Did Edmure save Robb's Life?
Edmure was torn apart by his nephew and his uncle, because he gave Tywin battle, he didn't want to allow Tywin to go West, he had success at it.
Let's pretend Tywin go West unmolested... How is Robb not fucked? He has less than 6.000 men, Tywin has close to 20.000, after Tywin cross de Golden Tooth, he will join the 4000 remaining from the battle of the camps, somewhere at casterly rock or lannisport Daven is reuniting Stafford's Host, massive advantage goest to the West army fighting at ho
Sorry, what is not?
Well first of all military scouting does not work like that. the greatest military scout in the Balkans is not going to be on the same level if he is dropped in the middle of China or the Sudan. Being the best scout in one place does not automatically make the you the best everywhere on the planet, even in the modern age were you can bridge a lot of gaps with the internet that is simply not going to be the case, there are just far too many variables involved. Actually