Baratheon. Currently (at the end of ADWD) I think it is the Tyrells. However, one could make the case that Dany (and therefore House Targaryen) is the most powerful since she has the ultimate weapon : dragons.

One could argue that the Martells are the most powerful, since they know how to kill dragons

Link to comment
Share on other sites

House Backfyre is the Most Powerful at the End,(Mostly Due to Varys Being A Member), With the Only Other House That Could Possibly Match them Being House Baelish (Due to Littlefinger Being the Only Member), All the Other Houses on the lists are KNOWN to be Powerful, So Whenever Something Terrible Happens to the Smallfolk, The Houses That Let Themselves Be KNOWN to Have Power are the Scapegoats, Whereas House Baelish is Really At Fault, But Most People Would Not Believe it, Because That Would Be Interpreted as the Powerful Houses Using A Weak House As A Scapegoat, When In Reality It Is Reversed, With House Baelish( The Weak House) Using the "Powerful Houses" As Scapegoats.(Fun Fact, Large Paragraphs Gain More Attention In Forums Due to Their Rarity, Among Other Short 1-4 Sentence Replies;) 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Stannis Baratheon* said:

House Backfyre is the Most Powerful at the End,(Mostly Due to Varys Being A Member), With the Only Other House That Could Possibly Match them Being House Baelish (Due to Littlefinger Being the Only Member), All the Other Houses on the lists are KNOWN to be Powerful, So Whenever Something Terrible Happens to the Smallfolk, The Houses That Let Themselves Be KNOWN to Have Power are the Scapegoats, Whereas House Baelish is Really At Fault, But Most People Would Not Believe it, Because That Would Be Interpreted as the Powerful Houses Using A Weak House As A Scapegoat, When In Reality It Is Reversed, With House Baelish( The Weak House) Using the "Powerful Houses" As Scapegoats.(Fun Fact, Large Paragraphs Gain More Attention In Forums Due to Their Rarity, Among Other Short 1-4 Sentence Replies;) 

Stannis the Mannis why you say this? You are the Mannis of House Baratheon. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...