Jump to content

KingMudd

Members
  • Content count

    147
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by KingMudd

  1. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    Once Brans gone then it wont be a Stark as King of the 7 kingdoms. The northerners chose an independent North so that it would always be a Stark that rules over them.
  2. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    I think that's the main problem with endings. There will always be some that are unhappy with how it happens. You can't please everyone and a really good ending for one person might be the worst ending for someone else. I actually didn't mind the show ending. It was rushed and needed a few more episodes but I wouldnt mind if that is the ending of the books, just more fleshed out. The more I think about the show now that it's over the more I realize that I might have enjoyed the last few seasons more if I wasn't so preoccupied with wanting my favourite characters to have good things happen to them and being annoyed when charatcers I didn't like got more focus. That's just me though and I know that a lot of people just didn't like it.
  3. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    He's really not. He's writing a story he wants to tell and people buy that story.
  4. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    You're one person though. Plenty of people like Jon Snow and don't like Dany. GRRM isn't writing the books for you.
  5. KingMudd

    HBO president speaks about the final season

    So would we Casey Bloys, so would we.
  6. Like almost every elective monarchy in our history then. It won't last as pretty much all elective monarchies go hereditary succession eventually.
  7. KingMudd

    Magical Drogon going to revive Daenerys

    Jon's not a bastard. He's a Targaryen. Jaehaerys II Targaryen had a Blackwood mother and this didn't make him any less of a Targaryen.
  8. Possibly, I could see it going either way TBH. I don't think Daenerys would have moved all the people into the city to use as a human shield though. Cersei says that if Daenerys wants to kill her then she'll have to take out all the smallfolk as well.
  9. KingMudd

    Arya the Explorer

    I spy with my little eye?
  10. The threats made by Sansa and Arya where about stopping people from killing Jon not about who was going to be King. Tyrion nominated Bran and the others said yes. They all could have disagreed and the meeting would have went on.
  11. It's different casting an actor though. D&D are hired to create a series which takes much more time and planning than an Actor being hired for one role. I agree that they would have known or been in talks years in advance.
  12. Thats very debatable. All these proposed endings I've read are trash and just what that one person wants. The ending we got was good it just needed a few more episodes.
  13. I guess Tyrion could be the valonqar. Tyrion told Jaime to take Cersei down there and thats the only reason they were down there. Cersei was also crying right before the roof caved in (the tears part) and then the life was choked from her by being crushed by the falling debris. Or not, who knows.
  14. KingMudd

    Anyone else feeling bummed about the show being over?

    Yeah. Been watching since Season 1 episode 1. Felt that after season 4 something was missing from the show but couldn't quite figure out what. Even though it wasn't as good as it had been I still looked forward to new episodes.
  15. KingMudd

    *SPOILERS* Jon useless information

    If Jon isn't ok with marrying his aunt, I don't think he would ride his dad.
  16. KingMudd

    Gendry?!

    It's not democracy it's an elective monarchy and going by our own history it isn't going to end well. Most elective monarchies ended up electing people from the same family and eventually introduced hereditary succession after a while. So Westeros most likely goes back to how it was in a few hundred years.
  17. KingMudd

    The Six Kingdoms

    They survived for thousands of years before the Targayens came over, so I think they'll do fine.
  18. You do realize that the Kingdom of Westeros is only 300 years old? The other six kingdoms have all been going for thousands of years so they are in the same position as the North. The Reach, Westerlands, Stormlands, Dorne, the Iron Islands and the Vale are all pretty much just as old or older than the North and were founded by First Men houses when the First Men came to Westeros via the Arm of Dorne.
  19. KingMudd

    Time to rewatch from the beginning

    Sorry I couldn't finish your comment, I pretty much turn off when anyone who hasn't written a successful fiction series accuses the person who did of pacing problems and making them too long.
  20. KingMudd

    Prediction for finale

    Thats wrong, just look at house Mormont. Maege has five daughters: her eldest and heir, Dacey; and Alysane, Lyra, Jorelle, and Lyanna, they all have the name Mormont. Sansa can very much have Stark children and the current line of Starks are decended from a woman anyway, Brandon the Daughterless's daughter. I'm pretty sure any of the houses in ASoIaF that are thousands of years old will have had at least one female carry the name on.
  21. KingMudd

    Are the starks finished?

    She could have a matrilineal marriage where all children born are of the mother's house.
  22. KingMudd

    Time to rewatch from the beginning

    Going by your own rules since you've never been on the best seller list and have never delivered a massively successful worldwide literary work I don't think you should be commenting on length and pacing of the novels.
  23. KingMudd

    Are the starks finished?

    That's what she'll do. Just like Maege Mormont had children that were Mormonts to continue on the name. The Starks have done it before with Brandon the Daughterless's daughter and her bastard son.
  24. KingMudd

    Time to rewatch from the beginning

    So you think someone can't offer a critique of something unless they have achieved the same or better? That's complete bullshit. I can see bad writing in TV shows as can plenty of others, you don't need to be a good writer to know when something is bad. Going by your logic you can't criticize anything. Ahh right you're just more intelligent than the average viewer.
×