jonny__bravo Posted April 2, 2013 Share Posted April 2, 2013 I agree with Mulled Vino, you can see the logic for the scene and placing Roose at HH but its the whirlwind tour of the Wester/Riverlands by Robb with his entire host thats problematic here. Before Tywin decides to march to the aid of the capital, Ser Kevan points out that Robb's host remained north of Ashemark, which tally's with Robb and Talisa going to the Crag to accept their surrender.Now if Robb and Roose know its the mountain and only a small garrsion that were left defending HH, then it stands to reason they know Tywin has left HH (whether they know about Stannis' defeat remains uncertain). Now if we specuate that Robb upon hearing of Hoster's death heads to Riverrun (much to Karstark's annoyance), from there (judging by the trailers "take his home, take his gold") plans an attack on Casterly Rock you have to wonder why he didn't pursue such an attack when he was near Ashemark initially. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.