-
Content count
2,625 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Articles
Everything posted by Dorian Martell's son
-
A New Husband for Catelyn
Dorian Martell's son replied to Tywin Manderly's topic in General (ASoIaF)
A wight. She is undead after all -
Nothing would have changed. Ned would still discover the twincest, threaten cersei and then beheaded. The story would continue as written
-
Did Ned Hear The Weirwood?
Dorian Martell's son replied to •Brandon Ice Eyes's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Yes. This is the complex type of foreshadowing that the author uses. Ned was dolmed from the very beginning. He ignored the message and killed the messenger with Ice. Later, his message was ignored and he was killed by ice. I disagree. Rivers is not wrong. He is quite clear about the past being the past. If he was wrong, Bran could have had a conversation with his dad, told him of the impending others invasion, the twincest and the folly of going to king's landing and seperating the family allowing Ned to rally the north, reinforce the watch, make peace with the wildlings, contact the children of the forest and unite humanity above the neck against the return of the ice demons effectively undoing the whole story before Dance. That would suck ass. So, the past is simply the past that a lucky few like Bran can see. That sight will allow him to reveal Jon's bio parentage. Have we seen bran climb anything since he fell? Bl,oodraven said he would never climb again, but he would fly, and bloodraven was correct. Bran-raven was talking to theon in real time. Not from the future to an unchangable past Bingo! I'll be in my bunk -
Yes, they are good. on the first read feast kinda sucked because there was no tyrion, dany or any other character I was used to. The second read was awesome
-
Hypothetical: Should Bran & Co have stayed at Winterfell after the sack?
Dorian Martell's son replied to trazayn's topic in General (ASoIaF)
no -
the strangler was in one fake stone. she probably has the hair net but there is no strangler left in it
-
If Renly lives, how does the war play out?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Eddard Waters's topic in General (ASoIaF)
He dies after he crushes Stannis and Stannis rallies so the story continues as written -
How do you think Tommen and Myrcella will die?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Selere's topic in General (ASoIaF)
well, the entire thing we shall not mention has come and gone while waiting for a single book, and while I am sure a few things may be different, the "big reveal" has been spoiled 3 years ago and George himself has stated on his blog that he may not finish the series even though he intends to do so. We have what we have -
How much did Bloodraven know about warging/greenseeing before meeting the Children of the Forest??
Dorian Martell's son replied to El Diego's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Lol -
How do you think Tommen and Myrcella will die?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Selere's topic in General (ASoIaF)
We know how they will die. suicide and poisoning. -
If Robb had declared for Stannis, what would have changed?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Canon Claude's topic in General (ASoIaF)
What did you say James, your comment seems to have retreated to the ether -
If Robb had declared for Stannis, what would have changed?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Canon Claude's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Nothing. Robb would still get killed at the red wedding to make the story work as written. -
if dragonglass & dragonsteel kills the ice walkers, what kills the fire walkers
Dorian Martell's son replied to Lady Winter Rose's topic in General (ASoIaF)
lances, swords, spears,arrows, falling, boulders, drowning, starvation. Fire wight is misleading. They are not dead, they are very much alive with all the weaknesses of regular people -
Who or what attacked Essos during The Long Night?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Mordor's topic in General (ASoIaF)
That was probably just the tales of the long night that changed and mutated over generations and thousands of leagues of travel. After something as destructive as the long night, with people starving and dying from the cold and famine, communication lines would not be very strong. -
Poll x2: Will Sandor Slay Robert Strong? ...or Slay A Dragon?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Platypus Rex's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Since we cannot speak about ASOIAF in other media formats, All I can say is that as of now in the books, at best Sandor is seriously injured on an island where nobody speaks or at worst dead and buried. Those two things do not lend themselves to killing much of anything, much less enormous reanimated corpses or giant flying fire breathing reptiles -
Poll x2: Will Sandor Slay Robert Strong? ...or Slay A Dragon?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Platypus Rex's topic in General (ASoIaF)
1: We will have to wait until the next book. Baseless speculation is just that. 2: We will have to wait until the next book. Baseless speculation is just that. -
Which Castles are the Best at Defending Dragons?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Shpati's topic in General (ASoIaF)
The Dornish holdfasts seemed to fare well in spite of three dragons attacking repeatedly -
I read it with no coffee first thing in the morning and made a mistake
-
We see The Golden company arrived in Westeros, not leaving Essos. Essos as a setting is done
-
If there is a FM plot yet to happen, It will involve the FM returning to kill Arya. Otherwise, Essos as a setting is over and done
-
we desperately need a second book so this forum can be used to discuss things that were actually in the books as opposed to fan fic
-
My Cold Hands Theory: Jon Snow
Dorian Martell's son replied to gendrybranaryandjon's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Man, 8 years between books and we have Juan Snow=Coldhands. I wonder what is next. Tyrion is the Night's King? Dany is cersei time traveling and warging Tywin's baby? -
The Tower Of Joy - 3 vs 3
Dorian Martell's son replied to FitzChivalry Fartseer's topic in General (ASoIaF)
I agree -
yet another clue in lemon gate and proof that R+L=J is false
-
Joffrey becomes King unopposed, what does his reign look like?
Dorian Martell's son replied to Eddard Waters's topic in General (ASoIaF)
shouldn't this be in forum games?