Jump to content

New Elimination Game, #2: Best TV Show with a Female Lead


honeyed chicken

Recommended Posts

Heal OUAT 

Hurt bewitched 

(plus Helena, Jez bell and Ramsay B included) 

Bewitched 1 (-+- -)

 2. Big Little Lies 7

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

 10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 7 

 16. Once Upon a Time 9(-+-+)

 18. Orphan Black 11(+)

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 12 

21. Sharp Objects 13(+) 

24. The Good Place 

 26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

 28. Veronica Mars 11

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 4 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal Once Upon a Time

Hurt Xena

 

1.  Bewitched 1

 2. Big Little Lies 7

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

 10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 7 

 16. Once Upon a Time 10 (+1

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 12 

21. Sharp Objects 13

24. The Good Place 11

 26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

 28. Veronica Mars 11

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 (-1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, HelenaExMachina said:

Hurt ouat

heal orphan black

 

3 hours ago, RhaenysBee said:

Heal OUAT 

hurt bewitched

 

2 hours ago, Jez Bell said:

Hurt OUAT

Heal Bewitched

 

1 hour ago, Ramsay B. said:

Heal Sharp Objects

Hurt Bewitched

Heal Veronica Mars

Hurt OUAT

1. Bewitched 2 (-+-) 

2. Big Little Lies 7

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14 

7. Gilmore Girls 8

10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 7 

16. Once Upon a Time 7 ( - + - -)

18. Orphan Black 11 (+)

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 12 

21. Sharp Objects 13 (+) 

24. The Good Place 11

26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

28. Veronica Mars 12 (+)

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 4 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The current correct score:

 

1.  Bewitched 0 (-)

 2. Big Little Lies 8(+)

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

 10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 7 

 16. Once Upon a Time 9 (- - +)

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 12 

21. Sharp Objects 13

24. The Good Place 11

 26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

 28. Veronica Mars 12(+)

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was to late....my baby Bewitched :( Anyway, let's continue the game:devil:

Heal Sharp Objects

Hurt UOAT

 

 

2. Big Little Lies 8

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

 10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 7 

 16. Once Upon a Time 8 (-)

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 12 

21. Sharp Objects 14 (+)

24. The Good Place 11

 26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

 28. Veronica Mars 12

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Dolorous Gabe said:

You did this without Forbrydelsen and Happy Valley?

 

I love Buffy, Jessica Jones, Orphan Black and The Handmaid's Tale but they are all inferior works compared to the above pair.

Why weren't you there to nominate them? Your fault.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, RhaenysBee said:

Heal ouat 

hurt marvelous mrs maisel

Hurt OUAT

Heal Prime Suspect

 

2. Big Little Lies 8

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 14 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 6 ( -)

 16. Once Upon a Time 8 (+-)

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 13 (+) 

21. Sharp Objects 14 

24. The Good Place 11

 26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

 28. Veronica Mars 12

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, Annara Snow said:

Why weren't you there to nominate them? Your fault.

Even had I noticed this EG happening at the time of nominations, their absence proves that they wouldn't have won anyway amongst this crowd. Their nomination would have been futile.

Please merely take my words as a recommendation to watch Happy Valley and Forbrydelsen (The Killing).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Meera of Tarth said:

heal Buffy

hurt UOAT

 

51 minutes ago, RhaenysBee said:

Look, for once the score is correct 

heal ouat 

hurt mrs maise 

 

why does everybody hate ouat? are we watching the same thing? 

I don't hate it, I just don't think it's as good as most of the other shows on the list. At least those I've seen, and I've seen 11 of these still remaining (including OUAT). IMO it's not as good as Buffy, Jessica Jones, Sharp Objects, Prime Suspect, The Good Place, Big Little Lies, The Handmaid's Tale or Veronica Mars. 

Heal Buffy

Hurt OUAT

 

2. Big Little Lies 8

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 16 (+2) 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 8

10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 5 ( -)

 16. Once Upon a Time 7 (-+-)

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 13 

21. Sharp Objects 14 

24. The Good Place 11

26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

28. Veronica Mars 12

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, RhaenysBee said:

Look, for once the score is correct 

heal ouat 

hurt mrs maise 

 

why does everybody hate ouat? are we watching the same thing? 

I already said it was decent to start with (though not as good as any of the other contenders imo). But the later seasons (I can't remember exactly which one as I watched all at once so they kind of merged for me. Maybe it was the Frozen storyline, certainly the Brave storyline) were utter tripe, such that I sat out the final two seasons. You are on season 2? Season 3? Atm so your opinion is only based on the better stuff.

Hurt OUAT

Heal Marvelous Mrs Maisel (I'm surprised, I thought you would enjoy this. If you haven't watched it you should, it's by the same person as Gilmore Girls and shares a number of the same stylistic choices and quirks)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal OUAT (the frozen storyline just started, I’m hoping it doesn’t get bad)

hurt mrs Maisel which is the only show left I haven’t heard of before so it’s a victim of the process of elimination 

 

and look at that. Kristoff is whatshisname... errr.... argh... god what’s his name? What’s the name of that person....? the new guy. Damn... Nathaniel! Kristoff is Nathaniel. And aurora is Mary Tudor and Phillip is Wren kingston. It’s all really hilarious. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, RhaenysBee said:

Look, for once the score is correct 

heal ouat 

hurt mrs maise 

 

why does everybody hate ouat? are we watching the same thing? 

In my case....because I have not watched it, and I assumed it was not as good considering that other people was hurting it.

To be frank, the fact that there are many shows that I have not seen makes my choices a little bit random in case of the ones I hurt.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal Sharp Objects

Hurt Gilmore Girls

 

2. Big Little Lies 8

3. Buffy the Vampire Slayer 16 

5. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend 14

7. Gilmore Girls 7 (-)

10. Jane the Virgin 9

11. Jessica Jones 13

14. Marvelous Mrs Maisel 5 (-+)

 16. Once Upon a Time  7(+-)

 18. Orphan Black 11

20. Prime Suspect (UK) 13 

21. Sharp Objects 15 (+)

24. The Good Place 11

26. The Handmaid's Tale 8

28. Veronica Mars 12

30. Xena the Warrior Princess 3 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...