Lady Sharya Posted August 15, 2015 Share Posted August 15, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow - CERTAIN of R+L 2. Tyrion Lannister - MOST LIKELY T+J 3. (f)Aegon - NO IDEA Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane - ALIVE 5. Gregor Clegane - UNDEAD 6. Quentyn Martell - DEAD 7. Syrio Forel - DEAD 8. Rhaegar Targaryen - DEAD 9. Jon Snow - ALIVE True identities 10. Hooded man - HALLIS MULLEN (or Robert Glover) 11. The knight of the laughing tree - LYANNA STARK 12. The Harpy - THE GREEN GRACE 13. Coldhands - NO CLUE 14. Azor Ahai - JON OR DANY 15. The Prince that was Promised - JON OR DANY 16. The Valonqar - JAIME LANNISTER True or False 17. Jojenpaste - FALSE 18. Frey pies - TRUE 19. Lemongate FALSE 20. Cercei will burn down KL - NO CLUE I will post the results when I get enough response. If you want to see other theories in the list, write them and put them in it. Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne - IDK True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor - NO Dany goes crazy - NO Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Orphalesion Posted August 15, 2015 Share Posted August 15, 2015 1. Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen, it's not even funny anymore at this point. 2. Joanna and Tywin 3. Everything is possible. 4. Alive, unfortunately 5. Undead, hopefully mindless 6. Dead 7. Who cares? 8. Dead 9. Alive or soon to be undead 10. Mance Rayder 11. Lyanna Stark 12. Who cares? Seriously, who cares? 13. A former member of the Night's Watch 14. Dany or Jon 15. Dany or Jon 16. Jaime 17. Sure, why not. 18. I thought that was confirmed? 19. I still say Dany conflated memories of different childhood homes in Essos, but she never was anywhere near Dorne. 20. If Jaime is the Valonquar this is likely the catalyst. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ChillyPolly Posted August 15, 2015 Share Posted August 15, 2015 > Parentage of... (Father + Mother) > 1. Jon Snow. In the interests of good sport I'll say "Brandon and Ashara." (But really,no opinion. Mom is either Lyanna or Wylla or Ashara. Dad is either Ned or Brandon or Rhaegar.) > 2. Tyrion Lannister In the interests of sport, I'll say "Tywin & Joanna" (no surprises!). No strong opinion. > 3. (f)Aegon I'll go out on a limb and say Young Griff's real parents are Doran Martell and Melario of Norvos. (I should really say "no opinion" but what's the fun in that?) > Alive or dead (or undead?) > 4. Sandor Clegane Alive > 5. Gregor Clegane Undead > 6. Quentyn Martell Alive > 7. Syrio Forel Dead > 8. Rhaegar Targaryen Dead > 9. Jon Snow Alive True identities > 10. Hooded man No opinion, but I'll go with "Mance" in the interests of sport. > 11. The knight of the laughing tree No opinion, really, but I'll guess "Howland Reed" in the interest of sport. > 12. The Harpy No opinion. > 13. Coldhands No opinion; except "Not Benjen". > 14. Azor Ahai Jaime; or at least I believe "Azor Ahai" foreshadows Jaime's emergence as a political leader and champion of the Red God, wielding a red hot flaming sword in his magic golden hand, and practicing human sacrifice of those he used to love. This is a villainous figure, and as such, I have no opinion as to whether it is the "real" Azor Ahai. > 15. The Prince that was Promised No opinion, but see above. To the extent that "Azor Ahai" and "The Prince that was Promised" can be thought as as different figures, ... my only guess would be "not Dany"; but rather "Baby Aegon" (wherever he may be hiding and under whatever guise). > 16. The Valonqar Jaime: by which I mean that Jaime will strangle Cersei; and Maggy's prophesy foreshadows this. > True or False > 17. Jojenpaste Yes, Bran ate Jojen. > 18. Frey pies Yes, Manderly cooked 3 freys in pies and ate them. > 19. Lemongate Yes, the lemon tree outside Dany's window is significant. Yes, this means the House with the Red Door was not in Braavos. Yes, this means Dany is not who she thinks she is - the daughter of the Mad King. > 20. Cercei will burn down KL No. (But KL will burn, nonetheless). > Suggested additions: > Alive or Dead: > Ashara Dayne Dunno, but I'll guess "Alive". > True/False: > Sansa winds up with Sandor Yes, they will meet again. No opinion beyond this. > Dany goes crazy No. At least, she will not end up more crazy than she is now, though things may get worse before they get better. In the end, she "remembers who she is" and becomes more sane. > HS = HR Nothing against the theory, but I have to guess "no". Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SeethemFly Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow - Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark2. Tyrion Lannister - Tywin Lannister and Joanna Lannister3. (f)Aegon - Not 100% sure but probably Illyrio Mopatis and SerraAlive or dead (or undead?)4. Sandor Clegane - Alive5. Gregor Clegane - Undead6. Quentyn Martell - Dead7. Syrio Forel - Dead8. Rhaegar Targaryen - Dead9. Jon Snow - Dead (but will be resurrected)True identities10. Hooded man - Howland Reed (not 100% on this one)11. The knight of the laughing tree - Lyanna Stark12. The Harpy - The Green Grace13. Coldhands - Wight controlled by Bloodraven14. Azor Ahai - (Same as the PtwP and Dragon has three heads = Jon, Daenerys and someone else)15. The Prince that was Promised - (Same as Azor Ahai and Dragon has three heads = Jon, Daenerys and someone else)16. The Valonqar - Jaime LannisterTrue or False17. Jojenpaste - False18. Frey pies - True19. Lemongate - False = was probably in a Braavosi palace that had a tree garden or something.20. Cercei will burn down KL - True Others: Ashara Dayne Alive or Dead - Dead Tysha Alive or Dead - Alive, she's the sailors wife Benjen Stark Alive or Dead - Alive Identity of Daario Naharis - Euron Greyjoy Identity of Roose Bolton - Immortal skin stealer who is just growing Ramsay waiting to harvest some new skin! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Selena Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother)1. Jon Snow R+L2. Tyrion Lannister T+J3. (f)Aegon R+E Alive or dead (or undead?)4. Sandor Clegane dead5. Gregor Clegane undead6. Quentyn Martell dead7. Syrio Forel dead 8. Rhaegar Targaryen dead9. Jon Snow dead......for now ;)True identities10. Hooded man no idea11. The knight of the laughing tree Lyanna12. The Harpy no idea13. Coldhands Benjen14. Azor Ahai TBD15. The Prince that was Promised TBD16. The Valonqar TBDTrue or False17. Jojenpaste F18. Frey pies F( not that they dont deserve it)19. Lemongate F20. Cercei will burn down KL F(she will attempt it...) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Night'sQueen Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow R + L = J 2. Tyrion Lannister Tywin + Joanna 3. (f)Aegon Don't know, don't care. He's fake. Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane Alive 5. Gregor Clegane FrankenMountain 6. Quentyn Martell Dead 7. Syrio Forel Dead 8. Rhaegar Targaryen Dead 9. Jon Snow ALIVE True identities 10. Hooded man Undecided 11. The knight of the laughing tree Lyanna 12. The Harpy the Green Grace 13. Coldhands no one we know 14. Azor Ahai Daenerys 15. The Prince that was Promised Jon The Last Hero Bran 16. The Valonqar Jaime True or False 17. Jojenpaste False 18. Frey pies True 19. Lemongate False 20. Cercei will burn down KL She will attempt, but not succeed ETA: Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne Dead Benjen Stark Alive True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor False Dany goes crazy False HS=HR False (and absurd) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DMC Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 Ah the strange comfort of filling out these lists. It's like the paperwork of this forum... Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow - Rhaegar and Lyanna 2. Tyrion Lannister - Tywin and Joanna 3. (f)Aegon - Pass Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane - Alive 5. Gregor Clegane - Undead 6. Quentyn Martell - Dead 7. Syrio Forel - Alive, but will never be seen again. 8. Rhaegar Targaryen - Even his ashes are dead. 9. Jon Snow - Just needs some Viagra for his resurrection. True identities 10. Hooded man - Never will be addressed 11. The knight of the laughing tree - Lyanna 12. The Harpy - The Green Grace 13. Coldhands - One of the Raven's Teeth/Never will be addressed 14. Azor Ahai - Jon 15. The Prince that was Promised - Daenerys 16. The Valonqar - Jaime Last Hero - Bran True or False 17. Jojenpaste - False 18. Frey pies - True (why is this even controversial?) 19. Lemongate - Super false 20. Cercei will burn down KL - She will try and be thwarted. Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne - Meh, Alive True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor - False Dany goes crazy - False (although crazy is fairly subjective) HS=HR - Super false Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Dragons Hand Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 What is your opinion on the following theories? Having no idea / opinion is a possible answer and will be in the results. Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow: R+L=J 2. Tyrion Lannister: Joanna and somebody 3. (f)Aegon: Serra and Illyrio Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane: Alive 5. Gregor Clegane: Dead, Shadowbaby is Ser Robert Strong 6. Quentyn Martell: Dead 7. Syrio Forel: Alive? 8. Rhaegar Targaryen: Dead 9. Jon Snow: Alive True identities 10. Hooded man: Benjen Stark? That'd be fun 11. The knight of the laughing tree: Lyanna, somehow. 12. The Harpy: Galazze Galare 13. Coldhands: Fellow who was sacrficed in the Winterfell Godswood in Bran's vision 14. Azor Ahai: Daenerys. Maybe Jon gets junior status. 15. The Prince that was Promised: Jon, maybe Daenerys gets junior status 16. The Valonqar: Jaime, perhaps one of the most obvious answers ever, but there you go. True or False 17. Jojenpaste: True, probably. 18. Frey pies: This is contested? True. 19. Lemongate: Fucking hell no. Death to the Illemonati. 20. Cercei will burn down KL: Jaime strangles her before she can. I will post the results when I get enough response. If you want to see other theories in the list, write them and put them in it. Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne: Dead Benjen Stark: Could be either. True identities: The Last Hero: Jon, maybe Benjen. Daario Naharis: Daario Naharis. True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor: Can't see how it could be true. Dany goes crazy: Basic reading comprehension says no. HS=HR: No. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Good Guy Garlan Posted August 16, 2015 Share Posted August 16, 2015 What is your opinion on the following theories? Having no idea / opinion is a possible answer and will be in the results. Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow - Rhaegar + Lyanna 2. Tyrion Lannister - Tywin + Joanna 3. (f)Aegon - Illyrio + Serra Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane - Alive 5. Gregor Clegane - Undead 6. Quentyn Martell - Dead 7. Syrio Forel - Dead 8. Rhaegar Targaryen - Dead 9. Jon Snow - Dead (but soon to be undead) True identities 10. Hooded man - Raynald Westerling or Howland Reed 11. The knight of the laughing tree - Lyanna 12. The Harpy - the Green Grace 13. Coldhands - the Ryswell guy 14. Azor Ahai - Jon 15. The Prince that was Promised - Jon 16. The Valonqar - Don't know True or False 17. Jojenpaste - True 18. Frey pies - True 19. Lemongate - False 20. Cercei will burn down KL - False I will post the results when I get enough response. If you want to see other theories in the list, write them and put them in it. Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne - Dead Benjen Stark - Alive True identities: The Last Hero - Night's King Daario Naharis - Douchebag True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor - Hell, no Dany goes crazy - Yes HS=HR - No Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wolf's Bane Posted August 17, 2015 Share Posted August 17, 2015 What is your opinion on the following theories? Having no idea / opinion is a possible answer and will be in the results. Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow (Ned + The Fisherman's Daughter) 2. Tyrion Lannister (Tywin + Joanna) 3. (f)Aegon (Rhaegar + Elia) Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane (dead) 5. Gregor Clegane (alive) 6. Quentyn Martell (dead) 7. Syrio Forel (dead) 8. Rhaegar Targaryen (dead) 9. Jon Snow (alive) True identities 10. Hooded man (?) 11. The knight of the laughing tree (Lyanna) 12. The Harpy (Green Grace) 13. Coldhands (Benjen) 14. Azor Ahai (Daenerys) 15. The Prince that was Promised (Daenerys) 16. The Valonqar (Edmure Tully) True or False 17. Jojenpaste (?) 18. Frey pies (true) 19. Lemongate (false, the lemon tree's location is insignificant) 20. Cercei will burn down KL (false, KL will be burned because it becomes infested with Wights, not due to Cersei going mad) I will post the results when I get enough response. If you want to see other theories in the list, write them and put them in it. Suggested additions: Alive or Dead: Ashara Dayne Benjen Stark True identities: The Last Hero (Bran) Daario Naharis (he is who he says he is, a Tyroshi sellsword) True/False: Sansa winds up with Sandor (false) Dany goes crazy (false) HS=HR (false) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SnowHeart Posted August 17, 2015 Share Posted August 17, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother) 1. Jon Snow. R+L=J 2. Tyrion Lannister. Tywin and Joanna 3. (f)Aegon. Illyrio and Serra.... He's fake whoever it is Alive or dead (or undead?) 4. Sandor Clegane. Alive as the gravedigger 5. Gregor Clegane. Undead RS 6. Quentyn Martell. Toast 7. Syrio Forel. Dead as hell (unfortunately) 8. Rhaegar Targaryen. So very very dead 9. Jon Snow. Temporarily dead True identities 10. Hooded man. Theon Durden (although Really it's just going to be random soldier #3276) 11. The knight of the laughing tree. Lyanna 12. The Harpy. I honestly don't care anymore 13. Coldhands. Some random undead ranger 14. Azor Ahai. Jon 15. The Prince that was Promised. No one 16. The Valonqar. Jamie (with Brienne as YMBQ) True or False 17. Jojenpaste. False 18. Frey pies. True 19. Lemongate. Please God false 20. Cercei will burn down KL. At least the Red Keep, and Jamie will die trying to stop her Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Monoman32 Posted August 17, 2015 Share Posted August 17, 2015 Parentage of... (Father + Mother)1. Jon Snow- R+l+J2. Tyrion Lannister-Tywin and Joanna3. (f)Aegon- He's a Blackfyre(sadly)Alive or dead (or undead?)4. Sandor Clegane- Alive5. Gregor Clegane- Inbetween life and death(yeah I know it makes no sense)6. Quentyn Martell- Dead7. Syrio Forel-Dead8. Rhaegar Targaryen-Dead9. Jon Snow- Currently dead, but will be resurrectedTrue identities10. Hooded man-Robett Glover11. The knight of the laughing tree-Lyanna Stark12. The Harpy- The Green Grace13. Coldhands- A member of the NW who died while Bloodraven was LC and Bloodraven was able to bind him in someway14. Azor Ahai- Dany15. The Prince that was Promised- Jon (I think TPTWP is more important than AAR)16. The Valonqar- JaimeTrue or False17. Jojenpaste- False18. Frey pies-True19. Lemongate-False, and even if true, I don't think it will have an impact on the story20. Cercei will burn down KL-She will try. She may only burn down part of it or the Red Keep, but I don't think she'll get it all. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.