Forgot your password?
Or sign in with one of these services
Ran, June 9, 2013 in E10: Mhysa
1,118 members have voted
What did you think?
Stannis is pretty much destroyed as a character my first thoughts. Has to be least closest character to his book version where stannis i books is in my top 5.
Agreed, they actually had him laugh!
8 because of Arya
I gave it a solid 7....pretty much setup for next season.
With a father like Tywin, who needs enemies. I think this episode will fuel the speculation that Tyrion is not really Tywin's.
Liked the Stannis scene. Everything else, not so much.
Well we got nothing from what was being expected, they just used the finale to tie up loose ends and set up season 4 a little. Nothing drastic at all in the episode..AT ALL
Maybe they should have left it unclear whether Jon Snow survived or not, so that the show watchers could feel the same agony as the book readers are now facing after book 5
No Coldhands? 3/10 did not like.
Best scene in the episode! Maisie Williams FTW!
Well, I expected to see LS at the end and also missed Coldhands, so that's why I gave it 8, because it was simply a chapter to tie things up for next season and nothing major happened.
What a let down.
Really liked it, but not sure the end scene was epic enough to leave us on.
S1 we had the dragons
S2 we has the White Walker with the army of he dead.
Seems just like an odd place to end it. Still really liked the episode though.
Sure it didn't have some of the scenes we wanted to see, but it set up Season 4 great, plus we'll still get those amazing scenes we want in season 4. I'm giving this one a 10.
You gotta think of it as an Unsullied point of view, they have Dany to cheer for now.
HBO has just given us the Best Television in a while.
I applaud the whole production cast and crew for Game of Thrones.
I gave it a 5.
After the RW episode, this one was a real let down. In fact, "Rains" should have been the finale for the season. There could have been a lot less Theon, which would have given time to tie up the loose ends and bring us to a decent concusion, rather than end with this episode, which felt more like season opener.
Always end a season on a show-stopper, and, given the amount of commentary I've heard outside these forums, "Rains" was definitely a show-stopper.
I'll give it an 8.
It was a good episode. I'm not going to let one little thing (the lack of Stoneheart) bring the rating down too much.
I think they're letting Cat's death sink in some more.
There were a ton of book differences. I know it's tough rounding out a season roughly 60-70% into the book its adapting, but a lot of the rounding out felt contrived. I thought the "Mhysa" thing with Dany was contrived and underwhelming compared to the mid season climax in Astapor. The Ygritte/Jon scene was implausible and weighed down by the cliche'd love story. The buddy/buddy Tyrion/Sansa scene was off. The Shae/Varys scene almost gave me a heart attack. I thought for a minute they were going to walk right into the abyss with changing things. It felt like D&D were trolling book readers.
Solid 7. Obviously it was going to be underwhelming coming off of 3x9. I thought the first half was very very good...especially the Roose/Walder and Ramsay/REEEEEEKKKKK scenes. Tyrion and Tywin had some good dialogue.
I liked the Dragonstone stuff, nothing groundbreaking there.
But jesus christ on a carrot, Dany's scene was terrible. Cheesy and out of place, the music was hilarious, the crowd surfing was abysmal.
I'm not docking points off for no Coldhands/Stoneheart because they can still appear. No point in complaining because a scene you expected to be in there was absent, I rate the material given.
Could've been better, could've been worse. Still was better than S2 finale, but as a S3 episode, it was pretty average.
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Already have an account? Sign in here.