Impbread

Sorry didn’t read other posts

She already had a bastard on her small council. Aurane waters. So I doubt that will be a big deal

Yes but he could have named. A champion. And if the champion dies just do the shadow baby. To the posters point I do not think that this was necessary he could have left a s fraction of his enormous host to continue the siege as well.

He offered single combat after Renly was dead. So there is that.

It’s called a betrothal. It happens all the time. They wouldn’t necessarily be below the Tullys they would be part of the kings family and thus would have his ear.

Those fits only happen because he didn’t get to make the bad man fly. If he had he would be fine. There would be zero crime in the Vale if he were lord because they would know that they were going to fly.

This may Have mentioned up thread but maybe the dishonor in Barry’s mind was her not being crowned the queen of love and beauty. She was slighted. Maybe that’s what Barry meant when he said she was dishonored so she turned to the one person that she felt she was the most beutiful. I know it is a big stretch.

Sweet Robin is going to be the next winged night. Why wouldn’t he be capable of ruling the Vale?

Stannis' men did not rape many wildlings after they won because they knew their king would not accept it. So you could therefore assume that Robb's men may have in fact acted better then Tywins Stannis' men did not rape many wildlings after they won because they knew their king would not accept it. So you could therefore assume that Robb's men may have in fact acted better then Tywins

Im not sure if at has been mentioned up thread or not but the Targaryens broke their marriage with Barratheons during Aegon the V's rule. The Baratheons openly rebelled. Like real men with honor do. They did not pretend to be ok with it and then lure them in and savagely butcher them. They did not just kill these men. They also desecrated their bodies when they were done. As other posters have stated this event is universally looked down upon as an act of villainy not a justifiable revenge.

The aegon fort was wood.....

Benjen Stark is a goner for sure next book. Probably Rickon also

Benjen is so dead next book

Nobody thinks any Starks will die?

Ha! was just going to type that. Cheers!