Jump to content

[Book Spoilers] Lommy


Recommended Posts

Reading the books, I didn't feel much about Lommy's death; he was a minor character whose only purpose was to die brutally at the hands of the Lannisters.

Watching it on screen, I just can't let go of how young he is. While I know he's a child when I read it, actually seeing a little boy get stabbed through the throat is something else entirely.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think next episode they will find out very quickly that Lommy wasn't Gendry, judging by the preview. It looks like there will be some torture scenes, probably at the hands of The Tickler.

Also, the return of Gregor Clegane most likely! I hope the new actor does him justice. I liked Conan Stevens as Gregor in the few scenes he was in last season. Especially after his appearance in Spartacus Vengeance in a memorable episode. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think next episode they will find out very quickly that Lommy wasn't Gendry, judging by the preview. It looks like there will be some torture scenes, probably at the hands of The Tickler.

I sincerely hope they aren't torturing people in search of Gendry. There is no way that the other people in the group wouldn't give away his identity after a bit of torture. I hope they keep the torture relating to Beric's whereabouts, or some other external question.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I sincerely hope they aren't torturing people in search of Gendry. There is no way that the other people in the group wouldn't give away his identity after a bit of torture. I hope they keep the torture relating to Beric's whereabouts, or some other external question.

That is a very good point, I just don't know what they are going to do to tie in the end of the episode with Arya's line, into the next episode. I really hope Beric is mentioned, but nonbook fans may have forgot about him, so they will probably need a refresher about his role. I suppose we will find out on Sunday!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Right! And you know what else, why would Gendry give Lommy the helm, or let even let it out of his sights.

Ned Stark- "Who was your mom"

Gendry- "The helm is not for sale"

He loved that helm and wouldn't let Lommy have it as they try to escape and have a battle

I do not think Gendry let Lommy have the helm, I think he forgot it laying there when he run, and Lommy picked it up, probably he thought it was going to help him.

There is not way Arya's full list will get into the show, there are simply too many irrelevant characters like Raff on it. It would only confuse the wiewers and not really help the story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do not think Gendry let Lommy have the helm, I think he forgot it laying there when he run, and Lommy picked it up, probably he thought it was going to help him.

There is not way Arya's full list will get into the show, there are simply too many irrelevant characters like Raff on it. It would only confuse the wiewers and not really help the story.

I think Gendry forgot it as well, but it is still unlike him to do that.

I wouldn't say Raff is necessarily irrelevant. He is the one who kills the owner of the inn's son in Chiswyck's story, and he killed Lommy, granting him a spot on Arya's hit list. In AFFC Jaime's group goes to Harrenhal and he finds out info from Raff. He is noted as being much more well spoken than anyone else there, and Jaime takes him with him to Riverrun. He is now taking escorting Robin Ryger and Desmond Grell to Maidenpool so they can go to the wall. I am sure this will atleast be mentioned or come into play in the next novels.

My prediction is that they run into Nymeria, and she ends up killing Raff!

I know the entire list may confuse people, but I think it is great because it started out so large and it keeps dwindling. The list helps drive Arya, and it isn't that hard to follow in my opinion. But I am sure they will probably cut out some people from it unfortunately, Dunsen being a likely candidate for instance. I just don't want them to cut Raff out, or Chiswyck, or others.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok, he might not have been as irrelevant as a random commoner, he serves some purpose in the story, but when Edmure and Blackfish and the Reed children for all I know are cut, there is little possibility for Raff, Dunsen, Polliver and Tickler to be given a large parts of the story. One of them may do it, or they will merge them into one or two characters. Arya is already going around killing nobodies in the books, it would look ridiculous on screen, like her story is not connected with the others anymore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very good point on Edmure, Blackfish, and the Reeds. I have missed them a lot myself and they play huge roles in the book. I am just wishful thinking about the future in regards to her prayer list.

Though I don't know what you are referring to with her going around killing nobodies in the books.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think next episode they will find out very quickly that Lommy wasn't Gendry, judging by the preview. It looks like there will be some torture scenes, probably at the hands of The Tickler.

No please, no torture about Gendry !

I want so badly to hear: "Is there any gold ? Did you see Beric Dondarrion ? How many men were with him ? How many archers ? ..."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think Edmure and the others were cut totally from the series, I read a recent interview with one of D + D and he said there were some key characters they held off on introducing till next season just to avoid having too many new ones added at once to an already huge list. He used the phrase "delayed not cut" or something close to that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And also one thing to keep in mind is that there are characters in the second book who don’t appear this season, but are coming in later. It’s just about so many new characters introduced in the second season, so we saved some for the next season. They aren’t being omitted, they’re just being delayed.

Anyway, I think the first casting annoucments for season 3 will fall within two months...

About Arya's prayer: you can hear and see it at the very beginning of the late religion video: "Joffrey, Cersei, Ilyn Payne..." she says, apparently, she skips the titles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Reading the books, I didn't feel much about Lommy's death; he was a minor character whose only purpose was to die brutally at the hands of the Lannisters.

Watching it on screen, I just can't let go of how young he is. While I know he's a child when I read it, actually seeing a little boy get stabbed through the throat is something else entirely.

This. In the books, I figured he was a tough teenage lad. Still brutal, but not so much. In the show...dear God, how awful.

I forgot about the Tickler. :stillsick:

Well, I didn't forget, I just forgot that we had to witness him at work. I wonder if we'll see those peasant corpses strung up with entrails falling out, crows pecking eyes etc? That was a particularly nasty image from the book.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Think they are merging Raff and Polliver and change the Jaime getting introduced with Raff at Harrenhall with some other person maybe? Poliver picked up needle so i guess this would be him and the chapter with Arya and the Hound at the inn where they encounter Polliver and the Tickler is still plausable this way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...