Mafia Game 81.5 - Murder in New Piddlehinton

[Masonity]

I asked for confirmation in my PM, when I sent it. :dunno:

Can you explain why exactly I'd lie about that?

[Pebble thats Stubby]

Monday. The you being willing to hammer Kalaw thing. at the end of the day yes you said you would hammer, but you where not convicned and you where basically waiting for Malc to show up. Malc showed up, and had kalaw in and innocnet band, like faraday. we needed 2 more votes. Kalaw was not in a position to hammer.

When Faraday removed his vote it was early in the day - which is when his quote is refereing to (I think) Ya know when we nearly lynched him for not playing ball and voting for an uncountered rolled player. No-one was gonna hammer at that time. there was too much of day left.

[Masonity]

And in case you all decide that I'm just, I don't know, lying for the sake of lying or something, remember the reason we don't have nights as such is because of time constraints. My changing target did not hold up the day start. If I had to guess, I'd guess that's why it went through.

[Pebble thats Stubby]

Monday and everyone I guess. Do you believe that Masonity is the kind of player who would fakely claimed to have guarded someone without first checking the timing of his posts to see if he could be arround at that time a reason to guard that player came up?

I think Massoinity is more careful than this when evil. Ask yourself what reasons he had to pick Faraday over other players to be his CI if he really is evil. Why not his master unless you believe Faraday is Masonity's master?

[Masonity]

And if Faraday is my master, why isn't the game already over? With Kalaw voting Pebble and us both actively posting, an evil me would have jumped straight on to pebble, closely followed by an evil Faraday. He then could have killed either Monday or Kalaw, then we vote the other one off tomorrow.

That's the key; it just doesn't make any sense. Other than as a last minute ploy to try to cast doubt I guess?

[House Dondarrion]

Pebble looks so good, I feel how difficult is keeping my vote constant.

[Masonity]

To be fair, Monday looks so bad everyone else looks good right now. :P

[Pebble thats Stubby]

I would guess the mix up with the kill would be beacue the Mods not being arround when day ended. read their PM's forgot or mixed up the times. Posted the scene, then realised their mistake. of course by then its too late to correct the real death so they let it slip?

[Masonity]

Mix up with the kill? Is that a killer slip Pebbles

Wow.

[Masonity]

And to think I thought Monday looked bad :s

[Pebble thats Stubby]

Yeah mix up with the kill if you had guarded the killer, there would be no kill.

Yes I think Kalaw is more likely the killer and monday the symp.

[Masonity]

Monday Okay I can buy that, vote moved back.

[Monday]

Monday and everyone I guess. Do you believe that Masonity is the kind of player who would fakely claimed to have guarded someone without first checking the timing of his posts to see if he could be arround at that time a reason to guard that player came up?

I think Massoinity is more careful than this when evil. Ask yourself what reasons he had to pick Faraday over other players to be his CI if he really is evil. Why not his master unless you believe Faraday is Masonity's master?

I don't know what kind of player he is. I've played 2 games with him and he was NKed or lynched real early in both of them I think. I don't think he's been guilty in any games I've played.

It has crossed my mind that faraday could be his master, but I haven't really organized my thoughts. There is a lot going on around here today. My phone is ringing off the hook. I'll be back in a hour or two.

But this I know, unless there was a mod mistake, Masonity did not guard Faraday.

[Masonity]

I'm not sure I'd be comfortable using that logic. If it won us the game, we're winning from a mod slip up. I'm much more likely to think that they simply took the spirit of the no night thing. I'm still more comfortable with my monday vote.

[Masonity]

Are you claiming a role? I'm pretty sure that that's both a) the only way you'd know for sure, and b ) fairly typical last resort stuff here for a killer :-p

edit: I don't like the "Well it's this or this. Bye I have to go!" either.

[Masonity]

For the record, if we hadn't lynched stevonicus, we wouldn't have this problem anyway. We'd know for sure if all of the symps were dead at this point. :-p

Now we're still stuck not knowing if it's a 3-4 or a 2-5 :(

[Pebble thats Stubby]

It has crossed my mind that faraday could be his master, but I haven't really organized my thoughts. There is a lot going on around here today. My phone is ringing off the hook. I'll be back in a hour or two.

But this I know, unless there was a mod mistake, Masonity did not guard Faraday.

If Faraday and Masonity where both evil I Monday would have been lynched and the the game would be over

changed I to Monday. yeah I'm getting confused who had the votes

[Pebble thats Stubby]

Kalaw lets see if you will follow me on your Master.

[Pebble thats Stubby]

In case its not clear I'm talking to Monday in the post above. anthough feel free to vote your evil self kalaw

[HT Reddy]

Possibly.

He's down as not with Monday symply* because he had him in tier 1 and was pushing for him at one point, but I guess you've claimed you'd do the same thing, so it isn't entirely sympossible**.

*Yes, I know, groan, bad joke.

**Okay, doing it again in the same sentence was quite symply unforgivable.

Note to players: further puns of this magnitude of awfulness will result in modkills. No exceptions.

Also, night actions have to be in by the end of the day, not before the morning scene is posted. There was no mod slip-up last night, the actions in place when the hammer vote fell were carried out.