dragonprince Posted March 16, 2015 Share Posted March 16, 2015 It seems like you're just searching for any excuse to blame Catelyn for Robb's decision. First, she may not have even known about Ned's order, and I doubt it would have swayed Robb. Second, whatever strategies Ned had in AGOT were irrelevant at that point - the game had changed. Robb already knew Theon was his father's hostage and chose to release him anyway. The bad results are all on him, not the person who warned him what could happen! :bang: Catelyn did not doom Robb. Releasing Jaime was a boneheaded move on her part, but didn't affect the outcome of the war very much. Robb brought his doom on himself, largely by not listening to his mother do you believe Tywin arranges the RW if Robb still held Jamie hostage? Id have to think Twyin would not risk losing his first son and heir (even though Jamie was KG Twyin was determined to get him out of it) bc surely once Robb dies the blackfish beheads Jamie back at RR Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.