Criston of House Shapper

League of Thrones: Round 13, now with 48 characters

158 posts in this topic

The results of the round 2 matches are:

[1] Mance Rayder   vs.   [1] Jon Snow   2-9

[1] Arya Stark   vs.  [1] Sansa Stark   10-1

[5] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [5] Samwell Tarly   6-5

[5] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [8] Catelyn Tully   10-1

[8] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [8] Brandon Stark   9-2

[8] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [12] Doran Martell   4-7

[12] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Petyr Baelish   8-3

[12] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [12] Daenerys Targaryen   3-8

[17] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [17] Renly Baratheon   11-0

[17] Aemon Targaryen   vs.   [17] Eddison Tollett   6-5

[17] Brienne Tarth   vs.   [22] Robb Stark   8-3

[22] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [22] Cersei Lannister   10-1

[22] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [26] Wyman Manderly   7-4

[26] Barristan Selmy   vs.   [26] Eddard Stark   3-8

[29] Brynden Tully   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont   7-4

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Varys   4-7

 

Sandor whitewashed his opponent Renly and therefore wins the  "Lord Commander of the Kingsguard"-award.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The rankings after round 2 now are as follows:

 

1. Arya Stark 179.80
2. Jon Snow 170.71
3. Tyrion Lannister 168.69
4. Davos Seaworth 148.48
5. Sandor Clegane 144.44
6. Jaime Lannister 132.32
7. Daenerys Targaryen 128.28
7. Stannis Baratheon 128.28
9. Oberyn Martell 124.24
10. Samwell Tarly 123.23
11. Doran Martell 119.19
12. Brienne Tarth 117.17
13. Mance Rayder 107.07
14. Asha Greyjoy 103.03
15. Aemon Targaryen 98.99
16. Sansa Stark 97.98
17. Theon Greyjoy 96.97
18. Eddard Stark 94.95
19. Eddison Tollett 89.90
20. Brandon Stark 84.85
21. Petyr Baelish 82.83
21. Tormund Giantsbane 82.83
23. Catelyn Tully 75.76
24. Brynden Tully 74.75
24. Varys 74.75
26. Robb Stark 60.61
27. Wyman Manderly 58.59
28. Barristan Selmy 49.49
29. Jorah Mormont 47.47
29. Yoren 47.47
31. Renly Baratheon 44.44
32. Cersei Lannister 42.42

 

Arya remains at number 1 after a decisive victory against Sansa and wins the "Lord of the Seven Kingdoms"-award for the second month in a row. Jon receives the first ever "Hand of the King"-award as he is in second place.

Meanwhile Cersei has fallen to last place after getting destroyed by Oberyn and gets the "Black Cells"-award.

Oberyn jumps from number 22 all the way to number 9 and therefore wins the "Chaos is a ladder"-award. Meanwhile Catelyn (from 8 to 23) and Sansa (from 1 to 16) both lose 15 spots, and share the "Chaos is a pit"-award.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The matches for round 3 were determined by character's [rank], with neighbouring characters going up against each other. Ties were broken by a random draw (Brynden/Varys):

 

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

 

Round 3 will run for roughly a month, which means until 31st May. As usual it may last a bit longer than that, depending on when I have time to do the calculations. Thanks in advance to those of you who vote and have fun. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My choices in bold:

 

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark (this one was tough)

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully ~This is choosing between two evils.

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Edited by Jon's Queen Consort

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy 

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks to everyone who voted so far. :)

The current round will remain open until some point on Thursday, so if you want to vote, you can do so until then or edit your posts if you've already voted and aren't happy with your choices anymore.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The results of the round 3 matches are:

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [2] Jon Snow   5-6

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [4] Davos Seaworth   7-4

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Jaime Lannister   6-5

[7] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   8-3

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Samwell Tarly   6-5

[11] Doran Martell   vs.   [12] Brienne Tarth   3-8

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Asha Greyjoy   6-5

[15] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Sansa Stark   3-8

[17] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Eddard Stark   3-8

[19] Eddison Tollett   vs.   [20] Brandon Stark (Bran)   4-7

[21] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [21] Tormund Giantsbane   6-5

[23] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [24] Brynden Tully   6-5

[24] Varys   vs.   [26] Robb Stark   6-5

[27] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy   5-6

[29] Yoren   vs.   [29] Jorah Mormont   4-7

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister   5-6

 

Stannis, Brienne, Sansa and Ned all beat their opponents 8-3 and therefore share the  "Lord Commander of the Kingsguard"-award.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The rankings after round 3 now are as follows:

 

1. Tyrion Lannister 232.32
2. Arya Stark 225.25
2. Jon Snow 225.25
4. Stannis Baratheon 201.01
5. Sandor Clegane 198.99
6. Brienne Tarth 189.90
7. Davos Seaworth 184.85
8. Oberyn Martell 178.79
9. Jaime Lannister 177.78
10. Sansa Stark 170.71
11. Samwell Tarly 168.69
12. Eddard Stark 167.68
13. Mance Rayder 161.62
14. Daenerys Targaryen 155.56
15. Asha Greyjoy 148.48
15. Brandon Stark 148.48
17. Doran Martell 146.46
18. Petyr Baelish 137.37
19. Catelyn Tully 130.30
20. Varys 129.29
21. Tormund Giantsbane 128.28
22. Aemon Targaryen 126.26
22. Eddison Tollett 126.26
24. Theon Greyjoy 124.24
25. Brynden Tully 120.20
26. Jorah Mormont 111.11
27. Robb Stark 106.06
28. Wyman Manderly 104.04
28. Barristan Selmy 104.04
30. Cersei Lannister 96.97
31. Renly Baratheon 89.90
32. Yoren 83.84

 

Tyrion rises to number 1 and wins the "Lord of the Seven Kingdoms"-award. Jon and Arya share the "Hand of the King"-award as they are in second place. this is the second time in a row for Jon.

Yoren has fallen to last place and gets the "Black Cells"-award.

Brienne (from 12 to 6), Sansa (from 16 to 10) and Ned (from 18 to 12) climb 6 spots and win the "Chaos is a ladder"-award. On the other hand we see Dany (from 7 to 14), Aemon (from 15 to 22) and Theon (from 17 to 24) fall 7 spots, which earns them the "Chaos is a pit"-award.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The matches for round 4 were determined by character's [rank], with neighbouring characters going up against each other, with exceptions where they were already matched up in an earlier round. Ties were broken by a random draw:

 

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

 

Round 4 will run for roughly a month, which means until 30th June. As usual it may last a bit longer than that, depending on when I have time to do the calculations.

We had a discussion a while ago about how to avoid characters who lose all the time and are a waste of a spot. After thinking about it for a while I have decided on a solution that should be practical. From now on characters need to reach an average of 20% of the votes for the first five rounds, which equals to 100 points. If a character reaches 100 points within the first five rounds, they are safe forever. If a character doesn't reach that quota, he's out and is replaced with a different person.

Right now everyone has reached 100 points already, except Cersei, Renly and Yoren, but they are very close, too. If any of them don't make it in round 4, there will be a vote for who should replace the 1-2 characters in question (mathematically, it can't be all 3 because Renly and Yoren are fighting each other right now). If they then reach the 100 points in round 5, they will stay and the whole vote will have been for nothing. :D

This doesn't mean that there won't be new characters ever; I'm planning to expand this significantly after round 12. This rule will affect those new people, say if Penny were to be selected and then gets 0 points for five rounds in a row, she will be out.

What do you guys think? Is this suitable?

Thanks in advance to those of you who vote and have fun. :)

Edited by Criston of House Shapper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

3 hours ago, Criston of House Shapper said:

We had a discussion a while ago about how to avoid characters who lose all the time and are a waste of a spot. After thinking about it for a while I have decided on a solution that should be practical. From now on characters need to reach an average of 20% of the votes for the first five rounds, which equals to 100 points. If a character reaches 100 points within the first five rounds, they are safe forever. If a character doesn't reach that quota, he's out and is replaced with a different person.

What do you guys think? Is this suitable?

I think that creating a threshold at 100 is a mistake. Because of the way matchups are created, pitting low scorers against eachother creates a situation where low scorers will (on average) receive 50% of the votes against other low scorers. This means that after only 3 rounds, even unpopular characters have passed the 100-point benchmark. And it is nearly guaranteed that all will pass the benchmark after 5 rounds. I think a more appropriate benchmark would be 150-175 (30-35%) meaning they lose by something closer to a 2/3 majority.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.