Jump to content

TheSeer27

Members
  • Content count

    113
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About TheSeer27

  • Rank
    Sellsword

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. So my question is directed towards anyone who read A Dance with Dragons when it came out, or had no prior knowledge of the show, or Jon's death when you went into the book. Unfortunately for me, I watched the show first and then got into the books, so I went into Dance knowing Jon was going to be stabbed. I know there are a lot of hints throughout the book that it was going to happen, mostly all of Melissandre's warnings. But as someone who read it fresh, were you surprised? Or did you totally see it coming a mile a way?
  2. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    So Mance killed the direwolf? For what reasoning?
  3. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    We have no evidence that Gared saw the Others. He could have took a horse and left them there when they went to explore the village. Also, how could the Others convince Gared to do this for him. They can't just talk to him. We can't assume he was spared. Being on horseback, its conceivable he glimpsed them from afar and just rode south. The direwolf either could have already been in the Wolfswood, or it could have made its way south on its own (guided by Bloodraven, or the COTF.) The tines being snapped on the antler is definitely peculiar. But we just have no evidence it was Gared. Why would he sacrifice the direwolf then stick around long enough to be caught, just to get beheaded and die anyway?
  4. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    So what are you saying? The Others spared Gared to kill the Direwolf? I agree, who sent the direwolf and how Gared escaped the Others is what we've all been wondering for years lol. Although now thinking about it, the direwolf being pregnant would make it weaker so maybe Gared or someone/something else could have slain it.
  5. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    There was a foot of antler in the direwolves throat. No there wasn't a dead stag, but they didn't exactly look for one either. Also, I don't believe Gared could kill a Direwolf.
  6. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    What about the stag that killed the Direwolf?
  7. TheSeer27

    Lyanna Stark: A Gift from Old Gods

    This always bugged me about the direwolves. The mother being Lyanna makes perfect sense. And now I feel pretty stupid not having noticed it sooner
  8. TheSeer27

    Satin

    Yea I found this out after I did a little research. Interesting about Lyn Corbray.
  9. TheSeer27

    Satin

    ^ignore that lol Satin was brought to the Wall when he was found in a dungeon in Gulltown. He never volunteered. Nor is it said what he did.
  10. TheSeer27

    Satin

  11. TheSeer27

    Satin

    I made a post in re-read project but realized I probably should have put it here. Who is he and who is he working for? Its said he came from a brothel in Old Town, which of course reeks of Marwyn. But would Marwyn need eyes at the Wall? Well it is a magical place, so it does make sense. But it seems Satin definitely had something to do with Jon being murdered. Satin was very bad at keeping Jon's fires lit, which means he was off doing something else. Possibly conferring with whoever he is working for. Also, it was odd that when he was being attacked, Jon couldn't get Long Claw out of its scabbard. Which very well could have been planned. If you are going to murder someone it makes sense to disarm them without their knowing. Of course Satin being Jon's squire would be the prime suspect. He handles Jon's sword all the time. But it doesn't seem like Satin was working with the mutiny of the NW that stabbed Jon. They all were very much against Jon taking him on as a squire, and generally looked down on him for being a whore. So, what's going on here?
  12. TheSeer27

    Baby swap

    I get all that. I just think its a little ridiculous that Stannis would "have them brought back". With everything thats going on he doesn't have time to chase after a baby or even lose some men chasing them down. He needs every man he can get at the Wall and fighting the Boltons. And I get that it was a part of Jon "killing the boy" in himself and becoming a man. I do like what you said about Shireen though. Very interesting!
  13. TheSeer27

    Baby swap

    Was the baby swap with Craster's kid and Mance's kid really necessary? I mean couldn't she have just taken them both lol. Its not like Stannis is gonna leave the wall and chase after them. I don't think George would do it without a reason, so what do you guys think the significance will be in later books? Just something more to confuse us?
  14. TheSeer27

    ghost of high heart prophecy

    Could be Tyrion as well now that I think a little bit more about it. "giant" of Lannister. But I like the LF idea best.
  15. TheSeer27

    ghost of high heart prophecy

    I like the savage giant being LF. But isn't his sigil a hummingbird? But it kinda makes sense, hes definitely a giant as in a major player in the game.
×