SayGen

impulsive voting. Most people will come around. It wasn't a 1, but overall I agree it wasn't good either. Same thing with last episode, people loved it---it was nothing but half an episode of an action scene with Jon showing off his plot armor. It was rated highly. give it time and people will realize this episode was a little better, and last episode wasn't as good as the voters indicate. Margins will normalize.

I found them bland, and overly predictable. She was far too accepting of him, and didn't even test him or his loyalty. No mention of where the spider was, or attempts to retrieve him---nothing.

I can't believe how many people liked this episode...it was just a battle scene with a little bit of the good stuff thrown in at the middle. 7/10 and I was being generous.

10/10 MY VERY FIRST 10/10 I was super excited to see what was going on. Finally we got some real answers and set up some good plots. I was worried since I rated last episode so low (no not just cause of the Sansa scene) Hope next episode can carry the momentum.

you're your their there its it's They may all be unique but I don't type for a grade in some classroom, this is the internet and the purpose is to communicate. Don't troll.

So sad for Jorah, but Sansa situation though bleak is looking better---she has a fighting chance

Poor Jorah....I really liked him... he is top 10 on my signature :( Guess I'll have to start crossing names off :( 100% lost BSel, and who knows how long Jorah will last. If he knows the story of Stannis and his daughter perhaps he can get the same guys to look at him as look at Princess Shireen. Jorah soo good. He learned from his grievous mistakes (slave dealings/spying), if anyone should catch a break its him.

Your not alone, that's for sure. I was very underwhelmed about the sand snakes. I didn't like the obrera monologue at all. All she had to say was yes or no. I get why they had her say the backstory, but it was sooo out of flow with the scene. I will miss Selmy as well. :'( Wonder how the community as a whole ranks the sand snakes. I have hear so little good about them.

As audiences mature it becomes harder to suspend disbelief. A child can watch anything with wonder, adults can't. I like 'realistic' fantasy. Forgive the oxymoron, but I hope you do know what I mean. I hate when I'm like....that was just dumb and wouldn't happen. (Like when Arya and the hound got jumped by those 2 idiots after mercy killing the wounded guy) I literally stopped focusing on the show and wanted to facepalm. Having a realistic show, makes it easier to get into, it feels less cheesy and gimmicky.

They don't sell to survive, they sell cause it's more money than field labor.

People who age out of their prime are oft in denial they have diminished capability...this is not a new concept. Claiming he could cut them into pieces and actually doing it are different things padawon.

Not sure if it's related. May have been a worker outside talking about or to King Stanis.

LF now known as GOD. He must know EVERYTHING! All hail GOD LF!

Agree. And he did go out "As a knight" as he declared in KL. And more room for Tyrion as well (maybe).

9/10 Story was progressed Action scenes were on point. Glad Bariston went out fighting. Bron Jamie diagloue so good. Mormont/Tyrion set up well for the next part of their arcs. LF still alive Sansa still alive R+L=J Theory gaining momentum. Stanis is still the manest. Only things against the episide: Sandsnakes weak, esp the dialogue.

Yes LF must know EVERYTHING about EVERYONE...in fact we should start refering to LF as GOD. He also makes mistakes. This is likly one of them. Think about how important Sansa is to LF grand plans.....now explain why getting her killed helps him....... point set match.

Please, these posts are so off base. Sansa is CRITICAL to LF grand plans. It's one thing to throw her into a risky situation, getting slaughtered is another.

So people will question if it's true or not. Red herrings EVERYWHERE :)

Ah yes your right, I do that more often than I care to admit.

the 1 was Loras where she won her right to be in the Kingsgaurd via Renly. Rorge, what were his accomplishments again? Shagwell was crazy and even Jamie said he wasn't any good. http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Shagwell 2 bit mercenary on their best day, laughable sell swords any other day. Jamie was starved, beat, sleep deprived, unsheltered, shackled, Go back and read what he went through under Stark control. Wasn't even close to a fair fight. Also your confusing me with someone else, that or you just like to put words in the mouths of others. I do like Brienne, I just think she is over hyped by most of her 'fans'. Her story arc is great, and compelling....her fighting ability (or lack thereof) doesn't take away from that. Can you provide the melee location, I would be interested in rereading that bit. I recall it but not enough to pass judgment. Perhaps I'll change my mind after rereading it. Brianne was not nearly at the same disadvantage. please be serious, I know this is all books and fantasy, but come on. Sandor again, like Jamie was FAR from his best. Seems like she runs into her best challengers when they are at their lowest. Argue that.

the 1 was Loras where she won her right to be in the Kingsgaurd via Renly. Rorge, what were his accomplishments again? Shagwell was crazy and even Jamie said he wasn't any good. http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Shagwell 2 bit mercenary on their best day, laughable sell swords any other day. Jamie was starved, beat, sleep deprived, unsheltered, shackled, Go back and read what he went through under Stark control. Wasn't even close to a fair fight. Also your confusing me with someone else, that or you just like to put words in the mouths of others. I do like Brienne, I just think she is over hyped by most of her 'fans'. Her story arc is great, and compelling....her fighting ability (or lack thereof) doesn't take away from that. Can you provide the melee location, I would be interested in rereading that bit. I recall it but not enough to pass judgment. Perhaps I'll change my mind after rereading it. Brianne was not nearly at the same disadvantage. please be serious, I know this is all books and fantasy, but come on. Sandor again, like Jamie was FAR from his best. Seems like she runs into her best challengers when they are at their lowest. Argue that.

Not sure what your point 4 is. All your best picks are befuddling. Jaime hasn't proven capable since the losing of his hand. Brienne has only beaten one skilled opponent on even ground, and Sandor hasn't been mentioned since his potential cameo as a graveyard digger. Also do we know if Brianne is even still alive?