So you know how most people believe that the real reason why Ned didn't tell his wife about Jon was because Jon was Rhaegar and Lyanna's son well I just thought up my own crackpot theory, that could explain why Ned didn't tell her! (Might not be true but give it a chance.)
What if Ned didn't tell Catelyn the truth because Brandon cheated on Catelyn with Ashara and Jon was born out of that? Or even worse...what if Brandon violated/raped Ashara and because Ned knows that Catelyn loved Brandon, he would never tell her that truth? And what if the baby that Ned found at the Tower and he promised to keep safe for Lyanna is someone like Dark Star, who Ned could have given to the Daynes when he went through the Dayne lands and Starfall? I know all this may seem crackpot or already stated before but I just thought this up a few minutes ago and I felt like I should wright it. But, what if Lyanna's promise was totally not what we expect at all? What if there was no baby or the baby died? That would sure validate a lot of theories out there that Dany is the PTWP, Aemon thought so before he died after all. Thanks for reading guys.
Edited by KingMaekarWasHere, 13 July 2014 - 08:07 PM.