Jump to content

Gerg Sknab

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Gerg Sknab

  • Rank

Recent Profile Visitors

728 profile views
  1. Gerg Sknab

    Tyrek Lannister theories?

    More concerned on whether Gerion will show up. Tyrek is a well worn bloody smeer on Flea Bottom's cart paths Ermesande can vouch for that fact.
  2. Gerg Sknab

    Jon Snow's Real Name

    Huh? How is that? You know full well Reed heard Stark's call to Banners and answered the call. Just that fact makes all but impossible for Reed to be Meera's father as the rebellion lasted close to a year and Stark's tour to Storm's End, and the Tower of Joy would add another two months .
  3. Gerg Sknab

    ''Details'' you wish to see picked up before Asoiaf ends

    The firewyrms of Winterfell
  4. Gerg Sknab

    Cast in series

    Are there any threads discussing the Cast In series by Michelle Sagara?
  5. Gerg Sknab

    Fair Compensation for House Frey

    Frey's compensation is laid out by Tywin Lannister and Frey accepted it. Lannister had previously made agreement with Roose Bolton setting out Frey compensation,. The reality is that Bolton and Baelish are the power and Frey is in effect vassal holding three castles. Shucks Frey's compensation makes him less of an influence what with the Spicers and the Westerlings taking profitable castles on easily fordable forks. Frey had to agree to Bolton marrying the Frey daughter of his choice thereby guaranteeing Bolton a profitable marriage at the cost of Walder Frey.
  6. Gerg Sknab

    Is Walder Frey the smartest man in Westeros?

    Lets see Ryman by BwB, Marrett by BwB,, Peter Pymple by BwB Tytos by Sandor Clegane + two others, Symond, Jared, Rhaeger by Manderley, Aegon by Catelyn, Little Walder by unknown, Aenys by Crowsfoot Umber's boys Hosteen who maybe alive or dead depending which version of either ADWD or ACOK GRRM you read, andCleos by the Brave Companions anymore?
  7. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Vengence and war as stated by Merrett and Walder Walder is miffed he hasn't been taken seriously therefore he acts literally including bloviation and exaggeration. Symond Jarred and Rhaegar that is not the north but a single house Manderley. The Ryswell's, Dustin's (Barbey does have plans however does not have strength to bring to fruition), Cerwyn's, Karstark's and half the Umbers may not be pleased with the Frey's however they are backing the Bolton's and until the Bolton's lose the Frey's are safe. Read the Catelyn chapter with rains of Castlemere and tell me BwB got a musician in. Read the next chapter with Pavillions burning with Frey's rushing out to confront northmen and virtually butcher them and tell me BwB had infiltrated with whores that is an even bigger fallacy than Greywind dead.
  8. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Fanciful fan therories? on multiple threads? You don't like Rickon, Balerion the black cat, Jon Snow Sisterton/ Davos Asha/Theon/ Stannis, Danerys,/Barristan Aegon/ Connington, Arianne/ Sand Snakes, Marwyn, Sansa/Alayne and Arya Povs or that Victarian and Morroq never make it out of Mereen and they'll be replaced by Euron and Benerro or that Robert Strong will lose cersci's trial after being feathered with 50 to100 arrows from Black Balaq and his Dragon bone and Yew bowsmen while Margery is innocent in the faith's view and is free to become queen consort to Tommen kinda questionable considering Twow or ADOS hasn't been published yet.
  9. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    The BwB had spent several Arya chapters getting no where in their hunt for Arya and the Hound . What makes you think they could possibly infiltrate a pair of locked down castles with three large pavilions under flame? Remember there are at 500 Boltons, 300 Karstarks and innumerable Freys watching for any infiltration, shucks the Hound was lucky to through and drop three Freys before whacking Arya and getting away. he only places that mention the death of greywind are in Davos by Dragonstone smallfolk (lord of Light followers) Marrett's epilogue by the BwB again Lord of Light followers, Danerys at the House of the undead as precognition again emphasizing fire andfinally a Tyrion chapter in whichhe is kind to Sansa in not mentioning the Frey Fallacy. It is the Freys pushing the scenario no one else they made their bed with the Lannister's, Bolton's, Spicer's and Westerling's what diference is it to be despised by the rest of the north or the Riverlands for that matter?
  10. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Raynald escaped greywind freed from the net was not to far behind just because frey's say so doesn't make so.
  11. Gerg Sknab

    Pate in Citadel is not dead yet

    Pate, possibly Syrio Florel and Phyrio Forel
  12. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Book canon? Lem Yellowcoat and Marrett speaking about a subject that Lem more than likely wasn't present for or a Tyrion chapterthat Tyrion reads as thirdhand information is more canon than Arya, jon and Bran chapters?
  13. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Nah Father Frey making things up. How would the BWB have a clue they wouldn't have been anywhere near the Twins for an extended period what Bolton's men, Frey's men and riverlanders loyal to Freys hanging around. There is more in Jon, Bran, Jamie and Arya chapters in ASOS AFFC and ADWD to consider him alive rather dead
  14. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    And here II figured run ons were fun. In any case Bran's first chapter in ADWD we have anotherpack Lady's dead, maybe Grey wind too but somewhere there's Shaggydog, Nymeria and Ghost remember Ghost. In ASOS a bloodied Grey wolf with yellow eyes is mentioned twice in I believe Jon chapters with the POV first thought of being Greywind then secondarily Summer. Considering Bran iv ASOS they are already north of the wall and accordingly Jon 1 ADWD is unable to sense him north of the wall .
  15. Gerg Sknab

    Poll. is Greywind dead?

    Bran's chapter later on "Lady's dead, maybe Greywind too ghost remember Ghost Shaggydog and Nymeria Hon capther ASOS a bodied grey wolf with yellow eyes no mention of being dead another Jon chapter ASOS again a bloodied grey wolf with yellow eyes first thought is greywind then passes to summer. 4 remained Ghost, Shaggydog, Nyermia, Greywind and one north of the wall Summer