trgryn-strk-lnstr-mrtell Posted May 2, 2014 Share Posted May 2, 2014 Ok here's where im confused and would appreciate everyone's input.... WW attacks 8000 yrs ago...they are defeated and sent back, Wall's erected. First...if WW can turn humans or even babies in to other WW, then why didnt Azor Ahai or whoever else force every human to be south of the wall? I guess argument could be made that in last 8000 yrs, people who didnt want to be kneelers went back north to be free... second...if theory of Craster's blood being the special/unqiue one to produce WW's is true, and all the new WW are just his sons, think about it...crasters been doing this what...at the most 50 yrs? more likely 30....and no matter how fertile you think he is, he cant have sired more than a hundred sons...does it seem likely that entire WW army would consist of only a 100 of them plus whatever few thousand wights? this does make me think that WW's have similar arrangements with other wildlings, but only a few despicable creatures like craster would agree to keep up a steady supply of sacrificing sons/babies. Keep in mind, WW's have been planing this for a few millenniums! As for his "dont touch my wives", it doesnt have to be anything related to blood purity...he's a selfish, greedy, horny bastard (literally), he wasnt even willing to share his food or drinks if you remember...do you think its unreasonable a man like that would be unwilling to share his wives who also happen to be his daughters (double reasons for protectiveness) third...to whomever thinks Benjen Stark is Night's King...WW's were already attacking aggressively prior to start of book 1, that is what started Mance getting all of them together and those were the reports the NW got before Benjen went on the ranging to find out further information. How could he rise to the leadership of the WW in under 2 years? fourth...does anyone remember if ColdHands explained his motives for helping Bran (almost seemed like he was sent to get Bran from the Wall to BloodRaven, indicating BR somehow communicated with CH and gave him orders or a reason to do it...if that is the case, then the WW's want Bran on their side..unless CH went rouge and decided to help Bran since he might be able to beat the WW's.... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.