Jump to content

TheLastWolf

Members
  • Posts

    3,554
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TheLastWolf

  1. ... and here you have lost me. Not only did MaRey Sue have zero Skywalker blood, she didn't really have a meaningful relationship with any of them, either, due to the piss-poor writing of the sequels Rey ( Daisy ridley) had zero Skywalker blood, but no meaningful relationship with Skywalkers??? With Luke and Leia?? Palpatine got his ass kicked and at last Rey answers to the name of Rey Skywalker. It's a damn Skywalker saga for chrissakes!!
  2. , though I have contributed to some of the crackpots, both to RLJ and alternative parentage theories. I think that the Jon parentage theories must end, or at least take a break. Because one thing is for sure, Jon is Ned's son and a true Stark with their First men heritage. Not biologically (though that is not to be dismissed outright), but I mean in every other sense. Hope you get the gist. Let Jon's biological parents be Rhaegar-Lyanna or Brandon/Ned-Lyanna (that gross incest ship) or Howland-Lyanna or Mance-Lyanna or Ned-Ashara or Ned-Wylla or anydamnbody like Mata Hari and Sauron ..... .... but Jon's father in every way was Ned and will be Ned. Contributing 23 chromosomes (the rest is surely Stark blood as is evident in Jon's appearance) is not gonna make Rhaegar the papa. Like how Rey chose to be a Skywalker when she was a Palpatine by blood. There is always another choice. Maybe the revealing of his parentage will have political repurcussions, but not in his character. Jon is not gonna go Edric storm on Rhaegar (if R is the daddy and its revealed). Moreover Jon could have been born with some of his non-stark parent's traits (Lyanna's lover or Ned's) but Nature and chance chose him to be a Stark and that is what he is and what he will be. Jon (Stark) will be the alpha direwolf of his pack and the Rains of Castamere will be forgotten after the Boltons and Freys are gone through. Maybe Red wedding 2.0 or something. There are a lot of characters hungry for revenge, from Arya and Nymeria's pack to UnCat Stoneheart and the BwB, Jon Stark/Snow/ Targ/Reed/plain stark/Rayder/Dayne/Trump etc etc to Rickon of Skagos (with Cannibals, that is important) to Alayne/Sansa with the Vale,so there is absolutely no way the Freys and Boltons are not going to get their asses whupped (or at least an attempt will be made) My like of the North and hatred of the slimy backstabbing cowardly opportunistic traitors has nothing to do with what is going to happen to the latter. And I bet my ass it will. To sum up, Jon is Ned's son in all but... genetics. (And that may also be wrong if Ned ends up being Jon's biological dad as from the beginning )
  3. I asked more or less the same thing to @lehutinin my alternative parentage theory with Howland Reed as daddy. Godric Borrel seems to be a person who does all thinks after carefully judging the risks and profits for him in it. If Godric lied and spread lies about Wylla, then Ned had to have made him happy (hope u know what I mean) somehow. But some believe Borrel is one of the few who knows Jon's parentage, I think it unlikely. Ned wouldn't trust his own wife, why would he put faith in that cunning fatso? Though one more potential person aware of Jon's parentage would be nice to bolster Jon's claim ( to legitimacy, if not the Iron throne or KITN) Yep
  4. Sorry. Got it into my head that your gender was listed as female. My bad. What are those rules @Ran ??? Why does the software archives topics/threads with a dozen posts/replies only, while some thread/topics with replies numbering in hundreds are not archived? These are my real questions now ....Lord @Ran
  5. One very small question.... To Lady @Ran I've seen a lot of threads getting archived after 200-300 replies. Some even below 10. Do you archive the threads when they're dead? Or when you feel that they are dead? I've seen some really inconsequential topics archived after a few replies, while some really great and longly discussed are not. Can you pleased explain to me the reasons, requirements and other factors for a topic to be archived?
  6. Harvey Dent —Sandor Clegane THE JOKER - Smiling Knight Batman /Bruce Wayne-Eddard Scarecrow /what's his name - Jaime Ra'as AL ghul - Bloodraven..... Kinda Shiera/Quaithe - Miranda/Talia Lucius Fox - Howland Reed Gordon - Umber/Flint/Norrey/? Robin - Jon/Benjen . . . Oh! Forgot - Master Luwin as Alfred Any more??
  7. Aerys being Jon's father is crazy.......but possible. See the post by @Orm in https://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/157222-grrms-world-and-its-resemblances-to-our-real-one-from-religion-to-politics-and-geography-to-wildlife/ If Rhaegar is Jormungadr and Robert is Thor, then Aerys is Loki. Then Fenrir/s wolf is Jon.
  8. I'm not sure if this fits into this thread, but anyway......
  9. It was Ned's grandma who was half Skagosi and half flint(they sealed the Skagos rebellion with a marriage like joffrey and margaery) it's a whole other thread though
  10. Yet for all our discussions, Jon could could end up being Brandon and Ashara's bastard (remember Barristan telling about her getting dishonored at Harrenhal)
  11. Just finished ADWD again for the third time, the whole series re-read is fascinating as ever. Look out for my Topics and I promise that I shall not fail to deliver...the most interesting ones...and for this I say "A Lannister always pays his debts" ..FYI-I'm 1/64th a Lannister.;)

×
×
  • Create New...