Jump to content

towerofjoy

Members
  • Posts

    112
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by towerofjoy

  1. My husband, non-book reader and casual watcher, figured out immediately they weren't the boys. When I asked where he thought they were, he didn't have a clue but figures they'd be pretty obvious out on the road.

    I like the Qarth changes, makes it more interesting. Cersei being so honest with Tyrion was a surprise but it won't last o course. Jon running around with his blue boys and Ygritte is somewhat annoying but a good set up for the next season or two.

    I can't quite figure out the Jeyne/talisa thing but think she's up to no good. Wonder if she'll have a change of heart later on and feel horrible about RW.

    And like the Tywin/Arya dynamic - and good to see Arya hasn't gone all Stockholm-y. Unlike her sister she knows better than to trust people just because they aren't threatening to rape/beat/kill her at every turn.

  2. I do really miss the general absence of animals - horses, dire wolves, dragons. I get all the reasons why but still a gap.

    That said, book Ghost was frequently separated from Jon and did his own thing. And book Summer and Shaggy were also separated from Bran and Rickon for most of COK. So it's not really a big departure.

    But Greywind was constantly with Robb - and this IS significant later. Also will be interesting if Greywind takes a dislike to Talisa if she really is a spy/in on the betrayal later. And if Cat notices and that's a source of tension between her an Robb.

    Even with the changes, I think the show will basically end up in the same place as the books at the end of the season.

  3. I think all the back-and-forth editing took away from the impact quite a bit. But did like the focus on all the Starks.

    1. Sansa beaten, almost raped and rescued by Sandor.

    2. Arya spotted by Baelish, Lorch and rescued by Jaqen.

    3. Bran and Rickon held captive by Theon and rescued by Osha

    4. Robb beguiled by Talisa and rescued from temptation (for now) by his mom.

    5. Jon beguiled by Ygritte and rescued from temptation (again for now!) by the cold.

×
×
  • Create New...