Jump to content

is the Iron Throne the heir of Valyrian Empire


geogus

Recommended Posts

No. The Targ kingdom of Westeros is historically more akin to how a Norse adventurer or chieftain took and settled a small territory (Rollo taking over Normandy), and his descendant conquering a kingdom. Except Aegon I Targaryan, unlike William the Bastard, actually had no marital claim to any parts of Westeros. Also, in the wiki it's referred to as the Valyrian Freehold, not the Valyrian Empire. Apparantly it was never a unified empire, and never had a unified ruler. It was more like a collection of city states, sending dragonlord's off to conquer land to settle as I understand it.



Also, the Targaryans gave up their old Valyrian gods and adapted the faith of the Andals, and in that they mostly resemble again the Norse settlers of Normandy - and Kiev -, who gradually abandonded their own culture and faith and adapted the customs and faith of the people they ruled.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Firstly: Valyria was not an Empire.


Second: Valyrian customs (like incest and slavery) are not accepted in Westeros


Third: By their own words Targaryens are dragons. How can an animal reign over human?





Nobody denies that the Targaryens have the blood of old Valyria, and that they are the rightful owners of te IT.




I think that there are way too many people that deny that.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only significant differences in Westeros pre-Conquest vs. post-Conquest was the consolidation of power in King's Landing and the existence of the Kingsguard. Literally every other part of Westerosi culture, which had existed long before the Targaryens arrived remains intact, with very little of Valyrian imports.

So, no. As people have said, Volantis is the closest thing to a successor to Old Valyria, and even they are a pretty weak imitation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not to hijack the thread but I can't help thinking:



- Westeros = Britain


- Essos = Eurasia


- First Men = Ancient Britons


- Valyria = Rome


- Wo5K = War of the Roses


- Starks = Yorks


- Lannisters = Lancasters


- Dorne = Cornwall


- The Wall = Hadrian's wall


- Wildlings = Scots


- Ironborn = Vikings


- Dothraki = Huns


- Bravoos = Venice


- Volantis = Constantinople


- Ghiscari Empire = Persian Empire


- Summer Islanders = Africans


- Asshai = India


- Yiti = China? (name sounds Chinese for sure)


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah, the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros kept their own culture and customs. The Free Cities (with the exception of Braavos, which was founded by escaped Valyrian slaves) are the cultural successors of the Valyrian Freehold, especially Lys (where the population is mostly of Valyrian descent) and Volantis (which is a direct political continuation of the Freehold).


Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Valyrian FREEHOLD was a Republic of sorts, so no.



Of course, that may very well be beyond the understanding of 99.99 % of the Westerosi, They all seem to have real trouble understanding political systems different from their own: The Small Council treated Dany and Khal Drogo as if the dothraki cared about westerosi feudal "rights", Stannis and Selyse thought that the wildlings had a westerosi-style monarchy, and even Tyrion didn't seem to really understand how Volantene Triarchy works.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...