Jump to content

Bear Claw

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited


About Bear Claw

  • Rank

Recent Profile Visitors

3,277 profile views
  1. Bear Claw

    Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot

    It could be a part of a new pact to get the WW's to go back North.
  2. Bear Claw

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    Murder is commonplace since the beginning of time. She is a cold-blooded mass-murderer. I can't be a fan of that.
  3. Bear Claw

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    What about the Lannister soldiers on the Loot Train battle? Why did she give them the same non-choice she gave the Tarlys? They never swore her or her underlords fealty, yet she demanded their loyalty or be executed on the spot. After the massacre at KL, she didn't even give them a choice, and in fact, they had surrendered already and they were murdered for doing their job. It's not justified, and it's horrible. There is no defense for this action.
  4. That would be awesome! So, no, the show didn't do that.
  5. Bear Claw

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    Executing prisoners was brought up in Season Two when Lord Boton suggested it to Robb. Robb told him he would not execute prisoners, so in show verse, it was certainly something that was considered wrong.
  6. Bear Claw

    GRRM's (Brief) Thoughts on the Final Episode

    Sorry, I was talking about Sansa. The post I was responding to said that Sansa would never have children, but apparently, Sansa views that as an essential quality for a monarch, so I think she will have children out of duty.
  7. Bear Claw

    GRRM's (Brief) Thoughts on the Final Episode

    How could she intend on not having children when she made a point of Bran's unsuitability based on his inability to procreate.? Seems like heirs must be in her plans.
  8. Bear Claw

    Purpose of the wall now ?

    Yes, and the Dothraki Blood Riders are sworn to kill for their leader. I guess they "kinda forgot".
  9. Bear Claw

    Who was Daenerys turned into?

    Her character? What about Jon? Wasn't he supposed to care about innocent people? Wasn't he trying to save the people of Westeros? Yet, even after Dany kills everyone in KL, Tyrion has to be Jon's moral compass because Jon now only cares about Dany.
  10. Bear Claw

    The Wall

    How did Sam get out of the Night's Watch?
  11. Bear Claw

    Season 8: News, Spoilers And Leaks

    Sometimes I wonder about what other people experience in life. In my experience, being a fan often means being disappointed. Of course, there are high points and enjoyable moments, but my teams lose more often than win. This fandom has been very enjoyable for me, and while this alleged ending isn't what I hoped for, I don't think I can complain at all. I do wish that the series had more time and incorporated more of the real story, but the show is still better than most I have seen on TV.
  12. Bear Claw

    This is all Jon’s fault

    I think Jon and the Northern forces will get the blame for supporting her and fighting for her, even if they didn't know she was going to go ballistic. Northern troops were taking part in the war crimes, so yes, he gets some blame. Also, let's not forget that the wight hunt is what allowed the NK to gain access into Westeros, so he had a hand in that as well. I don't see how Jon comes out of this mess with anyone's respect. I see him being given the same option that LF gave to Ned right when King Robert was dying. LF told Ned to take control, but honorable Ned wouldn't do it, and here, Varys gave Jon the option to take control, but honorable Jon wouldn't do it. ETA: Jon seems to be making all of the wrong choices.
  13. Bear Claw

    [Spoilers] Episode 805 Discussion

    Listen to his sister for one thing.
  14. Bear Claw

    [Spoilers] Episode 805 Discussion

    Yes, he went downhill since going to Dragonstone, but this season is even worse.
  15. Bear Claw

    [Spoilers] Episode 805 Discussion

    Very disappointed in Jon. What is wrong with him?