mormont Posted January 24, 2013 Share Posted January 24, 2013 or we can come to logical rationalizations. i find the idea of lyanna competing to be more absurd than the thought that a girl can tweak a story.What's 'logical' about the idea that Meera 'tweaked' the story to make the KotLT short?There is no evidence to suggest that she did so, so there's no logical reason to believe that she did. There is no credible motivation for her to do so, so again, it's not logical to believe she did. And if she did 'tweak' this particular detail, there's no logical reason to believe that any other detail in the story is reliable either.The only 'logical' reason to believe that Meera changed this detail is if you are so desperate that the KotLT should be Ned, you are actually willing to flat out make things up. And once you reach that point, you're beyond reason. There's really not much point in discussing it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.