Platypus Rex

Jojen Paste was one of my first "unpopular theory" polls. It was more popular than most I polled, but still unpopular. At least 2/3rds of voters on this forum were against it.

Never said it was great. I have many unpopular theories of my own.

Thank you for your answers. You've certainly gone out on a limb. I don't agree with any of them, though. I will owe you props if any o the above come true. I note now 2 different contradictory Ashara theories associated with the Heresy thread. Does "Heresy" therefore stand for any unpopular theory?

Thanks. I'm familiar with that theory, but did not know it was associated with "Heresy" threads. My own belief is that Septa Lemore is Mellario of Norvos, the wife of Doran. Dunno if that theory is more "heretical" than the Ashara theory.

I tend to avoid Heresy threads, because, from my ignorant perspective, they sound like a lot of smoke and noise signifying nothing. That's what I get from the OP's summary here. "Heresy" signifies everything and nothing. That said, I think it is a lot of fun to go out on a limb with unpopular theories … to go out on a limb with a prediction that actually has a chance of being proven right or wrong in coming volumes (if they are ever released). Can any of the participants in these heresy threads venture one or more simple, definable, and FALSIFIABLE heresy-related propositions that have some reasonable chance of being definitely provable as right or wrong in coming books? Sorry that I lack the patience for reading through a billion heresy posts. And thanks in advance for any answers.