Mr Smith Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 that Robb never got Jeyne with child? I'd be surprised if they'd do what they did to Talisa if Robb having a living heir was meant to be important, but its possible. Thoughts? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TomBadgerlock Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Almost definitely. Besides, Elio said he was 99% certain that the clue about the hips was just a mistake on GRRM's part. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Damon_Tor Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 that Robb never got Jeyne with child? I'd be surprised if they'd do what they did to Talisa if Robb having a living heir was meant to be important, but its possible. Thoughts?Seems that way, though the novels weren't exactly abuzz with evidence to the contrary. You know, seeing as her mother was sneaking her birth control disguised as a fertility elixir and all. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
~DarkHorse~ Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Probably, I can't see them changing something that drastically. An heir is too important to kill off. However, I'm curious about the Will that never happened and Jon being named Heir? Does this reveal the will has no importance to the story? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lebron James Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Pretty much Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Joker Of FunLand Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yep. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Newstar Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yup. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stallion That Mounts Texas Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Probably, I can't see them changing something that drastically. An heir is too important to kill off.However, I'm curious about the Will that never happened and Jon being named Heir? Does this reveal the will has no importance to the story?The will is with Lord Reed and Lord Reed has some other information that will trump the will. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MarieAntoinette Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yeah, I pretty sure that clue was a mistake on GRRM's part. I don't think they would change something this important. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Joey Beers Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 No heir. Just hair. Curly, and black. Humidity and Snow. Both resolves the same.North and South.No blame in the game. Just fame due to maim, ing.Tame,ingThe small folk into fealty.Gentrification,Cut your hair.Robb has no son.Ahhh!Snow bear!Jon.Has hair.Seen bear.Death stare.This was just a drunken dare.Test me.Test me.Best me. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StannisandDaeny Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Even though if you were part of the world, it'd be disturbing, I'm so happy Talisa died. It's even better that this does seem to mean, no Robb's heir from the traitor Westerling family will come into play (such a child would simply be smothered by her traitor mother or worse, turned against the North as a fake means to control it, they could brainwash it while he / she was young). Now I just need to see some Westerlings dying by Wolves and I'll be happy. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Independent George Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 that Robb never got Jeyne with child? I'd be surprised if they'd do what they did to Talisa if Robb having a living heir was meant to be important, but its possible. Thoughts?Yep. Though I'm sure there are some true believers who will retain hope. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
six Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 It doesn't imo, because they're not the same character. They made a point of making them into different characters and naming them differently. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kienn Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yep, just like it proves Bran is the only person ever anywhere to warg a human. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Joker Of FunLand Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yep, just like it proves Bran is the only person ever anywhere to warg a human.The producers know how the series will end, if they change something this big...it's because it's not important in the long run AKA Jeyne isn't pregnant.Then again, it could just be a total mind fuck directed at the readers. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Joker Of FunLand Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 It doesn't imo, because they're not the same character. They made a point of making them into different characters and naming them differently.True, but you'd think for 2 guys who know how GRRM will end it, that killing off Robb's heir would be a big decision...unless Robb's heir is either Jon or Bran/Rickon. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Joker Of FunLand Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 The will is with Lord Reed and Lord Reed has some other information that will trump the will.I doubt the information of 1 bannerman trumps the Will of the dead king. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cadiva Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 It doesn't imo, because they're not the same character. They made a point of making them into different characters and naming them differently.I agree with this, I don't understand why people amalgamate Jayne Westerling and Talisa into the same character, I think the show's made it pretty clear they're not supposed to be and that she was written as a TV show character specifically. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Runaway Penguin Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 Yeah, I pretty sure that clue was a mistake on GRRM's part. I don't think they would change something this important.To be frank, the clue suffered from over-analysis (as many minor details do). Cat didn't think in the books "she has wide hips", but "she has good hips" - that doesn't necessarily mean too wide, and for Jaime, being a male, her hips may look narrow (esp. if she generally didn't care much about herself since RW so she was probably a bit underfed as well). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Greiffenstein Posted June 3, 2013 Share Posted June 3, 2013 For a certain reason I was never convinced by the theory that Jeyne Westerling is pregnant. And that reason is Rickon. He doesn't do much in the books and seems even less important in the show. They could have easily cut his part out like they did with many others. But instead they even kept him in the 3rd season although he isn't even in the books anymore from that point on. I can think of only one reason why they did his: He will be the one to rebuild Winterfell and House Stark later on. But Rickon could never become Lord of Winterfell if Robb had a child. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.