I am so glad I found this thread as I have been thinking about this a lot lately.   I think @ravenous reader very much is on the right path with these quotes here: I fully agree with @ravenous reader that the transitive property here applies to Jaime "shall have [Dawn]. I also enjoyed this quote: But it steered me in another direction, toward another one handed warrior, Qhorin Halfhand.  Conisder these quotes: When Jon and LC Mormont are awaiting Qhorin, the chapte