Voting for the next ASOIAF Elimination Game

[Q the Cat]

I vote off the following:

Eliminate:

5. Dany staying in Mereen

11. Sansa not leaving with the Hound

12. Mel and her vision ( when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when ever she asks to see PtwP)

14. Catelyn being mean to Jon at Bran’s bedside.

15. Lysa’s coddling of her son, Robert Arryn

16. Lysa refusing to send the soldiers of the Vale to help her nephew Robb

17. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brother’s wedding bed

18. Jeyne Westerling’s mother makes her lose Robb’s baby

22. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar

23. Cersei and Jaime sex in the sept

29. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking he’s going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun

31. Cersei trying to seduce Ned

33. Jorah falling in love with Dany

34. Robert Baratheon’s style of ruling

40. Quentyn trying to woo Danaerys

[Bori]

voting off:

9. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb

11. Sansa not leaving with the Hound

12. Mel and her vision ( when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when ever she asks to see PtwP)

14. Catelyn being mean to Jon at Bran’s bedside

15. Lysa’s coddling of her son, Robert Arryn

16. Lysa refusing to send the soldiers of the Vale to help her nephew Robb

17. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brother’s wedding bed

18. Jeyne Westerling’s mother makes her lose Robb’s baby

19. Mirri Maz Durr telling Dany she won't scream

22. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar

33. Jorah falling in love with Dany

34. Robert Baratheon’s style of ruling

37. Theon not recognizing Asha upon returning to Pyke

39. Khal Drogo falling off his horse

40. Quentyn trying to woo Danaerys

[Annara Snow]

We need to take off 16, not 15, right?
I vote to take off:

5. Dany staying in Mereen
6. Cat releasing Jaime
7. Rob marrying Jeyne*
8. Rob trusting Theon
9. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb
11. Sansa not leaving with the Hound
18. Jeyne Westerling’s mother makes her lose Robb’s baby
16. Lysa refusing to send the soldiers of the Vale to help her nephew Robb
19. Mirri Maz Durr telling Dany she won't scream
23. Cersei and Jaime sex in the sept
25. Robb trusting Walder Frey *
29. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking he’s going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun
33. Jorah falling in love with Dany
35. Balon’s rebellion
39. Khal Drogo falling off his horse
40. Quentyn trying to woo Daenaerys


* I didn't get the impression that he trusted him

Jeyne and Daenerys were misspelled in the original list, BTW.

[lil' ghost]

Jeyne and Daenerys were misspelled in the original list, BTW.

and Robb

[Bori]

Jeyne and Daenerys were misspelled in the original list, BTW.

and Robb

and Arianne.

But Kraznys was spelled correct! :cheers:

[honeyed chicken]

Accepting sign ups for Final Five Survive! Game #4: Facepalm Moments. Pm me with your final five.

[lil' ghost]

I'll submit my picks after the starting 30 are finalized.

same

[honeyed chicken]

Anybody want tally the votes here and present the final 30 facepalm moments?

I'd do it but the sun decided to come out and I have to get to work.

ps

Yeah, I'm not much of a speller/typer. I got Kraznys right only from going to the wiki to check. :)

[Lyanna<3Rhaegar]

Ok if my counting is correct this is how the votes tally:

Facepalm moments

1. Ned telling Cersei he knows everything

2. Oberyn getting too close to the Mountain

3. Cersei arming the faith -1 vote

4. Quentyn trying to tame a dragon

5. Dany staying in Mereen - 5 votes

6. Cat releasing Jaime - 1 vote

7. Rob marrying Jeyne - 1 vote

8. Rob trusting Theon - 1 vote

9. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb 3 votes

10. Ned trusting LF

11. Sansa not leaving with the Hound - 7 votes

12. Mel and her vision ( when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when ever she asks to see PtwP) 3 votes

13. Cersei telling bank of Braavos to go F*** themselves 3 votes

14. Catelyn being mean to Jon at Brans bedside. - 6 votes

15. Lysas coddling of her son, Robert Arryn - 4 votes

16. Lysa refusing to send the soldiers of the Vale to help her nephew Robb - 8 votes

17. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brothers wedding bed 3 votes

18. Jeyne Westerlings mother makes her lose Robbs baby - 7 votes

19. Mirri Maz Durr telling Dany she won't scream - 5 votes

20. Sansa trusting Cersei and telling her of Ned's plan to send the girls north

21. Brandon Stark going to King's Landing and shouting for Rhaegar to come out and die - 1 vote

22. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar - 4 votes

23. Cersei and Jaime sex in the sept - 5 votes

24. Robb trusting Roose Bolton

25. Robb trusting Walder Frey - 1 vote

26. Viserys threatening and insulting the Dothraki all the time

27. Lysa believing that she would get to live happily ever after with Littlefinger

28. Victarion thinking he'll get to wed Daenerys - 1 vote

29. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun - 4 votes

30. Craster taking insult and going after a ranger when hes outnumbered by them 12 to 1

31. Cersei trying to seduce Ned - 2 votes

32. Kraznys the slave factor falling for Danys feigned ignorance of Valyrian - 2 votes

33. Jorah falling in love with Dany - 8 votes

34. Robert Baratheons style of ruling - 5 votes

35. Balons rebellion -4 votes

36. Rhaegar running off with the betrothed daughter of the Warden of the North (Lyanna) - 2 votes

37. Theon not recognizing Asha upon returning to Pyke - 1 vote

38. LF kissing Sansa especially when Lysa might see it - 2 votes

39. Khal Drogo falling off his horse - 7 votes

40. Quentyn trying to woo Dany - 5 votes

41.Arya not naming anybody significant for Jaqen - 2 votes

42.Theon not taking the black / staying in Winterfell with only a couple of ironmen - 2 votes

43.Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived 3 votes

44.Tywin taunting Tyrion (who has a loaded crossbow pointing at him) - 1 vote

45.Stannis not informing Robert about the incest instead sits home brooding - 1 vote

46.Arriane's "Queenmaker" plan

We have a 5 way tie for last to be voted off. #'s 9, 12, 13, 17, & 43

Think we need to vote just for those. I vote to take off #43

[a free shadow]

Off:

1. Ned telling Cersei he knows everything

2. Oberyn getting too close to the Mountain

3. Cersei arming the faith

4. Quentyn trying to tame a dragon

5. Dany staying in Mereen

6. Cat releasing Jaime

7. Rob marrying Jayne

8. Rob trusting Theon

9. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb

10. Ned trusting LF

11. Sansa not leaving with the Hound

12. Mel and her vision ( when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when ever she asks to see PtwP)

13. Cersei telling bank of Braavos to go F*** themselves

14. Catelyn being mean to Jon at Bran’s bedside.

15. Lysa’s coddling of her son, Robert Arryn

16. Lysa refusing to send the soldiers of the Vale to help her nephew Robb

17. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brother’s wedding bed

18. Jeyne Westerling’s mother makes her lose Robb’s baby

19. Mirri Maz Durr telling Dany she won't scream

20. Sansa trusting Cersei and telling her of Ned's plan to send the girls north

21. Brandon Stark going to King's Landing and shouting for Rhaegar to come out and die

22. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar

23. Cersei and Jaime sex in the sept

24. Robb trusting Roose Bolton

25. Robb trusting Walder Frey

26. Viserys threatening and insulting the Dothraki all the time

27. Lysa believing that she would get to live happily ever after with Littlefinger

28. Victarion thinking he'll get to wed Daenerys

29. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking he’s going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun

30. Craster taking insult and going after a ranger when he’s outnumbered by them 12 to 1

31. Cersei trying to seduce Ned

32. Kraznys the slave factor falling for Dany’s feigned ignorance of Valyrian

33. Jorah falling in love with Dany

34. Robert Baratheon’s style of ruling

35. Balon’s rebellion

36. Rhaegar running off with the betrothed daughter of the Warden of the North (Lyanna)

37. Theon not recognizing Asha upon returning to Pyke

38. LF kissing Sansa especially when Lysa might see it

39. Khal Drogo falling off his horse

40. Quentyn trying to woo Danaerys

41.Arya not naming anybody significant for Jaqen

42.Theon not taking the black / staying in Winterfell with only a couple of ironmen

43.Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived

44.Tywin taunting Tyrion (who has a loaded crossbow pointing at him)

45.Stannis not informing Robert about the incest instead sits home brooding

46.Arriane's "Queenmaker" plan

That is my full list :ninja:

[Lyanna<3Rhaegar]

Well if we take A Free Shadow's votes the list looks like this:

Facepalm moments

1. Ned telling Cersei he knows everything

2. Oberyn getting too close to the Mountain

3. Cersei arming the faith

4. Quentyn trying to tame a dragon

5. Cat releasing Jaime

6. Rob marrying Jeyne

7. Rob trusting Theon

8. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb

9. Ned trusting LF

10. Mel and her vision (when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when she asks to see PtwP)

11. Cersei telling bank of Braavos to go F*** themselves

12. Lysas coddling of her son, Robert Arryn

13. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brothers wedding bed

14. Sansa trusting Cersei and telling her of Ned's plan to send the girls north

15. Brandon Stark going to King's Landing and shouting for Rhaegar to come out and die

16. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar

17. Robb trusting Roose Bolton

18. Robb trusting Walder Frey

19. Viserys threatening and insulting the Dothraki all the time

20. Lysa believing that she would get to live happily ever after with Littlefinger

21. Victarion thinking he'll get to wed Daenerys

22. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun

23. Craster taking insult and going after a ranger when hes outnumbered by them 12 to 1

24. Cersei trying to seduce Ned

25. Kraznys the slave factor falling for Danys feigned ignorance of Valyrian

26. Balons rebellion

27. Rhaegar running off with the betrothed daughter of the Warden of the North (Lyanna)

28. Theon not recognizing Asha upon returning to Pyke

29. LF kissing Sansa especially when Lysa might see it

30. Arya not naming anybody significant for Jaqen

31. Theon not taking the black / staying in Winterfell with only a couple of ironmen

32. Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived

33. Tywin taunting Tyrion (who has a loaded crossbow pointing at him)

34. Stannis not informing Robert about the incest instead sits home brooding

35. Arriane's "Queenmaker" plan

We still need to get rid of 5. We have #'s 10, 12, 13, 16, 22, 26, & 32 all tied with 4 votes

I vote to get rid of 10, 12, 16, 26,& 32.

Keeping #'s 13 & 22

[Lord Lyman]

12, 13, 22, 26 and 35,

Number 35 got added to the list after submissions were closed and after some of us already made our suggestions.

[Kobayashi Maru]

yeah this is a go !!!! :) Me very very happy !!! I see HC kept all of my suggestions,love you HC :)

so these are my suggestion what should be out of the list.

hope this helps

BTW 13 was more lough out loud moment than facepalm moment for me :lol:

Facepalm moments
1. Ned telling Cersei he knows everything
2. Oberyn getting too close to the Mountain
3. Cersei arming the faith
4. Quentyn trying to tame a dragon
5. Cat releasing Jaime
6. Rob marrying Jeyne
7. Rob trusting Theon
8. Theon thinking his dad would join Robb
9. Ned trusting LF
10. Mel and her vision (when she says how flames don't work cause she keeps seeing Jon when she asks to see PtwP)
11. Cersei telling bank of Braavos to go F*** themselves
12. Lysas coddling of her son, Robert Arryn
13. King Robert fathering Edric Storm in his brothers wedding bed
14. Sansa trusting Cersei and telling her of Ned's plan to send the girls north
15. Brandon Stark going to King's Landing and shouting for Rhaegar to come out and die
16. Daenerys' decision to wed Hizdhar
17. Robb trusting Roose Bolton
18. Robb trusting Walder Frey
19. Viserys threatening and insulting the Dothraki all the time
20. Lysa believing that she would get to live happily ever after with Littlefinger
21. Victarion thinking he'll get to wed Daenerys
22. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun
23. Craster taking insult and going after a ranger when hes outnumbered by them 12 to 1
24. Cersei trying to seduce Ned
25. Kraznys the slave factor falling for Danys feigned ignorance of Valyrian
26. Balons rebellion
27. Rhaegar running off with the betrothed daughter of the Warden of the North (Lyanna)
28. Theon not recognizing Asha upon returning to Pyke
29. LF kissing Sansa especially when Lysa might see it
30. Arya not naming anybody significant for Jaqen
31. Theon not taking the black / staying in Winterfell with only a couple of ironmen
32. Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived
33. Tywin taunting Tyrion (who has a loaded crossbow pointing at him)
34. Stannis not informing Robert about the incest instead sits home brooding
35. Arriane's "Queenmaker" plan

[honeyed chicken]

yeah this is a go !!!! :) Me very very happy !!! I see HC kept all of my suggestions,love you HC :)

Good. Thanks! & back atcha! :)

The great thing about this list is how many people contributed. You, RhaenysBalerion and I put together the first 36 or so. Here on this thread, 6 or 7 more people have contributed.

"We still need to get rid of 5. We have #'s 10, 12, 13, 16, 22, 26, & 32 all tied with 4 votes"

Of these seven, the five I'd vote off are 10, 13, 16, 22, 32.

[Annara Snow]

Well, if we're voting again, now from this list, can we vote for any of the entries? Or just bolded ones? Because, if it's just for those with equal points, it's not right that me or someone else who's already voted votes again, we'll be contributing two points to the same entry.

If if we're starting from scratch and we can vote for any entry, I vote for:

22. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun
26. Balon's rebellion
32. Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived

and also:

6. Rob marrying Jeyne

18. Robb trusting Walder Frey (like I said, saying he trusted Walder Frey is a real exaggeration; and it's not like anyone was able to predict that WF would go so far to organize a massacre)

Also, there's a mistake in the list - Mel was trying to see Azor Ahai, not Prince that was Promised. The latter is a Targaryen prophecy, the former is the Lord of Light religion prophecy.

[honeyed chicken]

Well, if we're voting again, now from this list, can we vote for any of the entries? Or just bolded ones? Because, if it's just for those with equal points, it's not right that me or someone else who's already voted votes again, we'll be contributing two points to the same entry.

If if we're starting from scratch and we can vote for any entry, I vote for:

22. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun

26. Balon's rebellion

32. Tyrion not sending Shae away after Tywin arrived

and also:

6. Rob marrying Jeyne

18. Robb trusting Walder Frey (like I said, saying he trusted Walder Frey is a real exaggeration; and it's not like anyone was able to predict that WF would go so far to organize a massacre)

Also, there's a mistake in the list - Mel was trying to see Azor Ahai, not Prince that was Promised. The latter is a Targaryen prophecy, the former is the Lord of Light religion prophecy.

There are seven that are tied with 4 votes each for the last two spots. (see post #231) They're #'s 10, 12, 13, 16, 22, 26, & 32 - pick 5 of those to kick out.

[Lyanna<3Rhaegar]

I'm not sure how we should decide which 5 to take off. I'm not the OP was just tallying the votes. The 7 I bolded were all tied so it would make sense to me to o vote 5 of those off but how ever it is decided is fine with me. I would wait & see what HC thinks.

ETA: you ninja'd me HC :ninja: :D

[honeyed chicken]

I'm not sure how we should decide which 5 to take off. I'm not the OP was just tallying the votes. The 7 I bolded were all tied so it would make sense to me to o vote 5 of those off but how ever it is decided is fine with me. I would wait & see what HC thinks.

I think what you did was great (just one player's opinion). It makes sense to me to stick to those seven moments that were tied with 4 votes each and take 5 to eliminate as you suggested.

[Lyanna<3Rhaegar]

I think what you did was great (just one player's opinion). It makes sense to me to stick to those seven moments that were tied with 4 votes each and take 5 to eliminate as you suggested.

Thanks :D

[The Abominable SnowOther]

10 12 16 26 32

:crying: 22. Ser Patrek of King's Mountain thinking hes going to woo & wed Val, but gets pulled apart by Wun Wun

please, no. This was the one I was going to rally under