-
Posts
6,807 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Articles
Everything posted by sifth
-
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Martin also lies. His universe is filled with people who are pure evil; Gregor, Joff, Ramsay, The Brave Companions and so on. -
He could also only have girls or be too busy rebuilding the realm to have more children. Just too many variables at play. Ned would be a much more hands on king and not leave the work to his Hand and small council, that’s for sure.
-
Keep in mind, in the timeline you're suggesting Bran isn't born yet and may not be. Only Robb and Jon are born. The other children might not even exist.
-
I imagine Robb would be Prince of Dragonstone. He is Ned's heir. Benjin would likely get Winterfell though.
-
Because we needed a scene where Thrawn lost, yet still claimed it as a win. He basically did this all the time on Rebels and it made him look more stupid each time. Honestly, Baylan is the only interesting character on this show for me and it's because unlike everyone else, he doesn't have plot armor. Thrawn either has to win or escape, so his plot line is predictable. Dave Filoni is too in love with Ahsoka, to kill her off or injure her in any permanent way, so her plot line is predictable. Basically Thrawin is going to either win or escape, but do so in a way, where he wont kill any of the main characters, I'm calling it now. Baylan's plot however, it at least something new and original. Which makes it only more sadder that Ray Stevenson is no longer with us.
-
Load the ship with what and why? Also his strategy was honestly very basic for a so called master strategist. He reminded me of a Naruto villain, "no losing that fight, was actually part of my plan the entire time"; I usually hate BS writing like that.
-
I watched Rebels and didn't get a lot more out of it, because of Ezra, lol
-
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
You’re literally comparing Ned Stark to a Nazi………the most honorable character in the series. You have a rather interesting take on ethics. -
Well that was an episode...............were we suppose to feel something when C3-P0 showed up? Honestly Hera's entire story this season feels like filler or very close to being it. Why does Thrawn even bother fighting Ezra, Sabine and Ahsoka. He could just leave.
-
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
hmmm, you make a logic point. I never thought of it that way. -
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
True, I just thought no living brother, aside from Sam knew about it. -
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
You’re not exactly moral if you let a known criminal go by that logic. His duty was to report to Mormont, he choose dissertation instead. The man swore a vow to serve for life. Violated that vow and was justly killed as a result. -
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
I recall him also changing his mind about it. -
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Ned murdered a man, for breaking the law. Listen, it sucks, but the Brothers of the Night's Watch serve for life. To be honest, that scene never made sense to me; how did Gared get over The Wall, without going to Castle Black first? He's an old man and not a climber and even if he were, he didn't have the equipment to climb The Wall. -
Hollywood STRIKES UPDATE: SAG AFTRA reaches agreement with AMPTP!
sifth replied to Mladen's topic in Entertainment
I suspect the SAG strike will end in the next week or so. Many of the demands of the WGA are similar to the ones the SAG wanted. Also writers are still picketing with the SAG. -
Do you agree that Eddard Stark/Ned is Near Pure Good?
sifth replied to SaffronLady's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Pretty sure the killing of Tyrion was just a bluff. Even Jamie calls him out on it. -
Hollywood STRIKES UPDATE: SAG AFTRA reaches agreement with AMPTP!
sifth replied to Mladen's topic in Entertainment
It likely will be approved. Still there's probably a 1% chance it wont and like you said the SAG is still on strike. So for Hollywood this is a case of one problem down and one to go. -
Do you agree that Petyr Baelish/Littlefinger is Near Pure Evil?
sifth replied to boltons are sick's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Dany is also freeing people from slavery, while Cersei is giving people who know too much to Qyburn and his extracurricular activities. -
She was fighting Darth Maul, lol
-
Do you agree that Petyr Baelish/Littlefinger is Near Pure Evil?
sifth replied to boltons are sick's topic in General (ASoIaF)
He's evil, but he also killed Joffrey................so naturally I have conflicting feelings about him, lol -
Daenerys Targaryen is a better leader than Jon Snow.
sifth replied to Here's Looking At You, Kid's topic in General (ASoIaF)
You're not even trying to sound like a separate person anymore. You're literally using the same spacing mistakes every time you make a post, using a different alt. -
Yea, I didn't enjoy this episode of Lower Decks. It just wasn't all that funny.
-
Daenerys Targaryen is a better leader than Jon Snow.
sifth replied to Here's Looking At You, Kid's topic in General (ASoIaF)
Still doesn't answer why a state would willingly give up it's only means of the defense. The world is filled with many people willing to sack a city, just for the hell of it, especially in George's world. -
Daenerys Targaryen is a better leader than Jon Snow.
sifth replied to Here's Looking At You, Kid's topic in General (ASoIaF)
So who's army is it? I always thought those slavers, were the ones who ruled the city.