David Selig

That's all good, but it has nothing to do with the fact that Ros can not pass for Arya under any circustances ever. The age gap is too big, they look nothing alike, and she wouldn't have the first clue how to act like the daughter of Lord Stark. It would be a completely ridiculous plot development. Why would Roose accept her? Any girl of a close age to Arya would serve his goal way better.

Yes, they kept it.

Really good episode, much better than last week's IMO. I liked pretty much everything, even the Ros scene was decent, and somewhat necessary for non-readers to get what a ruthless bastard Littlefinger is. I guess I am ove of the few who liked Asha/Yara. Davos and Saan were good and the Stannis scenes worked better this time. The Yoren/Arya/Gendry scenes were really well done. Oh, and I love that Craster owned Jon again. ;) How the hell would this happen? The ages don't match at all. Nobody at all would be fooled which makes it pointless.

Great job, Xray, Xnixnix and Bafleyanne, this thread has been really helpful for me. thanks.