KamiShikkaku

So if my thread contains clear spoiler warnings, is on-topic, and is not superfluous content, yet for some reason is not approved, what am I to make of that? I think the moderators should give reasons for not approving topics. I spent a good 20 minutes writing my last one, so I'm sure a moderator could spend 10 seconds to tell me what was wrong with it.

Yes, I'll agree that "do something about him" was a bad choice of words. The user is clearly very dedicated to the Wiki, and we wouldn't necessarily want to lose someone with such passion. Still, I think that we need to get it across to him (or her) in one way or another that the articles he's writing do not fit the guidelines, before he does the same with too many other pages.

Question: How long is too long? How detailed is too detailed? I would argue that the profile's of Green Grace, Alliser Thorne, Big Walder, Moqorro, Dusky Woman, Renak, Mormont's frickin raven, Lady Ryswell, Gilly, Shahaz, Strong Belwas, and all others edited several times each by the user "Dimadick" all pass the threshold of reasonable length and then smash it at least fivefold. Please look at Alliser's entry. It is ridiculous. Every scene Alliser is in has at least two paragraphs, and there are paragraphs about events that Alliser was not even present for, that barely have any baring on him. Here are the EIGHT PARAGRAPHS describing Alliser's meeting with the council in ACOK: Note that his sentence structuring is pretty bad too (eg. "He then manages a wane smile and asks Alliser to confirm the purpose of his mission. Which is that the Watch needs men.") I have little to no experience editing Wikis. Is there something that can be done about this guy?