The Game of Thrones Episode Elimination Game.

[brAnthelAstgreenseer]

I dug this out . Last time we had an episodes EG.

http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/90693-asoiaf-elimination-game-li-best-episode-s1-s3/

[Annara Snow]

Dude we did an episodes EG last year . I am sure everyone will agree to do it this year also , if you wait and discuss with them . Please have some patience . GOT is considered as ASOIAF game .

Who cares what game there was a year ago?

[yomi]

Just so you don't miss the other part of the discussion, here is the thread for deciding on the next "official" ASoIaF elimination game, where brAn-romAnov-seer and I now brought the topic up as well: http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/107306-voting-for-the-next-asoiaf-elimination-game/page-17

[Frey Pies]

Thanks guys.

[Annara Snow]

I don't see any reason not to continue this game... We're already voting on a new ASOAIF game.

heal Fire and Blood

hurt The Bear and the Maiden Fair - it has some really nice scenes, but it also has the Theon (literal) torture porn, and this scene:

https://31.media.tumblr.com/e630c1f4f574ee0c93d394ba8e477f05/tumblr_n7jbwm6nkB1rnobf0o1_500.gif

https://31.media.tumblr.com/a35c2e25f11c6f1cf199b48b8b1b8d08/tumblr_n7jbwm6nkB1rnobf0o2_r1_500.gif

https://38.media.tumblr.com/46ad8aabe4f9ad7874530da1cf43cc40/tumblr_n7jbwm6nkB1rnobf0o3_r1_500.gif

1. Winter Is Coming 7

2. The Kingsroad 5

3. Lord Snow 5

4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5

5. The Wolf and the Lion 5

6. A Golden Crown 5

7. You Win Or You Die 5

8. The Pointy End 5

9. Baelor 6

10. Fire and Blood 6 +

11. The North Remembers 5

12. The Night Lands 1

13. What Is Dead May Never Die 5

15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5

16. The Old Gods and the New 5

17. A Man Without Honor 5

18. The Prince of Winterfell 5

19. Blackwater 7

20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5

22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5

23. Walk of Punishment 5

24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6

25. Kissed by Fire 5

26. The Climb 5

27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 4 -

28. Second Sons 5

29. The Rains of Castamere 6

30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5

32. The Lion and the Rose 5

33. Breaker of Chains 5

34. Oathkeeper 5

35. First of His Name 5

36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6

37. Mockingbird 5

38. The Mountain and the Viper 5

39. The Watchers on the Wall 5

40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38.

39.

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Dany Lannister]

Hurt torture porn

Heal 1

1. Winter Is Coming 8+

2. The Kingsroad 5

3. Lord Snow 5

4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5

5. The Wolf and the Lion 5

6. A Golden Crown 5

7. You Win Or You Die 5

8. The Pointy End 5

9. Baelor 6

10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5

12. The Night Lands 1

13. What Is Dead May Never Die 5

15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5

16. The Old Gods and the New 5

17. A Man Without Honor 5

18. The Prince of Winterfell 5

19. Blackwater 7

20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5

22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5

23. Walk of Punishment 5

24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6

25. Kissed by Fire 5

26. The Climb 5

27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 3 -

28. Second Sons 5

29. The Rains of Castamere 6

30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5

32. The Lion and the Rose 5

33. Breaker of Chains 5

34. Oathkeeper 5

35. First of His Name 5

36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6

37. Mockingbird 5

38. The Mountain and the Viper 5

39. The Watchers on the Wall 5

40. The Children 7

[Annara Snow]

heal What Is Dead May Never Die

hurt Bear and the Maiden Fair

1. Winter Is Coming 8+
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 5
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
12. The Night Lands 1
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6 +
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 2 -
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 6
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 5
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 5
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

39.

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[DreamSongs]

Heal Bear and the Maiden Fair

Kill The Night Lands

1. Winter Is Coming 8+
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 5
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
12. The Night Lands 0
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 3+
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 6
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 5
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 5
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Dany Lannister]

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 5
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
12. The Night Lands 0
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 2-
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7+
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 5
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 5
40. The Children 7

[Annara Snow]

heal The Pointy End (was as good as Baelor, just didn't feature a climactic scene like Ned's death)

hurt the torture porn and Marg's bullshitting about how good it is to be forced into a marriage to your enemies at age 14

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6 +
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
12. The Night Lands 0
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
27. The Bear and the Maiden Fair 1-
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 5
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 5
40. The Children 7

[Frey Pies]

So, are we continuing? Sorry again for any confusion caused.

Heal The Watchers on the Wall

Hurt Bear Maiden

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 5
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 5
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 6+
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[K-26dp]

Heal Two Swords, the best season premiere to date.

Hurt Breaker of Chains, and the Jaime/Cersei snafu.

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 7
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6 +
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 4 -
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 6
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Annara Snow]

hurt Breaker of Chains

heal Blackwater

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 5
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8 +
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 3 -
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 5
39. The Watchers on the Wall 6
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[K-26dp]

Heal The Mountain and The Viper because *splat*

Hurt Lord Snow, the weakest of season 1.

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4 -
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 6
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 3
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6 +
39. The Watchers on the Wall 6
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Annara Snow]

Lord Snow had some pretty good original scenes - the best of the original scenes from season 1, I think (not a fan of the Robert/Cersei overrated conversation in one of the following episodes) and I thought it was an improvement over The Kingsroad.

heal Baelor

hurt Breaker of Chains

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 7 +
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 5
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 2 -
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6
39. The Watchers on the Wall 6
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[yomi]

Hurt Walk of Punishment, Heal The Watchers on the Wall

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 5
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 7
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 4 -
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 2
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 5
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6
39. The Watchers on the Wall 7 +
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Dolorous Gabe]

Heal A Golden Crown

Hurt The First Of His Name

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 6 +
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 7
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 5
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 4
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 6
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 2
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 4 -
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6
39. The Watchers on the Wall 7
40. The Children 7

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones

[Ramsay B.]

Heal 24

Hurt 40

1. Winter Is Coming 8

2. The Kingsroad 5

3. Lord Snow 4

4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5

5. The Wolf and the Lion 5

6. A Golden Crown 6

7. You Win Or You Die 5

8. The Pointy End 6

9. Baelor 7

10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5

13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6

15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5

16. The Old Gods and the New 5

17. A Man Without Honor 5

18. The Prince of Winterfell 5

19. Blackwater 8

20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5

22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5

23. Walk of Punishment 4

24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 7+

25. Kissed by Fire 5

26. The Climb 5

28. Second Sons 5

29. The Rains of Castamere 7

30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6

32. The Lion and the Rose 5

33. Breaker of Chains 2

34. Oathkeeper 5

35. First of His Name 4

36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6

37. Mockingbird 5

38. The Mountain and the Viper 6

39. The Watchers on the Wall 7

40. The Children 6-

[yomi]

Heal 24, hurt 16

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 6
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 7
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 4 -
17. A Man Without Honor 5
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 4
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 8 +
25. Kissed by Fire 5
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 2
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 4
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6
39. The Watchers on the Wall 7
40. The Children 6

[K-26dp]

Heal Kissed By Fire, for all the baths.

Hurt A Man Without Honor, for botching Qhorin Halfhand

1. Winter Is Coming 8
2. The Kingsroad 5
3. Lord Snow 4
4. Cripples, Bastards and Broken Things 5
5. The Wolf and the Lion 5
6. A Golden Crown 6
7. You Win Or You Die 5
8. The Pointy End 6
9. Baelor 7
10. Fire and Blood 6

11. The North Remembers 5
13. What Is Dead May Never Die 6
15. The Ghost of Harrenhal 5
16. The Old Gods and the New 4
17. A Man Without Honor 4 -
18. The Prince of Winterfell 5
19. Blackwater 8
20. Valar Morghulis 4

21. Valar Dohaeris 5
22. Dark Wings, Dark Words 5
23. Walk of Punishment 4
24. And Now His Watch Is Ended 8
25. Kissed by Fire 6 +
26. The Climb 5
28. Second Sons 5
29. The Rains of Castamere 7
30. Mhysa 5

31. Two Swords 6
32. The Lion and the Rose 5
33. Breaker of Chains 2
34. Oathkeeper 5
35. First of His Name 4
36. The Laws of Gods and Men 6
37. Mockingbird 5
38. The Mountain and the Viper 6
39. The Watchers on the Wall 7
40. The Children 6

Eliminated:

38. 3.07 The Bear and the Maiden Fair

39. 2.02 The Night Lands

40. 2.04 Garden of Bones