Jump to content

SerMudz

Members
  • Content count

    67
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About SerMudz

  • Rank
    Freerider

Recent Profile Visitors

347 profile views
  1. Considering the event that actually started the rebellion was the burning of Rickard Stark and the strangling of Brandon Stark, I fail to see how it was based on a lie.
  2. SerMudz

    How did The Reach lose?

    The show has always established House Lannister as by far the most powerful house in Westeros - they even have Tyrion in the episode commenting on how they have been the true power in Westeros for a long time. They are the richest, can raise the biggest army and have the best equipped and most highly trained forces. Not consistent with the books as the Westerlands is one of the smallest of the 7 kingdoms while the reach is huge and can raise a far larger host, but there you go. By comparison the Tyrells are established on the show as being the number 2 house right from the beginning, they are the second richest, can raise the second biggest army, and now according to Olenna can't actually fight that well as it's never been their forte. I think that's all the explanation they're gunna give for why the Tyrell's lost other than Tarly and possibly other Reach lords siding with The Lannisters. Also, the show seems to have decided that the War of the five Kings hasn't had much of an impact on The Lannisters forces. Unlike the books where they're on their last legs
  3. SerMudz

    How did The Reach lose?

    Pretty sure The Reach is downgraded in the show though. In the books they are said to be able to muster a maximum force of 90,000 but in the show they are consistently referred to as being the second strongest house after The Lannisters. When Tyrion said he expected 10,000 I thought that was just the number he expected to be at Casterly Rock not that the Lannisters only had that number in total Agreed that they should be far more weakened than they've been shown to be though...in the books the Lannisters have pretty much been demolished from all the fighting
  4. SerMudz

    [Book Spoilers] EP306 Discussion

    They do this and I'm done with the show.
×