Imp Slap

Can I have some feedback on why my topic was rejected? I've checked over 25 pages of threads and while there are some topics about Theon (is he Azor Ahai, a fan thread, etc.) I couldn't find one discussing the believability of Reek. I'm not asking to be antagonistic, I'm genuinely interested in understanding the process as the whole shrouded in mystery feel makes the moderating seem whimsical and arbitrary at present.