Jump to content

the Other Wolf

  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

1,918 profile views

the Other Wolf's Achievements


Squire (4/8)

  1. I dont see Sam burning anything down because he gets his hand on a glass candle. IMHO, it would be more likely that Sam goes to the library and tries to find ALL the info he can before jumping in the deep end and try's to light a candle. p.s. OP, Thank you for a future what if! I really do not like the what if the story is changed posts, e.g. what if Ned goes to the wall vs losing his head. I think that is fan fiction and should not be part of a book discussion. We should be having a discussion on what our interpretation of how the story will unfold going forward or what we think how a past event may influence others going forward. All via book canon. Just like an "in person" book club would do. (Book clubs discuss the story and its implications, they do not rewrite the story.)
  2. People stopped caring long ago about this being the book forum.
  3. From @mormont We understand that developments in the TV show may or may not turn out to be relevant to the plot of future books. Accordingly, they may or may not be spoilers for future books. Our policy on this is precautionary and is an extension of our existing policy on show/book discussion. Discussion of the show should go in the show forums: this includes discussion of plot points from the series, and whether they tell us anything about the future direction of the books.
  4. Well it is the BOOK forum and they are two different stories and there is a separate section to discuss show stuff where no one will mind if you combine the stories there.
  5. Not sure if you are aware, but this is the book forum and this Night King character is not in the books.
  6. How is it stupid to not bring up stuff that is not in the books in the book forum?
  7. You have been here a year and still do not know this is the BOOK ONLY section of the forum!? Not to mention this character is not even in the books.
  8. This is the book forum. Where did any of this happen in the books?
  9. Sweet summer child. A lot of posters could clearly care less, especially those introduced by the abomination. Besides, the moderators gave up a long time ago.
  10. I remember a time when the show was not allowed to be discussed here. It is sad that the moderators gave up a long time ago.
  11. If it's not in the books, it's Fan Fiction. 

  12. If it's not in the books, it's Fan Fiction. 

  • Create New...