Jump to content

ASOIAF Guessing Game XIV - #1 - Most Tragic Character


Lord Lyman

Recommended Posts

Here is the rest of the list from 26 on down:



(position, character, lists, points)



26 Robert Baratheon 5 50


27 Stannis Baratheon 5 49


28 Samwell Tarly 4 43


29 Brandon Stark 5 42


29 Donella Hornwood 4 42


31 Maester Aemon Targaryen 3 41


32 Jaime Lannister 6 40


33 Rhaella Targaryen (Aerys II) 3 36


34 Shireen Baratheon 3 35


35 Cersei Lannister 3 34


36 Grey Wind 2 33


37 Lady 4 32


38 Jon Connington 5 31


39 Bran Stark 3 30


40 Helaena Targaryen 3 28


41 Davos Seaworth 3 27


42 Arys Oakheart 4 26


43 Maester Luwin 2 25


43 Lommy Greenhands 1 25


45 Tommen Baratheon 2 24


46 Gilly 4 23


46 Ygritte 5 23


48 Aegon II Targaryen 2 22


49 Dontos Hollard 2 20


49 Eroeh 2 20


51 Dick Crabb 3 19


51 Aemon the Dragonknight 1 19


53 Brienne of Tarth 3 18


54 Gared 2 16


54 Robert "Sweetrobin" Arryn 1 16


54 Aerys II Targaryen 1 16


57 Rickon Stark 2 15


57 Alannys Harlaw 1 15


57 Danny Flint 1 15


60 Penny 2 13


60 Kyra 1 13


62 Melara Hetherspoon 1 12


63 Mirri Maz Duur 2 11


63 Rhaenys Targaryen (QWNW) 1 11


63 Doran Martell 1 11


66 Merret Frey 1 10


66 Dacey Mormont 1 10


68 Aegon V Targaryen 1 9


68 Kevan Lannister 2 9


68 Danaerys Targaryen 1 9


71 Symon Silver Tongue 1 8


71 Aegor Rivers 1 8


71 Loras Tyrell 1 8


71 The Waif 1 8


75 Stalwart Shield 2 7


75 Beric Dondarrion 2 7


75 Ghost of High Heart 1 7


78 Cleos Frey 1 6


78 Joffrey Baratheon 1 6


80 Myrcella Baratheon 1 5


80 Edmure Tully 1 5


80 Rodrik Cassel 1 5


80 Jory Cassel 1 5


80 Patchface 1 5


80 Rickard Stark 1 5


86 Addam Velaryon 1 4


86 Aegon Frey 1 4


86 Harrenhal Bear 1 4


86 Smallfolk 1 4


90 Hodor 1 3


90 Alester Florent 1 3


90 Miller Boys 1 3


90 Tanselle Too-Tall 1 3


90 Joanna Lannister 1 3


90 Arryk 1 3


90 old women in Dany's Chapter 1 3


97 Baelor "Breakspear" Targaryen 1 2


97 Nettles 1 2 97 Erryk 1 2


97 Free Folk 1 2


101 Donal Noye 1 1


101 Yoren 1 1


101 Edric Storm 1 1


101 Alysanne Targaryen 1 1


101 Jeor Mormont 1 1


101 Tywin Lannister 1 1


Link to comment
Share on other sites

All number ones:


Theon Greyjoy (4)


Catelyn Tully-Stark (3)


Eddard Stark (2)


Rhaegar Targaryen (2)


Elia Martell (1)


Sandor Clegane (1)


Quentyn Martell (1)


Rhaenyra Targaryen (1)


Rhaenerys Targaryen (1)


Lommy Greenhands (1)


Lyanna Stark (1)



Mosts lists:


1 Theon Greyjoy 17


2 Catelyn Stark/Tully 16


3 Eddard Stark 13


4 Elia Martell 12


5 Sandor Clegane 12


6 Quentyn Martell 12


7 Jeyne Poole 11


8 Arya Stark 11


9 Robb Stark 11


10 Viserys III Targaryen 9


11 Tyrion Lannister 8


12 Sansa Stark 8


13 Lyanna Stark 7


14 Jorah Mormont 7


15 Tysha 7


16 Rhaegar Targaryen 6


17 Weasel 6


18 Jaime Lannister 6


18 Maester Cressen 5


20 Oberyn Martell 5


21 Ashara Dayne 5


22 Lysa Arryn/Tully 5


23 Robert Baratheon 5


24 Stannis Baratheon 5


24 Brandon Stark 5


26 Jon Connington 5


27 Ygritte 5


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks guys. I just want to see what all your reactions would be if it was someone other than Theon.



This was a lot of fun hosting and I enjoyed watching you guys go back and forth in your discussions, although I don't mind getting back to the guessing.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Congratulations Bustard :commie:

Nice hosting Lord Lyman

You totally got me with Rickon! I was thinking no way!

I would love to play the IT one next. If we changed it to 'Who we would like to sit the IT' we may get a wider range of people? Just a suggestion. Who is willing to host the next game?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought I'd mention that I have an urge to host a game on Who will sit the Iron Throne? Too few candidates, you say? Read the fine print...

Who will sit the Iron Throne at some point before the end of the series, or be the consort of the monarch on the throne?

With this expanded scope I found I could come up with 20 candidates, not all equally as likely, of course, but with an arguable case for each. Add up the people with a claim based on Baratheon or Targaryean blood, the eligible bachelors and bachelorettes who could help their causes ... and then of course some people think the Iron Throne might simply be claimed by force, which opens it up to various wildcards.

Is anybody interested?

Bumping my game idea. Please say if you're interested.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure - my reason for including consorts was just that I think there are about 6 obvious claimants to the throne. If we had a list of each the bottom ten of each would be diverse, getting on the lists with just a few votes, and hard to guess. Also, some people might end up as consorts or monarch, although that may not be a problem.



I might just put up a sign up list and see how many want to play.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...