Jump to content

Any historians/writers in Westeros at the moment ?


Yanninho

Recommended Posts

I often wonder if there are some producers of written content about what's going on as we live it in the saga. Maybe some maesters in Oldtown ?

Some intellectuals may have found their way in fancy courts advising and informing powerful lords, but aside from council members in King's Landing or some few known, we seem to the lack this information.

I know the story takes place in a medieval fantasy world where reading is not the most common skill in the world but literature has to exist in some kind of way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

History is mostly written after the fact, not while it happens. ;)

So yeah any of the literate people could be the future [ASOIAF-future] historians of the War(s) of the Five Kings.

Much of our knowledge about, e.g., the history of Rome comes from people who were politicians and actors while the big things happened, and only wrote their version of events down years later. Generals or diplomats who were too busy to write books while they were active, but had time and resources in their retirement to write it all down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In all likelihood, there are Maesters and Septons who are chronicling these events, just as they chronicled things like Aegon's conquest, Maegor's conflict with the Faith Militant, the Dance of Dragons etc.

And, given his intellectual interests, one could easily imagine Tyrion writing his own history of events, if he survives.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To be honest I wouldn't be suprised if there are maesters over in the Citadell who are on a kind of duty to record what goes on in Westeros while information is fairly fresh, witnesses can be accessed and so on, for the sake of creating relatively clear historical records of what happened.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To be honest I wouldn't be suprised if there are maesters over in the Citadell who are on a kind of duty to record what goes on in Westeros while information is fairly fresh, witnesses can be accessed and so on, for the sake of creating relatively clear historical records of what happened.

Perhaps, but the books that Tyrion and the other literate characters refer to don't really give the impression that historiography as practiced in the world of ASOIAF is a particularly well-structured or objective craft. The books are all referred to by their authors and people speak about their biases and omissions in a way that implies that is is well-known they aren't objective at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The books are all referred to by their authors and people speak about their biases and omissions in a way that implies that is is well-known they aren't objective at all.

That's exactly what happens with history books nowadays, isn't it?

ETA: Specially the ones that deal with current events. Or can't we find in the bookstores contradictory accounts of what's happening in Irak, Israel/Palestine, Chechenya,...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...

The Maesters live in a world of their own. If you're not in the Citadel, you wouldn't know what they are debating there. But I actually don't think there's much debate over history. I think very few Maesters really take much interest in it. But it would be interesting to read about Maesters in one book accusing another Maester for being wrong about stuff in his book.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

I agree with previous posters that the Maesters are recording events as they happen. There will also be another form of recording, though-the bards will be making songs about specific events: the Battle of Black Water Bay, the Red Wedding etc. These songs shouldn't be discounted as faulty sources of information, either; in the real Middle Ages, long-form songs like the "Song of the Cathar Wars" were important modes of transmission for specific events.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Perhaps we should differentiate between chroniclers and historians.

I'm sure there is a whole department at the Citadel tasked with chronicling events: In this year so-and-so was born, there was drought/flood/plague in these parts of the land, etc. Jaime's work with the White Book would also fall into this category.

As for history, we haven't seen Tywin Lannister or LF giving any interviews, or being careful about preserving documentation for posterity. Much the opposite, really. Varys probably destroys everything his little birds give him when he's done with it. Then he destroys the little birds. No maester even bothered to interview Catelyn or Brienne about Renly's death.

The Weterosi Historical Society really needs to get in contact with Bloodraven or Bran. The weirwoods are going to be the only source of inside information for later generations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...